Government Action is Illegal, Expert Says

 

Mudrajad Kuncoro, an economics and business professor at Universitas Gajah Mada, testified before the Constitutional Court during a trial concerning the purchase of PT Newmont Nusa Tenggara (NNT) divestment shares, Tuesday (9/4). Mudrajad stated that the state institutions dispute resolution process (SKLN) should not delay NNT’s divestment process.
 
He warned that “this dispute will give foreign parties an advantage and make the investment climate uncertain,” during the SKLN trial. 
 
The SKLN trial addresses a dispute between the government, represented by the Indonesia Investment Agency (Pusat Investasi Pemerintah - PIP), and the Supreme Audit Agency (BPK) and the House of Representatives. The House claims PIP’s purchase of seven percent of NNT shares was illegal.
 
In House letters No. PW.01/9333/DPR-RI/X/2011 and No. AG/9314/DPR-RI/X/2011, dated 28 October 201, the House states that the purchase was carried out without House approval. 
 
According to Articles 14 (1) and 15 (5) of Law No. 17 of 2003 on State Finances (State Finances Law), ministry/institution budget plans have to be included in the State Budget, which is approved by the House. 
 
Therefore, PIP as a public service agency (badan layanan umum – BLU), has to seek approval from the House for the purchse. “PIP revenue is categorized as non-tax government revenue,” said Mudrajad, who represented the House as an expert.
 
Furthermore, Law No. 41 of 2008 on the 2009 State Budget and Law No. 47 of 2009 on the 2010 State Budget state that funds used by PIP have to be discussed with related Commissions of the House. In this case, PIP should have discussed the purchase with Commission XI. 
 
“Former Minister of Finance Sri Mulyani once requested the House’s permission to buy back state-owned company shares through PIP during the 2008 global economic crisis,” he said.
 
Mudrajad, however, admitted that Article 41 of Law No. 41 of 2004 on State Treasury allows the government to make long term investments by buying shares and bonds as well as making direct investments. Short term investment is regulated under Government Regulation No. 1 of 2008 on Government Investment.
 
In terms of direct investment, Mudrajad asserted that the government can only make direct investments in publicly listed companies. NNT is not yet a listed company, so Mudrajad pointed out that it would be “strange if the government is allowed to invest in non-listed companies by issuing Minister of Finance Regulation No. 44 of 2011, which states that government investment is not limited to listed companies”. 
 
OC Kaligis, who represented BPK as an expert, also supported Mudrajad’s opinion. He stated that the investment made by PIP without House approval is an act of misfeasance, because it contradicts BPK’s report. 
 
BPK’s report stated that the government investment in NNT should be included in a government regulation, after House approval. However, the government failed to comply with BPK’s report, even though this requirement is mandated under Article 23 (3) of the 1945 Constitution.
 
The government, as the applicant, is asking the Constitutional Court to declare that it has the authority to purchase seven percent of PT NNT shares in accordance with Articles 4 (1), 17 (1), 32C, and 33 (3) of the 1945 Constitution.
 
(Agus Sahbani / Mahinda Arkyasa)

 

Mudrajad Kuncoro, an economics and business professor at Universitas Gajah Mada, testified before the Constitutional Court during a trial concerning the purchase of PT Newmont Nusa Tenggara (NNT) divestment shares, Tuesday (9/4). Mudrajad stated that the state institutions dispute resolution process (SKLN) should not delay NNT’s divestment process.
 
He warned that “this dispute will give foreign parties an advantage and make the investment climate uncertain,” during the SKLN trial. 
 
The SKLN trial addresses a dispute between the government, represented by the Indonesia Investment Agency (Pusat Investasi Pemerintah - PIP), and the Supreme Audit Agency (BPK) and the House of Representatives. The House claims PIP’s purchase of seven percent of NNT shares was illegal.
 
In House letters No. PW.01/9333/DPR-RI/X/2011 and No. AG/9314/DPR-RI/X/2011, dated 28 October 201, the House states that the purchase was carried out without House approval. 
 
According to Articles 14 (1) and 15 (5) of Law No. 17 of 2003 on State Finances (State Finances Law), ministry/institution budget plans have to be included in the State Budget, which is approved by the House. 
 
Therefore, PIP as a public service agency (badan layanan umum – BLU), has to seek approval from the House for the purchse. “PIP revenue is categorized as non-tax government revenue,” said Mudrajad, who represented the House as an expert.
 
Furthermore, Law No. 41 of 2008 on the 2009 State Budget and Law No. 47 of 2009 on the 2010 State Budget state that funds used by PIP have to be discussed with related Commissions of the House. In this case, PIP should have discussed the purchase with Commission XI. 
 
“Former Minister of Finance Sri Mulyani once requested the House’s permission to buy back state-owned company shares through PIP during the 2008 global economic crisis,” he said.
 
Mudrajad, however, admitted that Article 41 of Law No. 41 of 2004 on State Treasury allows the government to make long term investments by buying shares and bonds as well as making direct investments. Short term investment is regulated under Government Regulation No. 1 of 2008 on Government Investment.
 
In terms of direct investment, Mudrajad asserted that the government can only make direct investments in publicly listed companies. NNT is not yet a listed company, so Mudrajad pointed out that it would be “strange if the government is allowed to invest in non-listed companies by issuing Minister of Finance Regulation No. 44 of 2011, which states that government investment is not limited to listed companies”. 
 
OC Kaligis, who represented BPK as an expert, also supported Mudrajad’s opinion. He stated that the investment made by PIP without House approval is an act of misfeasance, because it contradicts BPK’s report. 
 
BPK’s report stated that the government investment in NNT should be included in a government regulation, after House approval. However, the government failed to comply with BPK’s report, even though this requirement is mandated under Article 23 (3) of the 1945 Constitution.
 
The government, as the applicant, is asking the Constitutional Court to declare that it has the authority to purchase seven percent of PT NNT shares in accordance with Articles 4 (1), 17 (1), 32C, and 33 (3) of the 1945 Constitution.
 
(Agus Sahbani / Mahinda Arkyasa)
2026 Hak Cipta Milik Hukumonline.com
Cookies Info