Mining Law Prevents Public Participation

Fitri Novia Heriani, Pirhot Nababan

Law No. 4 of 2009 on Mining shifted the mining industry paradigm. The industry went from a centralized industry, where the government controlled all licensing for mining activities, to a decentralized industry, where local governments are authorized to grant licenses for mining companies.

Even though this shift was satisfying, civil society criticized the Mining Law for being investor-oriented rather than public-oriented.

Hendrik Siregar, campaigner from the Mining Advocacy Network (Jaringan Advokasi Tambang - Jatam), said that many articles in the Mining Law have shut down public participation in mining business. Therefore, he suspects mining investors interfered in the Mining Law drafting process.

"Not only foreign investors, but also domestic investors," Hendrik said during a seminar titled the Role of Representation in Parliament’s Legislative Function, in Jakarta, Tuesday (17/4).

Hendrik explained that half of the Mining Law only covers licensing issues. There is no article on which companies can obtain mining licenses. The Mining Law only states that a foreign mining company should establish a partnership with a local mining company.

Furthermore, Article 162 of the Mining Law states that any person who hampers mining operations is subject to criminal sanctions or fines. "This article belittles public sovereignty. It is also a criminalization," he asserted.

Hendrik further added that even though Article 145 stipulates that the public can provide input, opinions, and suggestions regarding mining activities, the Mining Law does not elaborate on mechanisms for public participation.

Meanwhile, Roichatul Aswidah, Research Deputy at the Center for Democracy and Human Rights Studies, criticized the lack of transparency in the Mining Law drafting process. Roichatul said that this issue generates two problems: the contradiction between the government regulation on mining, and the delayed Work Contracts adjustment process.

"This happens because the parliament does not have a mechanism to control the issuance of government regulations," Roichatul asserted.

For example, Roichatul explained, the issuance of Government Regulation No. 22 of 2010 on Mining Areas does not have a mechanism for public participation, which is required under the Mining Law.

On the other hand, Alexander Sonny Keraf, former parliament member, denied the accusation. He asserted that the Mining Law drafting process was based on public interests.

Alexander, however, admitted that the Mining Law needs to be improved. For example, public rights to determine mining areas should be included in the law.

Fitri Novia Heriani, Pirhot Nababan

Law No. 4 of 2009 on Mining shifted the mining industry paradigm. The industry went from a centralized industry, where the government controlled all licensing for mining activities, to a decentralized industry, where local governments are authorized to grant licenses for mining companies.

Even though this shift was satisfying, civil society criticized the Mining Law for being investor-oriented rather than public-oriented.

Hendrik Siregar, campaigner from the Mining Advocacy Network (Jaringan Advokasi Tambang - Jatam), said that many articles in the Mining Law have shut down public participation in mining business. Therefore, he suspects mining investors interfered in the Mining Law drafting process.

"Not only foreign investors, but also domestic investors," Hendrik said during a seminar titled the Role of Representation in Parliament’s Legislative Function, in Jakarta, Tuesday (17/4).

Hendrik explained that half of the Mining Law only covers licensing issues. There is no article on which companies can obtain mining licenses. The Mining Law only states that a foreign mining company should establish a partnership with a local mining company.

Furthermore, Article 162 of the Mining Law states that any person who hampers mining operations is subject to criminal sanctions or fines. "This article belittles public sovereignty. It is also a criminalization," he asserted.

Hendrik further added that even though Article 145 stipulates that the public can provide input, opinions, and suggestions regarding mining activities, the Mining Law does not elaborate on mechanisms for public participation.

Meanwhile, Roichatul Aswidah, Research Deputy at the Center for Democracy and Human Rights Studies, criticized the lack of transparency in the Mining Law drafting process. Roichatul said that this issue generates two problems: the contradiction between the government regulation on mining, and the delayed Work Contracts adjustment process.

"This happens because the parliament does not have a mechanism to control the issuance of government regulations," Roichatul asserted.

For example, Roichatul explained, the issuance of Government Regulation No. 22 of 2010 on Mining Areas does not have a mechanism for public participation, which is required under the Mining Law.

On the other hand, Alexander Sonny Keraf, former parliament member, denied the accusation. He asserted that the Mining Law drafting process was based on public interests.

Alexander, however, admitted that the Mining Law needs to be improved. For example, public rights to determine mining areas should be included in the law.

2026 Hak Cipta Milik Hukumonline.com
Cookies Info