The Indonesian Nickel Association (Asosiasi Nikel Indonesia – ANI) is arguing that Minister of Energy and Mineral Resources (ESDM) Regulation No. 7 of 2012 on Increasing the Value-Added to Minerals Through Processing and Refining (“Regulation”) contradicts higher regulations.
Shelby Ihsan Saleh, Chairman of ANI, said that mining businesses and local governments urged the Government to postpone implementation of the Regulation.
“If the government insists on implementing the regulation, we will take legal action, either collectively or individually,” said Shelby during a discussion, titled “Legal, Local Government, and Business Perspectives on Minister of ESDM Regulation No. 7 of 2012” in Jakarta, Sunday (11/3).
Businesses and local government officials asserted that the Regulation was a government effort to take over local government. Shelby also argued that it contradicts Law No. 32 of 2004 on Regional Government.
He also added that the Regulation would create overlapping authority between the government and local governments.
Furthermore, Shelby highlighted some articles in the Regulation that will result in legal uncertainty for businesses. The first article he highlighted was Article 8 (4), which states that Special Production Operation Mining Business Permits (IUP Operasi Produksi Khusus) for processing and refining have to be issued by the Directorate General of Minerals and Coal on behalf of the Minister of ESDM, Governor, or Mayor/Regent.
He also highlighted Article 21, which forbids Mining License holders from selling raw minerals or mineral ores to foreign countries, starting three months after the regulation was issued.
Shelby asserted that these articles are problematic because they contradict Article 14 (1) (m) and Article 14 (2) of the Regional Government Law. Article 14 (1) (m) states that capital investment administration businesses within a Regent/City—which includes license/permit issuance—fall within regional governments’ authority.
“We hoped the Government would understand the loss caused by the ESDM Regulation,” he said.
Ryaas Rasyid, an expert on regional governance, supports Shelby’s statement and the decision to take legal action. The Regulation, Ryaas said, will result in unemployment.
“I advise local governments, businesses, and the Indonesian Chamber of Commerce and Industry [Kadin] to submit a legal action to the Supreme Court, don’t just review it,” he said at the same event.
Furthermore, Natsir Mansyur, Kadin Deputy Chairman for the Trade Distribution and Logistics Division, also said that Kadin’s branches disagree with the ESDM Regulation, especially Article 21.
“This Article stipulates that half-processed minerals can’t be exported, and that will harm businesses,” he explained.
Fadli Ibrahim, Head of the Laws and Regulations Bureau at the Ministry of ESDM, responded to Kadin’s complaint by explaining that Article 21 was based on exports, which have increased 800 fold since the issuance of Law No. 4 of 2009 on Mineral and Coal Mining. He also explained that it was the Ministry of Trade’s suggestion.
Previously, Fadli also explained that mine products are non-renewable resources, and mineral ore exports will be prohibited when the Regulation enters into force on 7 May 2012.
(M Agus Yozami / Mahinda Arkyasa)
The Indonesian Nickel Association (Asosiasi Nikel Indonesia – ANI) is arguing that Minister of Energy and Mineral Resources (ESDM) Regulation No. 7 of 2012 on Increasing the Value-Added to Minerals Through Processing and Refining (“Regulation”) contradicts higher regulations.
Shelby Ihsan Saleh, Chairman of ANI, said that mining businesses and local governments urged the Government to postpone implementation of the Regulation.
“If the government insists on implementing the regulation, we will take legal action, either collectively or individually,” said Shelby during a discussion, titled “Legal, Local Government, and Business Perspectives on Minister of ESDM Regulation No. 7 of 2012” in Jakarta, Sunday (11/3).
Businesses and local government officials asserted that the Regulation was a government effort to take over local government. Shelby also argued that it contradicts Law No. 32 of 2004 on Regional Government.
He also added that the Regulation would create overlapping authority between the government and local governments.
Furthermore, Shelby highlighted some articles in the Regulation that will result in legal uncertainty for businesses. The first article he highlighted was Article 8 (4), which states that Special Production Operation Mining Business Permits (IUP Operasi Produksi Khusus) for processing and refining have to be issued by the Directorate General of Minerals and Coal on behalf of the Minister of ESDM, Governor, or Mayor/Regent.
He also highlighted Article 21, which forbids Mining License holders from selling raw minerals or mineral ores to foreign countries, starting three months after the regulation was issued.
Shelby asserted that these articles are problematic because they contradict Article 14 (1) (m) and Article 14 (2) of the Regional Government Law. Article 14 (1) (m) states that capital investment administration businesses within a Regent/City—which includes license/permit issuance—fall within regional governments’ authority.
“We hoped the Government would understand the loss caused by the ESDM Regulation,” he said.
Ryaas Rasyid, an expert on regional governance, supports Shelby’s statement and the decision to take legal action. The Regulation, Ryaas said, will result in unemployment.
“I advise local governments, businesses, and the Indonesian Chamber of Commerce and Industry [Kadin] to submit a legal action to the Supreme Court, don’t just review it,” he said at the same event.
Furthermore, Natsir Mansyur, Kadin Deputy Chairman for the Trade Distribution and Logistics Division, also said that Kadin’s branches disagree with the ESDM Regulation, especially Article 21.
“This Article stipulates that half-processed minerals can’t be exported, and that will harm businesses,” he explained.
Fadli Ibrahim, Head of the Laws and Regulations Bureau at the Ministry of ESDM, responded to Kadin’s complaint by explaining that Article 21 was based on exports, which have increased 800 fold since the issuance of Law No. 4 of 2009 on Mineral and Coal Mining. He also explained that it was the Ministry of Trade’s suggestion.
Previously, Fadli also explained that mine products are non-renewable resources, and mineral ore exports will be prohibited when the Regulation enters into force on 7 May 2012.
(M Agus Yozami / Mahinda Arkyasa)