The Supreme Court has issued Supreme Court Regulation No. 2 of 2012 on the Establishment of Petty Crime Limitations and Penalties in the Criminal Code. The Regulation is aimed at resolving interpretation issues regarding penalties for petty crimes in the Indonesian Criminal Code (KUHP). Harifin Tumpa, Chief Justice, announced the Regulation during the 2011 Supreme Court Annual Report, Tuesday (28/2).
Harifin hopes the Regulation will help judges make fair decisions about petty crimes. “The Regulation is also intended to prevent cases that may potentially interfere with the people’s sense of justice, and to help the criminal court system be more efficient and effective,” he said.
The Chief Justice also pointed out the need for court supervision. In 2011, the Supreme Court Supervisory Agency received 3.232 complaints: 2.833 of them were direct complaints from the public; 258 were from institutions; and 141 complaints were received online.
Out of the 3.232 complaints, only 130 resulted in disciplinary actions. Heavy disciplinary punishment was imposed on 43 officials, while 22 officials received medium disciplinary punishments, and 62 officials received light punishments.
In addition, two officials received warnings from the military court, and one official was detained. “Of the 130 judicial officials, 38 percent were judges, 19,6 percent were court staff, and 11,8 percent were acting registrars (panitera pengganti – ed.),” Harifin explained.
The most frequent violations were disciplinary violations (53,85 percent). 20,77 percent of the violations were for unprofessional conduct and 13,85 were violations of the code of ethics.
He also explained that the Supreme Court and Judicial Comission conducted a Judge Honorary Council trial four times in 2011. “After the trials, one judge was dissmissed without honor, one judge was honorably dismissed on his/her own request, one judge was suspended and transferred, and one judge was given a warning,” he said.
Harifin asserted that the Supreme Court managed to settle a significant number of cases in 2011. “The clearance rate in 2011 was 117,19 percent. MA was asked to hear 12.990 cases and managed to settle 15.223 cases (with decisions). This shows good progress, which means the number of pending cases in the Supreme Court has been reduced,” he said.
The report also includes the Supreme Court’s achievements in court reform, access to justice, human resource development and management, and allocating and moving funds. Access to information technology infrastructure, research and development on legal training, and the Supreme Court’s participation in international forums are also addressed in the report.
Even though the Chief Justice claimed the Supreme Court has been successful, the Report is still being criticized by members of the House. Benny Kabur Harman, Chairman of Commission III of the House, asserted that the report does not explain much about the court reform agenda. “Court reformation is not elaborated on in the report, its more like an activity list,” he criticized.
Pending cases, Benny said, were not accompanied by an explanation about the annual or monthly workload of justices. As a result, the public is unaware of the justices’ performance in settling cases. “It is important for the House to be aware of the root cause of judicial problems. We hoped the new MA Chairman would respond to public expectations,” he concluded.
(Agus Sahbani / Mahinda Arkyasa)
The Supreme Court has issued Supreme Court Regulation No. 2 of 2012 on the Establishment of Petty Crime Limitations and Penalties in the Criminal Code. The Regulation is aimed at resolving interpretation issues regarding penalties for petty crimes in the Indonesian Criminal Code (KUHP). Harifin Tumpa, Chief Justice, announced the Regulation during the 2011 Supreme Court Annual Report, Tuesday (28/2).
Harifin hopes the Regulation will help judges make fair decisions about petty crimes. “The Regulation is also intended to prevent cases that may potentially interfere with the people’s sense of justice, and to help the criminal court system be more efficient and effective,” he said.
The Chief Justice also pointed out the need for court supervision. In 2011, the Supreme Court Supervisory Agency received 3.232 complaints: 2.833 of them were direct complaints from the public; 258 were from institutions; and 141 complaints were received online.
Out of the 3.232 complaints, only 130 resulted in disciplinary actions. Heavy disciplinary punishment was imposed on 43 officials, while 22 officials received medium disciplinary punishments, and 62 officials received light punishments.
In addition, two officials received warnings from the military court, and one official was detained. “Of the 130 judicial officials, 38 percent were judges, 19,6 percent were court staff, and 11,8 percent were acting registrars (panitera pengganti – ed.),” Harifin explained.
The most frequent violations were disciplinary violations (53,85 percent). 20,77 percent of the violations were for unprofessional conduct and 13,85 were violations of the code of ethics.
He also explained that the Supreme Court and Judicial Comission conducted a Judge Honorary Council trial four times in 2011. “After the trials, one judge was dissmissed without honor, one judge was honorably dismissed on his/her own request, one judge was suspended and transferred, and one judge was given a warning,” he said.
Harifin asserted that the Supreme Court managed to settle a significant number of cases in 2011. “The clearance rate in 2011 was 117,19 percent. MA was asked to hear 12.990 cases and managed to settle 15.223 cases (with decisions). This shows good progress, which means the number of pending cases in the Supreme Court has been reduced,” he said.
The report also includes the Supreme Court’s achievements in court reform, access to justice, human resource development and management, and allocating and moving funds. Access to information technology infrastructure, research and development on legal training, and the Supreme Court’s participation in international forums are also addressed in the report.
Even though the Chief Justice claimed the Supreme Court has been successful, the Report is still being criticized by members of the House. Benny Kabur Harman, Chairman of Commission III of the House, asserted that the report does not explain much about the court reform agenda. “Court reformation is not elaborated on in the report, its more like an activity list,” he criticized.
Pending cases, Benny said, were not accompanied by an explanation about the annual or monthly workload of justices. As a result, the public is unaware of the justices’ performance in settling cases. “It is important for the House to be aware of the root cause of judicial problems. We hoped the new MA Chairman would respond to public expectations,” he concluded.
(Agus Sahbani / Mahinda Arkyasa)