Juanda Pangaribuan, an ad hoc judge for the Industrial Relations Court (Pengadilan Hubungan Industrial – PHI) explained that outsourcing and fixed-term contracts (Perjanjian Kerja Waktu Tertentu – PKWT) are legal. “Outsourcing is a normal practice,” he said at a panel discussion on Outsourcing Practices After the Issuance of Ministry of Labor and Transmigration Circular Letter No. B.31/PHIJSK/I/2012, in Jakarta, Tuesday (28/2).
He explained that the Circular Letter was the Government reaction to Constitutional Court Decision No. 27/PUU-IX/2011. “The Circular is just instructions to government institutions, and isn’t considered to be a law,” he asserted.
Juanda also said that companies and outsourcing companies are still able to outsource, using Article 59 of Law No. 13 of 2003 on Labor as a legal basis. Article 59 states that a fixed-term contract may be applied to work that can be completed in a definite period of time.
Further, he explained that the MK Decision was intended to protect workers rights by requiring all fixed-term contracts to include provisions on transferring workers rights. “The MK did not declared outsourcing and fixed-term contracts to be illegal, so these practices are still valid,” he said, “businesses should also be responsible for their workers.”
Juanda also urged the Government to amend the Labor Law to harmonize it with the MK’s Decision and protect workers rights. “An amendment is necessary to attain legal certainty in the industrial sectors” he said.
Iftida Yasar, Deputy Chairman of the Indonesian Business Association (Apindo) supports this idea. “In other countries, outsourcing is considered to be a blessing. In India, getting people to work is the most important thing,” she said at the same event.
She asserted that there are formal outsourcing companies that consider workers rights. Outsourcing’s bad image came from informal outsourcing companies that often neglect workers rights and do not want to be held responsible for them. “The problem is, 70% of Indonesian companies are in the informal sector,” she added.
Outsourcing, Iftida said, was not intended to reduce production costs for companies. “It only reduces the cost of severance payments if a layoff occurs. The company will still have to pay management fees,” she said.
Meanwhile, Irianto Simbolon, the Director of Work Requirements Welfare and a Discrimination Analyst at the Ministry of Labor and Transmigration, explained that many people do not understand the concept of outsourcing, and the MK Decision states that outsourcing and PKWT can still be conducted. “A PKWT can still be used as long as it includes provisions on the transfer of workers rights,” he said.
Irianto, however, emphasized that the MK’s Decision is confusing. He asserted that the Labor Law and other laws do not refer to or even use ‘outsourcing’ as a term, yet the MK includes the term in their Decision. “The people should criticize the MK, because they use ‘outsourcing’ in their decision,” he said concluded.
(Mahinda Arkyasa)
Juanda Pangaribuan, an ad hoc judge for the Industrial Relations Court (Pengadilan Hubungan Industrial – PHI) explained that outsourcing and fixed-term contracts (Perjanjian Kerja Waktu Tertentu – PKWT) are legal. “Outsourcing is a normal practice,” he said at a panel discussion on Outsourcing Practices After the Issuance of Ministry of Labor and Transmigration Circular Letter No. B.31/PHIJSK/I/2012, in Jakarta, Tuesday (28/2).
He explained that the Circular Letter was the Government reaction to Constitutional Court Decision No. 27/PUU-IX/2011. “The Circular is just instructions to government institutions, and isn’t considered to be a law,” he asserted.
Juanda also said that companies and outsourcing companies are still able to outsource, using Article 59 of Law No. 13 of 2003 on Labor as a legal basis. Article 59 states that a fixed-term contract may be applied to work that can be completed in a definite period of time.
Further, he explained that the MK Decision was intended to protect workers rights by requiring all fixed-term contracts to include provisions on transferring workers rights. “The MK did not declared outsourcing and fixed-term contracts to be illegal, so these practices are still valid,” he said, “businesses should also be responsible for their workers.”
Juanda also urged the Government to amend the Labor Law to harmonize it with the MK’s Decision and protect workers rights. “An amendment is necessary to attain legal certainty in the industrial sectors” he said.
Iftida Yasar, Deputy Chairman of the Indonesian Business Association (Apindo) supports this idea. “In other countries, outsourcing is considered to be a blessing. In India, getting people to work is the most important thing,” she said at the same event.
She asserted that there are formal outsourcing companies that consider workers rights. Outsourcing’s bad image came from informal outsourcing companies that often neglect workers rights and do not want to be held responsible for them. “The problem is, 70% of Indonesian companies are in the informal sector,” she added.
Outsourcing, Iftida said, was not intended to reduce production costs for companies. “It only reduces the cost of severance payments if a layoff occurs. The company will still have to pay management fees,” she said.
Meanwhile, Irianto Simbolon, the Director of Work Requirements Welfare and a Discrimination Analyst at the Ministry of Labor and Transmigration, explained that many people do not understand the concept of outsourcing, and the MK Decision states that outsourcing and PKWT can still be conducted. “A PKWT can still be used as long as it includes provisions on the transfer of workers rights,” he said.
Irianto, however, emphasized that the MK’s Decision is confusing. He asserted that the Labor Law and other laws do not refer to or even use ‘outsourcing’ as a term, yet the MK includes the term in their Decision. “The people should criticize the MK, because they use ‘outsourcing’ in their decision,” he said concluded.
(Mahinda Arkyasa)