The Indonesian Institute of Public Accountants (Institut Akuntan Pbulik Indonesia - IAPI) criticized the criminal clauses under Articles 55 and 56 of Law No. 5 of 2011 on Public Accountants (Public Accountants Law). The IAPI claims these articles were made up and not supported by scientific data.
“This is a constitutionalized form of ‘looking down’ on the public accounting profession,” said Tia Adityasih, Chairman of the IAPI, during a judicial review trial on the Public Accountant Law in the Constitutional Court, Wednesday (22/2).
The judicial review petition was submitted by a number of public accountants, including M Achsin, Anton Silalahi, Yanuaar Mulyana, Rahmat Zuhdi, and M Zainuddin. They argued that Articles 55 and 56 of the Public Accountant Law contradict Article 28H of the 1945 Constitution. According to the petitioners, the sanctions in Articles 55 and 56 are disproportional to the crimes and can be misused.
The applicants asserted that the word ‘manipulation’ in Articles 55 and 56 creates legal uncertainty and is ambiguous. ‘Manipulation’ is hard to interpret since the Indonesian Criminal Code does use it. The Indonesian Criminal Code only addresses forgery of documents.
The applicants also argued that ‘obscuring data or notes on a worksheet' should be an administrative violation, not a crime, since a worksheet is just an opinion, not a final document in the public accounting profession.
Tia explained that Articles 55 and 56 are out of synch with some characteristics of the accounting profession. In addition, she said the articles depict public accounting as an unrighteous profession. Instead of criminal sanctions, Tia said, an approach that empowers public accountants and facilitates internal disputes should be applied.
She asserted that criminal sanctions should only apply to specific crimes such as forgery. However, Articles 55 and 56 use the word ‘manipulation’, which is a general term, rather than the more specific term ‘forgery’.
Tia is concerned the word ‘manipulation’ will result in the criminalization of public accountants, which will increase professional risks and reduce business potential for public accountants. “Violations of professional standards and the code of ethics should be punished by imposing professional sanctions,” she said.
She also added that the Public Accountant Law should support the profession by mandating professional standards, a code of ethics, and articles of association for accounting organizations. “Imposing sanctions should be considered as a last resort,” she pleaded.
(Agus Sahbani / Mahinda Arkyasa)
The Indonesian Institute of Public Accountants (Institut Akuntan Pbulik Indonesia - IAPI) criticized the criminal clauses under Articles 55 and 56 of Law No. 5 of 2011 on Public Accountants (Public Accountants Law). The IAPI claims these articles were made up and not supported by scientific data.
“This is a constitutionalized form of ‘looking down’ on the public accounting profession,” said Tia Adityasih, Chairman of the IAPI, during a judicial review trial on the Public Accountant Law in the Constitutional Court, Wednesday (22/2).
The judicial review petition was submitted by a number of public accountants, including M Achsin, Anton Silalahi, Yanuaar Mulyana, Rahmat Zuhdi, and M Zainuddin. They argued that Articles 55 and 56 of the Public Accountant Law contradict Article 28H of the 1945 Constitution. According to the petitioners, the sanctions in Articles 55 and 56 are disproportional to the crimes and can be misused.
The applicants asserted that the word ‘manipulation’ in Articles 55 and 56 creates legal uncertainty and is ambiguous. ‘Manipulation’ is hard to interpret since the Indonesian Criminal Code does use it. The Indonesian Criminal Code only addresses forgery of documents.
The applicants also argued that ‘obscuring data or notes on a worksheet' should be an administrative violation, not a crime, since a worksheet is just an opinion, not a final document in the public accounting profession.
Tia explained that Articles 55 and 56 are out of synch with some characteristics of the accounting profession. In addition, she said the articles depict public accounting as an unrighteous profession. Instead of criminal sanctions, Tia said, an approach that empowers public accountants and facilitates internal disputes should be applied.
She asserted that criminal sanctions should only apply to specific crimes such as forgery. However, Articles 55 and 56 use the word ‘manipulation’, which is a general term, rather than the more specific term ‘forgery’.
Tia is concerned the word ‘manipulation’ will result in the criminalization of public accountants, which will increase professional risks and reduce business potential for public accountants. “Violations of professional standards and the code of ethics should be punished by imposing professional sanctions,” she said.
She also added that the Public Accountant Law should support the profession by mandating professional standards, a code of ethics, and articles of association for accounting organizations. “Imposing sanctions should be considered as a last resort,” she pleaded.
(Agus Sahbani / Mahinda Arkyasa)