The Legislative Body of the House of Representatives (Baleg DPR) has finished a Draft Bill on the Supreme Court. The House, declared that the Draft Bill was a House initiative during the plenary session (rapat paripurna), Thursday (12/4). The Draft Bill will be discussed further with the government.
"Since the Law on the Supreme Court has been amended three times, this is a replacement of the previous law, not an amendment," said Ignatius Mulyono, Chairman of the Baleg DPR.
Ignatius explained that one of most important provisions in the Draft Bill is the provision that imposes administrative and criminal sanctions on any judge who issues an incorrect decision.
This provision is intended to improve judges’ professionalism when examining and deciding cases. "Judges can also be a subject to criminal sanctions. If a judge uses the wrong legal basis for his decision on purpose, then he could receive an administrative sanction, or even a criminal sanction," he emphasized.
He also stated that criminal sanctions are not intended to hamper a judge’s independence when examining and deciding cases. "This is meant to improve judges’ professionalism when making a decision, considering the important position of judges," he explained.
However, based on hukumonline’s observations, a provision on criminal sanctions for judges was not included in the draft that was approved at the plenary session. This fact made Nudirman Munir, a member of Baleg DPR from the Golkar Party, furious.
Nudirman said that the articles which contained criminal sanctions for judges suddenly disappeared from the Draft Bill. In fact, he asserted that this section had been agreed upon in the Baleg DPR. "House leaders even agreed to include the provisions on the criminal sanctions in the draft," he said.
Meanwhile, Todung Mulya Lubis, Chairman of the Indonesian Advocates Association (Ikadin), said there should be very strong evidenciary requirement for proving that a judge used in incorrect legal basis for a decision. For example, whether the judge intentionally made the wrong decision—conspiracy or violated the code of conduct—should be considered to prove a judge’s fault.
"I don’t entirely agree with the criminalization of judges, unless, there is strong evidence such as if a judge is caught red-handed. But, for those who unintentionally make a bad decision, I think it is enough to impose an administrative sanction. Dismissal of a judge is a very harsh punishment," Todung said.
The concept of imposing liability on judges for their decisions is not new. AW Jongbloed, a professor of Law from the University of Utrecht Netherlands, explained the concept of judicial liability, and that it has been implemented in European countries and the United States.
Based on this concept, for example, a party in a civil case may claim damages against judges who issue incorrect decisions that result in losses to that party. There are different damages or compensation concepts for judges in many countries. The damages can be paid by the judge or the state, depending on the country’s law.
But it should be noted that Supreme Court Circular Letter No. 9 of 1976 states that a judge is not legally responsible for decisions that he makes.
(Ali Salmande / Batara Parlindungan)