Deputy Secretary of the Indonesian Businesses Association (Asosiasi Pengusaha Indonesia - Apindo), Iftida Yasar, is concerned that Constitutional Court (MK) decision No. 27/PUU-IX/2011 on Law No. 13 of 2003 on Labor (“Labor Law”) will be difficult to implement.
According to the MK decision, businesses must guarantee the labor rights of outsourced workers even if the outsourcing company changes. As a result, businesses must consider a worker’s length of service and make separate payments if layoffs occur, increasing businesses expenses.
Furthermore, Iftida explained that it would be financially impossible for a new outsourcing company to transfer workers’ rights, because the severance costs would be too high. Outsourcing companies and companies that use their services must have initial agreement on this topic.
“Who would be responsible? The outsourcing companies won’t want to employ the previous workers,” she said to hukumonline, Monday (20/2).
MK’s decision would increase businesses expenses, especially for companies that use outsourced labor. The decision would force outsourcing companies to include the cost of providing workers benefits in the fee components that have to be paid by the user company. Ifrida also explained that by using outsourcing services, businesses would not have to employ workers continuously.
Yogo Pamungkas, a lecturer from Trisakti University, explained that outsourcing is a labor management system. Outsourcing is intended to increase efficiency by reducing labor expenses. He argued that MK’s decision is essential to protect labors rights. The decision allows workers to remain employed either in the user company or the outsourcing company.
Further, he explained that the MK’s decision could be implemented if outsourcing companies have strong financial support. Currently, many outsourcing companies are established depending on customer needs for labor, which are usually temporary. Outsourcing companies are often dismissed if a customer’s labor needs change.
“Businesses will employ workers for three years, and then replace them, and after another three years, other replacements will be employed. Workers won’t be protected,” Yogo said.
Yogo said outsourcing companies should be established and managed professionally. He also urged the government to issue regulations that increase the performance of outsourcing companies. He suggested creating requirements for establishing outsourcing companies, such as minimum capital requirements and requiring outsourcing companies to be formed as limited liability companies.
“The decision can’t be implemented if outsourcing companies haven’t met these requirements,” he concluded.
(Ady Thea Dian Achmad / Mahinda Arkyasa)
Deputy Secretary of the Indonesian Businesses Association (Asosiasi Pengusaha Indonesia - Apindo), Iftida Yasar, is concerned that Constitutional Court (MK) decision No. 27/PUU-IX/2011 on Law No. 13 of 2003 on Labor (“Labor Law”) will be difficult to implement.
According to the MK decision, businesses must guarantee the labor rights of outsourced workers even if the outsourcing company changes. As a result, businesses must consider a worker’s length of service and make separate payments if layoffs occur, increasing businesses expenses.
Furthermore, Iftida explained that it would be financially impossible for a new outsourcing company to transfer workers’ rights, because the severance costs would be too high. Outsourcing companies and companies that use their services must have initial agreement on this topic.
“Who would be responsible? The outsourcing companies won’t want to employ the previous workers,” she said to hukumonline, Monday (20/2).
MK’s decision would increase businesses expenses, especially for companies that use outsourced labor. The decision would force outsourcing companies to include the cost of providing workers benefits in the fee components that have to be paid by the user company. Ifrida also explained that by using outsourcing services, businesses would not have to employ workers continuously.
Yogo Pamungkas, a lecturer from Trisakti University, explained that outsourcing is a labor management system. Outsourcing is intended to increase efficiency by reducing labor expenses. He argued that MK’s decision is essential to protect labors rights. The decision allows workers to remain employed either in the user company or the outsourcing company.
Further, he explained that the MK’s decision could be implemented if outsourcing companies have strong financial support. Currently, many outsourcing companies are established depending on customer needs for labor, which are usually temporary. Outsourcing companies are often dismissed if a customer’s labor needs change.
“Businesses will employ workers for three years, and then replace them, and after another three years, other replacements will be employed. Workers won’t be protected,” Yogo said.
Yogo said outsourcing companies should be established and managed professionally. He also urged the government to issue regulations that increase the performance of outsourcing companies. He suggested creating requirements for establishing outsourcing companies, such as minimum capital requirements and requiring outsourcing companies to be formed as limited liability companies.
“The decision can’t be implemented if outsourcing companies haven’t met these requirements,” he concluded.
(Ady Thea Dian Achmad / Mahinda Arkyasa)