A group of 32 individuals and 10 religious organizations recently submitted a petition for judicial review of Law No. 22 of 2001 on Oil and Gas (Oil and Gas Law). The applicants asked the court to review Article 1 (19), Article 1 (23), Article 3 point b, Article 4 (3), Article 6, Article 9, Article 10, Article 11 (2), Article 13, and Article 44.
The applicants argue that these articles contradict Article 28D (1), and Article 33 (2) and (3) of the 1945 Constitution. Furthermore, they assert that the Oil and Gas Law has liberalized oil and gas management by letting foreign parties dominate 89 percent of the Indonesian oil and gas sector, which will affect the people and harm state finances.
“The Oil and Gas Law has undermined state sovereignty and economic sovereignty,” said Syaiful Bakhri, the applicant’s attorney, during a preliminary examination in the Constitutional Court, Jakarta, Tuesday (17/4).
Syaiful argued that the Oil and Gas Law was drafted under pressure from the international community to reform the energy sector, especially oil and gas. “Reforms were not only focused on repealing fuel subsidies, they also allowed international corporations to exploit Indonesian oil and gas business,” he said.
In addition, he stated that Article 1 (19), which defines work contracts, degrades the state’s dignity. Article 1 (19) states that a work contract is a revenue sharing contract or other form of contract in exploration and exploitation, which favors the state and will be utilized for the people’s prosperity.
“Article 1 (19) creates legal uncertainty, especially the phrase ‘other forms of contract’,” he said.
Furthermore, contracts between the Upstream Oil and Gas Activity Agency (BP Migas), which represents the Government, and corporations, always agree to international arbitration, which lowers the state’s position against foreign companies. For example, when the government tried to revise the Oil and Gas Law in 2005, foreign oil and gas companies threatened to challenge the government’s actions through international arbitration.
“The state’s defeat would mean the defeat of the people. That’s the main point of degrading the state’s dignity,” said Syaiful.
He also argued that Article 44 of the Oil and Gas Law, which states that BP Migas has the authority to represent the state in controlling oil and gas production and reserves, has obscured Article 4 (3), which stipulates the concept of BP Migas as a mining authority. Furthermore, BP Migas is not directly involved in oil and gas exploration and exploitation, and it does not have commissioners or supervisors.
According to Syaiful, BP Migas’ lack of oil wells, oil rigs, tankers, gas stations, and inability to ensure domestic fuel supply, has blurred the interpretation of the phrase ‘controlled by the state’ in Article 33 (2) of the 1945 Constitution. “This will lead to unlimited authority which tends to be corrupted,” Syaiful explained.
Hamdan Zoelva, a member of the preliminary examination assembly reminded the applicants to include their signatures in the application. “Several applicants have not signed the application yet, namely Hizbut Tahrir, Pimpinan Serikat Islam, Marwan Batubara, Laode Ida, and Fauziah. This must be completed,” he suggested.
The judicial review petition was filed by the Chairman of PP Muhammadiyah, Din Syamsuddin; the former Chairman of MUI, Amidhan; the former Chairman of PB NU, Achmad Hasyim Muzadi; the former Minister of Manpower and Transmigration, Fahmi Idris; and the Rector of UIN Syarif Hidayatullah, Komarudin Hidayat.
In addition, several religious groups are involved in this petition, including Lajnah Siyasiyah Hizbut Tahrir Indonesia, Persatuan Umat Islam, Al Irsyad-Al Islamiyah, and the Indonesian Moslem Brotherhood.
(Agus Sahbani / Mahinda Arkyasa)
A group of 32 individuals and 10 religious organizations recently submitted a petition for judicial review of Law No. 22 of 2001 on Oil and Gas (Oil and Gas Law). The applicants asked the court to review Article 1 (19), Article 1 (23), Article 3 point b, Article 4 (3), Article 6, Article 9, Article 10, Article 11 (2), Article 13, and Article 44.
The applicants argue that these articles contradict Article 28D (1), and Article 33 (2) and (3) of the 1945 Constitution. Furthermore, they assert that the Oil and Gas Law has liberalized oil and gas management by letting foreign parties dominate 89 percent of the Indonesian oil and gas sector, which will affect the people and harm state finances.
“The Oil and Gas Law has undermined state sovereignty and economic sovereignty,” said Syaiful Bakhri, the applicant’s attorney, during a preliminary examination in the Constitutional Court, Jakarta, Tuesday (17/4).
Syaiful argued that the Oil and Gas Law was drafted under pressure from the international community to reform the energy sector, especially oil and gas. “Reforms were not only focused on repealing fuel subsidies, they also allowed international corporations to exploit Indonesian oil and gas business,” he said.
In addition, he stated that Article 1 (19), which defines work contracts, degrades the state’s dignity. Article 1 (19) states that a work contract is a revenue sharing contract or other form of contract in exploration and exploitation, which favors the state and will be utilized for the people’s prosperity.
“Article 1 (19) creates legal uncertainty, especially the phrase ‘other forms of contract’,” he said.
Furthermore, contracts between the Upstream Oil and Gas Activity Agency (BP Migas), which represents the Government, and corporations, always agree to international arbitration, which lowers the state’s position against foreign companies. For example, when the government tried to revise the Oil and Gas Law in 2005, foreign oil and gas companies threatened to challenge the government’s actions through international arbitration.
“The state’s defeat would mean the defeat of the people. That’s the main point of degrading the state’s dignity,” said Syaiful.
He also argued that Article 44 of the Oil and Gas Law, which states that BP Migas has the authority to represent the state in controlling oil and gas production and reserves, has obscured Article 4 (3), which stipulates the concept of BP Migas as a mining authority. Furthermore, BP Migas is not directly involved in oil and gas exploration and exploitation, and it does not have commissioners or supervisors.
According to Syaiful, BP Migas’ lack of oil wells, oil rigs, tankers, gas stations, and inability to ensure domestic fuel supply, has blurred the interpretation of the phrase ‘controlled by the state’ in Article 33 (2) of the 1945 Constitution. “This will lead to unlimited authority which tends to be corrupted,” Syaiful explained.
Hamdan Zoelva, a member of the preliminary examination assembly reminded the applicants to include their signatures in the application. “Several applicants have not signed the application yet, namely Hizbut Tahrir, Pimpinan Serikat Islam, Marwan Batubara, Laode Ida, and Fauziah. This must be completed,” he suggested.
The judicial review petition was filed by the Chairman of PP Muhammadiyah, Din Syamsuddin; the former Chairman of MUI, Amidhan; the former Chairman of PB NU, Achmad Hasyim Muzadi; the former Minister of Manpower and Transmigration, Fahmi Idris; and the Rector of UIN Syarif Hidayatullah, Komarudin Hidayat.
In addition, several religious groups are involved in this petition, including Lajnah Siyasiyah Hizbut Tahrir Indonesia, Persatuan Umat Islam, Al Irsyad-Al Islamiyah, and the Indonesian Moslem Brotherhood.
(Agus Sahbani / Mahinda Arkyasa)