
Buyung asserted that the Supreme Court was sensitive and responsive to public criticism regarding the handling of controversial petty crimes, before the Regulation was enacted. For example, in the ‘flip-flop theft’ case, a 15 year old was convicted for stealing a pair of sandals. However, he was returned to his parent’s custody rather than sentenced to five years in prison, in response to public criticism.
Buyung also predicted that the Regulation will create new problems, because the new penalties and threshold for petty crime is too high. The Regulation raised the penalties and damages regulated under Article 364, 373, 379, 384, 407, and 482 of the Criminal Code (Kitab Undang-undang Hukum Pidana – KUHP) from IDR 250 to IDR 2,5 million, a 10.000 fold increase. The Regulation also raises the minimum threshold for petty crime to IDR 2,5 million, an amount Buyung says is too high for some regions.
“The Regulation can’t be implemented as is because other regions have different income rates. In Jakarta, IDR 2,5 million may be meaningless, but for remote regions it’s a huge amount,” said Buyung at the Constitutional Court, Thursday (1/3).
For example, Buyung asked, if someone stole some laundry, rice, chicken, or even goats worth less than IDR 2,5 million, does he need to be arrested and detained if he repeats the crime over and over again?
“It would cause civil unrest and even public outrage if someone was arrested, and then released, and kept repeating the same crime. The public might resort to vigilante actions. Our police would feel miserable for having to release someone because the goods stolen had little value. We have to view the issue from a balanced perspective,” he explained.
However, he understands that the philosopy behind the Regulation, which was based on a sense of justice for criminals. “I understand MA had good intentions to protect people’s sense of justice, but the the Regulation was a hasty move, because it dosen’t take equality into consideration,” he criticized.
Dilemma
On the other han, Chief Justice M Hatta Ali claimed to be confused by the public response to the Regulation, since the public showed no support at all when judges sentenced the defendant of the flip-flop case and similar cases.
“After we issued the Regulation, people’s opinions have changed. Why was the public only concerned about freeing the defendant back then, why wasn’t the victim considered? What do the people want?” he asked.
He argued that the Regulation was intended to emphasize the ‘hospitality’ norm, especially between the defendant and the victim to achieve restorative justice.
“If the value is too small, it would be better if hospitality was emphasized. What’s important is that the defendant apologizes, and the victim forgives him/her, and there is the possibility that the damage has already been paid for and the goods have been returned,” he explained.
Hatta further explained that restorative justice principles are intended to protect the balance between the interests of the perpetrator, the victim, and the people. “This could be a very positive breakthrough if restorative justice can be implemented,” he said.
He asserted that restorative justice principles are embedded in the Regulation to prevent more cases such as the flip-flop case from going to the cassation level. “It would be shameful for Supreme Justices, who used to handle big cases, to handle petty crime cases. That would be quite distracting,” he said.
However, he admitted that the Regulation has not been included yet in the KUHP and the Criminal Procedure Code (Kitab Undang-undang Hukum Acara Pidana – KUHAP). “That’s why, in my dissertation, I suggested that including restorative justice principles in the KUHAP and KUHP as a legal basis. It would be better if the Regulation was implemented first,” he concluded.
(Agus Sahbani / Mahinda Arkyasa)

Buyung asserted that the Supreme Court was sensitive and responsive to public criticism regarding the handling of controversial petty crimes, before the Regulation was enacted. For example, in the ‘flip-flop theft’ case, a 15 year old was convicted for stealing a pair of sandals. However, he was returned to his parent’s custody rather than sentenced to five years in prison, in response to public criticism.
Buyung also predicted that the Regulation will create new problems, because the new penalties and threshold for petty crime is too high. The Regulation raised the penalties and damages regulated under Article 364, 373, 379, 384, 407, and 482 of the Criminal Code (Kitab Undang-undang Hukum Pidana – KUHP) from IDR 250 to IDR 2,5 million, a 10.000 fold increase. The Regulation also raises the minimum threshold for petty crime to IDR 2,5 million, an amount Buyung says is too high for some regions.
“The Regulation can’t be implemented as is because other regions have different income rates. In Jakarta, IDR 2,5 million may be meaningless, but for remote regions it’s a huge amount,” said Buyung at the Constitutional Court, Thursday (1/3).
For example, Buyung asked, if someone stole some laundry, rice, chicken, or even goats worth less than IDR 2,5 million, does he need to be arrested and detained if he repeats the crime over and over again?
“It would cause civil unrest and even public outrage if someone was arrested, and then released, and kept repeating the same crime. The public might resort to vigilante actions. Our police would feel miserable for having to release someone because the goods stolen had little value. We have to view the issue from a balanced perspective,” he explained.
However, he understands that the philosopy behind the Regulation, which was based on a sense of justice for criminals. “I understand MA had good intentions to protect people’s sense of justice, but the the Regulation was a hasty move, because it dosen’t take equality into consideration,” he criticized.
Dilemma
On the other han, Chief Justice M Hatta Ali claimed to be confused by the public response to the Regulation, since the public showed no support at all when judges sentenced the defendant of the flip-flop case and similar cases.
“After we issued the Regulation, people’s opinions have changed. Why was the public only concerned about freeing the defendant back then, why wasn’t the victim considered? What do the people want?” he asked.
He argued that the Regulation was intended to emphasize the ‘hospitality’ norm, especially between the defendant and the victim to achieve restorative justice.
“If the value is too small, it would be better if hospitality was emphasized. What’s important is that the defendant apologizes, and the victim forgives him/her, and there is the possibility that the damage has already been paid for and the goods have been returned,” he explained.
Hatta further explained that restorative justice principles are intended to protect the balance between the interests of the perpetrator, the victim, and the people. “This could be a very positive breakthrough if restorative justice can be implemented,” he said.
He asserted that restorative justice principles are embedded in the Regulation to prevent more cases such as the flip-flop case from going to the cassation level. “It would be shameful for Supreme Justices, who used to handle big cases, to handle petty crime cases. That would be quite distracting,” he said.
However, he admitted that the Regulation has not been included yet in the KUHP and the Criminal Procedure Code (Kitab Undang-undang Hukum Acara Pidana – KUHAP). “That’s why, in my dissertation, I suggested that including restorative justice principles in the KUHAP and KUHP as a legal basis. It would be better if the Regulation was implemented first,” he concluded.
(Agus Sahbani / Mahinda Arkyasa)