Jimly Asshiddiqie, a state law expert, said that ineffective legal systems lead tounequal access to democratic freedoms. “The real right [to justice] is only enjoyed by specificgroups. Social injustice keeps on growing today,” he said duringa discussion at the Judicial Commission, Tuesday (31/1).
Thepresent legal system is unjust, Jimly explained. “Social justice is impossible when the legal system creates social gaps. For example, many laws and court decisionsresult inlegal certainty,and even preserve social distortions,” Jimly asserted.
He suggested that the legal system and legal institutions should be modernized in favor of social justice. Legal institutions, such as the police, attorneys, and the Supreme Court must gain public trust.
“Those institutions need to be reformed or Indonesian law must be modernized. The stateand its people should be together. Another example, is that the Judicial Commission and Supreme Court relationship is also affected by the ineffective legal system,” he explained.
Modernization involves evaluating the substance of laws and regulations, so they may be used to narrow social gaps. “For example, there should be a provision that forces the rich to become closer to the poor,and the powerful to the weak,” Jimly further explained.
Furthermore, outdated lawsneed to be revised. Jimly presented the Bali bombing case as an example. The trial was conducted two years after the incident tookplace. Meanwhile, in Norway, a trial was conducted just five days after the incident occured. “If Norway can implement an efficient and just system, why can’t Indonesia? The case shows how inefficient Indonesia’s formal legal system is,” he said.
Jimly also cited the Nunun Nurbaeti and Miranda Gultom cases as examples. The Corruption Eradication Commission summoned Miranda as a witness in early 2010, but it took two years to declare her a suspect. “This shows injustice,” he argued.
Jimly asserted, modernization in law, civil procedure, and legal management is needed urgently. “This indicates the creativity and courage of government authorities,” he said.
This is not the first time Jimly advocated for legal modernization. He pressed the same issue at the Habibie Awards in 2011. Jimly explained, outdated case management in Indonesia has led to time-consuming processes for handling cases. “Case management has to be modernized; not only case administration, but also procedural law,” he said at the awards.
(Agus Sahbani / Mahinda Arkyasa)
Jimly Asshiddiqie, a state law expert, said that ineffective legal systems lead tounequal access to democratic freedoms. “The real right [to justice] is only enjoyed by specificgroups. Social injustice keeps on growing today,” he said duringa discussion at the Judicial Commission, Tuesday (31/1).
Thepresent legal system is unjust, Jimly explained. “Social justice is impossible when the legal system creates social gaps. For example, many laws and court decisionsresult inlegal certainty,and even preserve social distortions,” Jimly asserted.
He suggested that the legal system and legal institutions should be modernized in favor of social justice. Legal institutions, such as the police, attorneys, and the Supreme Court must gain public trust.
“Those institutions need to be reformed or Indonesian law must be modernized. The stateand its people should be together. Another example, is that the Judicial Commission and Supreme Court relationship is also affected by the ineffective legal system,” he explained.
Modernization involves evaluating the substance of laws and regulations, so they may be used to narrow social gaps. “For example, there should be a provision that forces the rich to become closer to the poor,and the powerful to the weak,” Jimly further explained.
Furthermore, outdated lawsneed to be revised. Jimly presented the Bali bombing case as an example. The trial was conducted two years after the incident tookplace. Meanwhile, in Norway, a trial was conducted just five days after the incident occured. “If Norway can implement an efficient and just system, why can’t Indonesia? The case shows how inefficient Indonesia’s formal legal system is,” he said.
Jimly also cited the Nunun Nurbaeti and Miranda Gultom cases as examples. The Corruption Eradication Commission summoned Miranda as a witness in early 2010, but it took two years to declare her a suspect. “This shows injustice,” he argued.
Jimly asserted, modernization in law, civil procedure, and legal management is needed urgently. “This indicates the creativity and courage of government authorities,” he said.
This is not the first time Jimly advocated for legal modernization. He pressed the same issue at the Habibie Awards in 2011. Jimly explained, outdated case management in Indonesia has led to time-consuming processes for handling cases. “Case management has to be modernized; not only case administration, but also procedural law,” he said at the awards.
(Agus Sahbani / Mahinda Arkyasa)