Labor Ministry: Foreigners Can Still be CEOs

The Ministry of Labor and Transmigration is busy handling complaints and questions about a restriction that prohibits foreigners from holding the Chief Executive Officer (CEO) position in an Indonesian company.

The restriction is stipulated in the recently issued Minister of Labor and Transmigration Decree No. 40 of 2012 on Restricted Positions for Foreign Workers, and has raised concerns, because foreigners hold the top position in many companies in Indonesia.

Djimanto, Chairman of the Indonesian Business Association (Apindo), asserted that the Regulation will disturb the Indonesian investment climate, and will lead many  investors to ‘pull the plug’.

However, Muhaimin Iskandar, Minister of Labor and Transmigration, explained that the CEO position refered to in the Decree is not the highest management position.

“What we mean by CEO is the head of the office who manages human resources and administration, not the highest management position,” he explained.

Furthermore, Sunarno, the Head of the Legal Bureau at the Ministry of Labor and Transmigration (the Ministry), explained that Indonesian laws do not acknowledge the term CEO.

However, in common language, the term usually refers to the highest management position in a company.

He also explained that the Ministry referred to the International Standard Classification of Occupations (ISCO) code when it used the term ‘CEO’ in the Decree. Under the ISCO, a CEO  is a human resources and administration manager.

Lack of Supervision

Rieke Dyah Pitaloka, a member of Commission IX of the House of Representatives, argued that the restriction is necessary to prevent conflicts in the office or at work sites.  

To emphasize her point, she cited the Drydock Case in Batam, where conflicts arose after foreign workers violated the Labor Law.

She also doubted whether the Decree can be implemented, since there are not enough supervisors. For example, in the Drydock case, there were only four supervisors to oversee all the companies in Batam.

“No matter how good the Decree is, it can’t be implemented without supervision and law enforcement,” she said to hukumonline, Sunday (11/3).

On the other hand, Syamsul Bahri, the Head of the Labor Norms Evaluation Sub-directorate at the Ministry, explained that supervisors will monitor violations related to foreign workers.

“There are 1.400 supervisors in Indonesia,” Syamsul said to hukumonline, Monday (12/3).

He also said that foreign workers often shift positions without authority. For example, a foreign worker may start off in a marketing position, but in the long run his/her position may be shifted to another department.

Sometimes, a foreign worker does even not work at a company that is permitted by the Ministry.

Syamsul also asserted that if a foreign worker violates labor laws and regulations, he/she will be fired from the company and may not work for any Indonesian company. Foreigners may even be deported.

(Ady Thea Dian Achmad / Mahinda Arkyasa)

The Ministry of Labor and Transmigration is busy handling complaints and questions about a restriction that prohibits foreigners from holding the Chief Executive Officer (CEO) position in an Indonesian company.

The restriction is stipulated in the recently issued Minister of Labor and Transmigration Decree No. 40 of 2012 on Restricted Positions for Foreign Workers, and has raised concerns, because foreigners hold the top position in many companies in Indonesia.

Djimanto, Chairman of the Indonesian Business Association (Apindo), asserted that the Regulation will disturb the Indonesian investment climate, and will lead many  investors to ‘pull the plug’.

However, Muhaimin Iskandar, Minister of Labor and Transmigration, explained that the CEO position refered to in the Decree is not the highest management position.

“What we mean by CEO is the head of the office who manages human resources and administration, not the highest management position,” he explained.

Furthermore, Sunarno, the Head of the Legal Bureau at the Ministry of Labor and Transmigration (the Ministry), explained that Indonesian laws do not acknowledge the term CEO.

However, in common language, the term usually refers to the highest management position in a company.

He also explained that the Ministry referred to the International Standard Classification of Occupations (ISCO) code when it used the term ‘CEO’ in the Decree. Under the ISCO, a CEO  is a human resources and administration manager.

Lack of Supervision

Rieke Dyah Pitaloka, a member of Commission IX of the House of Representatives, argued that the restriction is necessary to prevent conflicts in the office or at work sites.  

To emphasize her point, she cited the Drydock Case in Batam, where conflicts arose after foreign workers violated the Labor Law.

She also doubted whether the Decree can be implemented, since there are not enough supervisors. For example, in the Drydock case, there were only four supervisors to oversee all the companies in Batam.

“No matter how good the Decree is, it can’t be implemented without supervision and law enforcement,” she said to hukumonline, Sunday (11/3).

On the other hand, Syamsul Bahri, the Head of the Labor Norms Evaluation Sub-directorate at the Ministry, explained that supervisors will monitor violations related to foreign workers.

“There are 1.400 supervisors in Indonesia,” Syamsul said to hukumonline, Monday (12/3).

He also said that foreign workers often shift positions without authority. For example, a foreign worker may start off in a marketing position, but in the long run his/her position may be shifted to another department.

Sometimes, a foreign worker does even not work at a company that is permitted by the Ministry.

Syamsul also asserted that if a foreign worker violates labor laws and regulations, he/she will be fired from the company and may not work for any Indonesian company. Foreigners may even be deported.

(Ady Thea Dian Achmad / Mahinda Arkyasa)

2026 Hak Cipta Milik Hukumonline.com
Cookies Info