Mining Provisions Could Reduce Revenue

Mining businesses are criticizing Minister of Energy and Mineral Resources (ESDM) Regulation No. 7 of 2012 on Increasing Value-Added Minerals Through Processing and Refining, saying some provisions could shut down medium to small sized enterprises.

Natsir Mansyur, Deputy Chairman of the Indonesian Chamber of Commerce and Industry (Kadin), said that the Minister of ESDM Jero Wacik should revise Article 21 of the Regulation. Otherwise, the country will lose about 20 percent of its revenue, or about USD 46 billion based on export revenue projections for 2012.

Article 21 of the regulation forbids Mining License holders from selling raw minerals or mineral ores to foreign countries, starting three months after the regulation was issued. “This means our mining products can’t be exported and this could hurt the export target,” he said, Tuesday (6/3).

Natsir further explained that Kadin fully supports increasing the value-added to minerals through processing and refining. However, Law No. 4 of 2009 on Minerals and Coal (Mining Law) states that exporting mineral commodities is allowed until 2014. “There is a contradiction between the law and the regulation,” he asserted.

Bambang Sujagad, Deputy Chairman of Kadin for Industry Research and Technology, also added that the government should protect mining businesses that generate revenue for the country. “The government should come up with a solution to attain legal certainty, which doesn’t exist in the regulation,” Bambang said.

On the other hand, Fadli Ibrahim, Head of the Legal Bureau at the Ministry of ESDM, explained that Article 21 was the Ministry of Trade’s idea. Article 21 was based on export records, which show that there has been an 800 fold increase since the Mining Law was issued.

Article 21 may not be the only controversial article in the regulation. Fadli predicts that Articles 4 to 6, which regulate processing and refining mining products, will also be criticized by businesses. However, issues with these articles can be averted through combined efforts with bigger mining companies, as mandated by the Mining Law.

Meanwhile, Edy Prasodjo, Director of Coal Businesses Development at the Ministry of ESDM, said Article 21 recognizes that there is a limited amount of natural resources and is based on a commitment between the Ministry of ESDM and other related ministries. He also said that Article 21 is a shock therapy for businesses. “Policies can’t indulge everyone, an impact was to be expected,” he said.

Syahrir AB, Executive Director of the Indonesian Mining Association, also objected to the regulation. He argued that it will be hard to implement, and recommended issuing the regulation as a government regulation. “The ideas in the regulation are good, but the conditions need to be considered,” he concluded.

(Fitri Novia Heriani / M Agus Yozami / Mahinda Arkyasa)

Mining businesses are criticizing Minister of Energy and Mineral Resources (ESDM) Regulation No. 7 of 2012 on Increasing Value-Added Minerals Through Processing and Refining, saying some provisions could shut down medium to small sized enterprises.

Natsir Mansyur, Deputy Chairman of the Indonesian Chamber of Commerce and Industry (Kadin), said that the Minister of ESDM Jero Wacik should revise Article 21 of the Regulation. Otherwise, the country will lose about 20 percent of its revenue, or about USD 46 billion based on export revenue projections for 2012.

Article 21 of the regulation forbids Mining License holders from selling raw minerals or mineral ores to foreign countries, starting three months after the regulation was issued. “This means our mining products can’t be exported and this could hurt the export target,” he said, Tuesday (6/3).

Natsir further explained that Kadin fully supports increasing the value-added to minerals through processing and refining. However, Law No. 4 of 2009 on Minerals and Coal (Mining Law) states that exporting mineral commodities is allowed until 2014. “There is a contradiction between the law and the regulation,” he asserted.

Bambang Sujagad, Deputy Chairman of Kadin for Industry Research and Technology, also added that the government should protect mining businesses that generate revenue for the country. “The government should come up with a solution to attain legal certainty, which doesn’t exist in the regulation,” Bambang said.

On the other hand, Fadli Ibrahim, Head of the Legal Bureau at the Ministry of ESDM, explained that Article 21 was the Ministry of Trade’s idea. Article 21 was based on export records, which show that there has been an 800 fold increase since the Mining Law was issued.

Article 21 may not be the only controversial article in the regulation. Fadli predicts that Articles 4 to 6, which regulate processing and refining mining products, will also be criticized by businesses. However, issues with these articles can be averted through combined efforts with bigger mining companies, as mandated by the Mining Law.

Meanwhile, Edy Prasodjo, Director of Coal Businesses Development at the Ministry of ESDM, said Article 21 recognizes that there is a limited amount of natural resources and is based on a commitment between the Ministry of ESDM and other related ministries. He also said that Article 21 is a shock therapy for businesses. “Policies can’t indulge everyone, an impact was to be expected,” he said.

Syahrir AB, Executive Director of the Indonesian Mining Association, also objected to the regulation. He argued that it will be hard to implement, and recommended issuing the regulation as a government regulation. “The ideas in the regulation are good, but the conditions need to be considered,” he concluded.

(Fitri Novia Heriani / M Agus Yozami / Mahinda Arkyasa)

2026 Hak Cipta Milik Hukumonline.com
Cookies Info