Ludmilla Arief feels tricked after she bought a Nissan car last March. Nissan advertised the car as fuel efficient, but after driving the car, Ludmilla grew suspicious about the advertisement’s claims.
According to the advertisement, the car has a fuel consumption ratio of 21.8 kilometers per liter, which makes it very economical. However, after testing it for a month, she finally found out that the actual ratio was 7.9 to 8.2 kilometers per liter.
Ludmilla took her test results to the Nissan Warung Buncit and Nissan Halim showrooms, which conducted three tests to follow up on Ludmilla’s report.
However, the reports did not satisfy Ludmilla, so she took the case to the Consumer Dispute Settlement Board (BPSK). On 16 February 2012, BPSK held that Nissan Motor Indonesia (NMI) violated Article 9 (1) (k) and Article 10 (c) of Law No. 8 of 1999 on Consumer Protection and ordered NMI to pay IDR 150 million to Ludmilla.
The dispute continued when NMI took the case to court and asked the court to overturn the BPSK decision.
David ML Tobing, Ludmilla’s attorney, insists the court has to reject NMI’s objection and affirm the BPSK decision. David explained that NMI’s advertising was intended to mislead his client.
“No specific terms and conditions were included in the previous advertisement. But Nissan suddenly revised it by adding ‘combination route’ and ‘eco-driving’. This is just manipulation,” David said after the trial in the South Jakarta District Court, Tuesday (10/4).
David’s statement, however, was rebutted by Hinca Pandjaitan, NMI’s attorney. Hinca argued that the advertisement was consistent and not misleading. “The Nissan advertisement was true when it included data and references. Advertisement is a method to influence people,” he argued.
(Rofiq Hidayat / Mahinda Arkyasa)
Ludmilla Arief feels tricked after she bought a Nissan car last March. Nissan advertised the car as fuel efficient, but after driving the car, Ludmilla grew suspicious about the advertisement’s claims.
According to the advertisement, the car has a fuel consumption ratio of 21.8 kilometers per liter, which makes it very economical. However, after testing it for a month, she finally found out that the actual ratio was 7.9 to 8.2 kilometers per liter.
Ludmilla took her test results to the Nissan Warung Buncit and Nissan Halim showrooms, which conducted three tests to follow up on Ludmilla’s report.
However, the reports did not satisfy Ludmilla, so she took the case to the Consumer Dispute Settlement Board (BPSK). On 16 February 2012, BPSK held that Nissan Motor Indonesia (NMI) violated Article 9 (1) (k) and Article 10 (c) of Law No. 8 of 1999 on Consumer Protection and ordered NMI to pay IDR 150 million to Ludmilla.
The dispute continued when NMI took the case to court and asked the court to overturn the BPSK decision.
David ML Tobing, Ludmilla’s attorney, insists the court has to reject NMI’s objection and affirm the BPSK decision. David explained that NMI’s advertising was intended to mislead his client.
“No specific terms and conditions were included in the previous advertisement. But Nissan suddenly revised it by adding ‘combination route’ and ‘eco-driving’. This is just manipulation,” David said after the trial in the South Jakarta District Court, Tuesday (10/4).
David’s statement, however, was rebutted by Hinca Pandjaitan, NMI’s attorney. Hinca argued that the advertisement was consistent and not misleading. “The Nissan advertisement was true when it included data and references. Advertisement is a method to influence people,” he argued.
(Rofiq Hidayat / Mahinda Arkyasa)