Activist: Failed Reform at Directorate General of Tax

Directorate General of Tax

Dhana Widyatmika’s case highlights how reforms at the Directorate General of Tax have failed. Dhana was able to collect tens of billions in his bank accounts and many believe the Directorate failed to detect his actions, because of an inability to take care of the root of the problems at the Directorate.

According to Lucky Djani, Secretary General of Transparency International Indonesia, the Directorate General has ignored problems such as tax subjects who misbehave and poor supervision of tax officials.

“Reforms were not well-implemented,” said Lucky, during a discussion in Jakarta, Saturday (3/3). He said that the reforms emphasized issues such as remuneration and supervision. However, these issues soften supervision, making cases like the Gayus Tambunan case possible.

Although Gayus had high remuneration for a category III/C civil servant, he defended a tax subject who complained about a tax calculation and submitted an appeal to the tax court. “These problems can’t be solved by giving incentives. The Gayus and Dhana cases are considered organized crime, and the motives are unconventional,” he said.

However, Sunarsip, an economist from The Indonesian Economic Intellegence, disagreed with Lucky’s statement. He argued that bureaucratic reform in the Directorate is not failing. “Calling it a failure is excessive,” he said.

Sunarsip asserted no tax officials were exposed for misconduct before remuneration was increased in 2008. “Did you ever hear of a tax mafia before the remuneration changes?” he asked. He explained that the tax mafia is an ‘old disease’, but Gayus and Dhana—Sunarsip’s junior at the Sekolah Tinggi Akuntansi Negara—were only recently exposed.

Further, he added that Gayus’ assets were not collected in a single case. He assumed that Gayus’ misconduct occurred over a long time and resulted in hundreds of billions. “This was old behaviour that was revealed by the remuneration changes,” he added.

Sunarsip also explained that the Directorate General of Tax has increased government revenue from taxes. Tax revenue reached IDR 660 trillion and is still increasing. This year’s tax revenue is expected to be IDR 1.000 trillion.

“We have to remember that 75 percent of the State Budget comes from taxes. How can we say the reform was a failure? The Directorate is not responsible for Gayus and Dhana’s actions,” he said.

(Leo Wisnu Susapto / Mahinda Arkyasa)

Directorate General of Tax

Dhana Widyatmika’s case highlights how reforms at the Directorate General of Tax have failed. Dhana was able to collect tens of billions in his bank accounts and many believe the Directorate failed to detect his actions, because of an inability to take care of the root of the problems at the Directorate.

According to Lucky Djani, Secretary General of Transparency International Indonesia, the Directorate General has ignored problems such as tax subjects who misbehave and poor supervision of tax officials.

“Reforms were not well-implemented,” said Lucky, during a discussion in Jakarta, Saturday (3/3). He said that the reforms emphasized issues such as remuneration and supervision. However, these issues soften supervision, making cases like the Gayus Tambunan case possible.

Although Gayus had high remuneration for a category III/C civil servant, he defended a tax subject who complained about a tax calculation and submitted an appeal to the tax court. “These problems can’t be solved by giving incentives. The Gayus and Dhana cases are considered organized crime, and the motives are unconventional,” he said.

However, Sunarsip, an economist from The Indonesian Economic Intellegence, disagreed with Lucky’s statement. He argued that bureaucratic reform in the Directorate is not failing. “Calling it a failure is excessive,” he said.

Sunarsip asserted no tax officials were exposed for misconduct before remuneration was increased in 2008. “Did you ever hear of a tax mafia before the remuneration changes?” he asked. He explained that the tax mafia is an ‘old disease’, but Gayus and Dhana—Sunarsip’s junior at the Sekolah Tinggi Akuntansi Negara—were only recently exposed.

Further, he added that Gayus’ assets were not collected in a single case. He assumed that Gayus’ misconduct occurred over a long time and resulted in hundreds of billions. “This was old behaviour that was revealed by the remuneration changes,” he added.

Sunarsip also explained that the Directorate General of Tax has increased government revenue from taxes. Tax revenue reached IDR 660 trillion and is still increasing. This year’s tax revenue is expected to be IDR 1.000 trillion.

“We have to remember that 75 percent of the State Budget comes from taxes. How can we say the reform was a failure? The Directorate is not responsible for Gayus and Dhana’s actions,” he said.

(Leo Wisnu Susapto / Mahinda Arkyasa)

2026 Hak Cipta Milik Hukumonline.com
Cookies Info