Since the issuance of Law No. 4 of 2009 on Mineral and Coal Mining (Law), trading Mining Permits (IUP) and Special Mining Permits (IUPK) has been forbidden and illegal. According to Article 93 of the Mining Law, IUP and IUPK holders cannot not transfer their permits to another party. Since the permit holders cannot transfer their permits, mining businesses have started buying the company that owns the IUP to obtain the permit.
Sony Heru Prasetyo, a representative of the Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources (ESDM) explained that acquiring an IUP through a corporate transaction such as merger is illegal if the purpose of the transaction is to transfer of the target company’s IUP.
“An IUP transfer is a forbidden corporate transaction,” Sony said at the Second Mineral and Coal Mining Legal and Business Forum and Expo 2012, in Bali, Thursday (23/2).
Furthermore, Sony stated that many parties keep on applying for IUPs, even though they do not engage in any mining activities. “They don’t have the technical ability, and are only hoping for a profit. That’s why the Mining Law was issued,” Sony said.
On other hand, Yuliana Tjhai, a lawyer from Bahar and Partners Law Firm, explained that her clients bought IUPs legally and the purchases were approved by the Ministry of ESDM. “Currently, there is no implementing regulation for Article 93 of the Mining Law,” she added.
Yuliana also showed hukumonline, a response letter from from Edi Pasodjo, the Director of Coal Business Development. The letter, registered under No. 2140/30/DBB/2011 and dated 20 Oktober 2011, states that IUP can be transferred in accordance with the provisions of the Directorate General of Public Mining Decision No. 472K/2001/DJP/1998 on the Transfer of Mining Permits dated 15 September 1998.
Moreover, an IUP transfer has to be accompanied by a full exploration report, which proves that two potential areas which contain mineral and coal reserves have been found; the Annual General Meeting minutes from the companies that transfer and receive the IUP, which contains the IUP transfer agreement; and a no objection statement from the Directors of both of the companies, which has been approved by the Chief Commisioners of the companies. In addition, the transfer must fulfill administrative, technical, and environmental requirements.
“Usually the governor or regent that issued the IUP will not directly approve a transfer, they will wait for approval from the state government (the Ministry of ESDM),” Yuliana concluded.
(Davidson Samosir / Mahinda Arkyasa)
Since the issuance of Law No. 4 of 2009 on Mineral and Coal Mining (Law), trading Mining Permits (IUP) and Special Mining Permits (IUPK) has been forbidden and illegal. According to Article 93 of the Mining Law, IUP and IUPK holders cannot not transfer their permits to another party. Since the permit holders cannot transfer their permits, mining businesses have started buying the company that owns the IUP to obtain the permit.
Sony Heru Prasetyo, a representative of the Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources (ESDM) explained that acquiring an IUP through a corporate transaction such as merger is illegal if the purpose of the transaction is to transfer of the target company’s IUP.
“An IUP transfer is a forbidden corporate transaction,” Sony said at the Second Mineral and Coal Mining Legal and Business Forum and Expo 2012, in Bali, Thursday (23/2).
Furthermore, Sony stated that many parties keep on applying for IUPs, even though they do not engage in any mining activities. “They don’t have the technical ability, and are only hoping for a profit. That’s why the Mining Law was issued,” Sony said.
On other hand, Yuliana Tjhai, a lawyer from Bahar and Partners Law Firm, explained that her clients bought IUPs legally and the purchases were approved by the Ministry of ESDM. “Currently, there is no implementing regulation for Article 93 of the Mining Law,” she added.
Yuliana also showed hukumonline, a response letter from from Edi Pasodjo, the Director of Coal Business Development. The letter, registered under No. 2140/30/DBB/2011 and dated 20 Oktober 2011, states that IUP can be transferred in accordance with the provisions of the Directorate General of Public Mining Decision No. 472K/2001/DJP/1998 on the Transfer of Mining Permits dated 15 September 1998.
Moreover, an IUP transfer has to be accompanied by a full exploration report, which proves that two potential areas which contain mineral and coal reserves have been found; the Annual General Meeting minutes from the companies that transfer and receive the IUP, which contains the IUP transfer agreement; and a no objection statement from the Directors of both of the companies, which has been approved by the Chief Commisioners of the companies. In addition, the transfer must fulfill administrative, technical, and environmental requirements.
“Usually the governor or regent that issued the IUP will not directly approve a transfer, they will wait for approval from the state government (the Ministry of ESDM),” Yuliana concluded.
(Davidson Samosir / Mahinda Arkyasa)