Digital Broadcasting Should Be Regulated Under A Law, Expert Says

Minister of Communication and Information Technology Regulation No. 23 of 2011 on Digital Broadcasting (“Regulation”) is still widely criticized. Ade Armando, communication expert from Universitas Indonesia (UI), argues that public interests should be prioritized during the implementation process for the Regulation, particularly during the process of broadcasting frequency sharing.

“Broadcasting frequencies can be considered to be a natural resource, which must be used for national interests,” Ade said at Commission I of the House of Representatives, Thursday (26/1). This is in accordance with Law No. 5 of 1960 on Agriculture, which states that space is categorized as a natural resource.

Ade agreed that improving the television industry is a good thing. However, he said, local TV  must also be considered. “We should pay attention to our colleagues in many regions, so they can improve their business like Harry Tanoe (owner of MNC Group), Surya Paloh (owner of Metro TV), and Bakrie (owner of tvOne and ANTV),” Ade said.

He also explained that the switch from an analog to digital system will have a huge impact. It will change the infrastructure and lead to an increase in government expenditures. “I’m certain it won’t go well. The cost is too high,” he said.

To support his arguments, Ade described the United State's experience with migrating from analog to digital technology. “They began migrating from digital to analog technology in 2005. However, the process just finished in 2011 after Barack Obama supplied USD 1 billion for the project,” he explained.

In addition to concerns about the cost and need for new infrastructure, Ade argues that regulating digital broadcasting in a ministerial regulation is not sufficient. Instead, Ade emphasized, that digital broadcasting should be regulated by a law. It should be noted that the House is currently discussing an amendment to Law No. 23 of 2002 on Broadcasting.

Meanwhile, Minister of Communication and Information Tifatul Sembiring, argued that this policy creates new digital broadcasting frequencies. “There will be new frequencies, so people can start a new broadcasting industry easily,” he said at the House Secretariat, Thursday (26/1).

He asserted that the ministrial regulation is in accordance with the Broadcasting Law mandate. “If the regulation violates the Broadcasting Law, go ahead and review it [in the Supreme Court],” he concluded.

(Ali Samande / Mahinda Arkyasa)

Minister of Communication and Information Technology Regulation No. 23 of 2011 on Digital Broadcasting (“Regulation”) is still widely criticized. Ade Armando, communication expert from Universitas Indonesia (UI), argues that public interests should be prioritized during the implementation process for the Regulation, particularly during the process of broadcasting frequency sharing.

“Broadcasting frequencies can be considered to be a natural resource, which must be used for national interests,” Ade said at Commission I of the House of Representatives, Thursday (26/1). This is in accordance with Law No. 5 of 1960 on Agriculture, which states that space is categorized as a natural resource.

Ade agreed that improving the television industry is a good thing. However, he said, local TV  must also be considered. “We should pay attention to our colleagues in many regions, so they can improve their business like Harry Tanoe (owner of MNC Group), Surya Paloh (owner of Metro TV), and Bakrie (owner of tvOne and ANTV),” Ade said.

He also explained that the switch from an analog to digital system will have a huge impact. It will change the infrastructure and lead to an increase in government expenditures. “I’m certain it won’t go well. The cost is too high,” he said.

To support his arguments, Ade described the United State's experience with migrating from analog to digital technology. “They began migrating from digital to analog technology in 2005. However, the process just finished in 2011 after Barack Obama supplied USD 1 billion for the project,” he explained.

In addition to concerns about the cost and need for new infrastructure, Ade argues that regulating digital broadcasting in a ministerial regulation is not sufficient. Instead, Ade emphasized, that digital broadcasting should be regulated by a law. It should be noted that the House is currently discussing an amendment to Law No. 23 of 2002 on Broadcasting.

Meanwhile, Minister of Communication and Information Tifatul Sembiring, argued that this policy creates new digital broadcasting frequencies. “There will be new frequencies, so people can start a new broadcasting industry easily,” he said at the House Secretariat, Thursday (26/1).

He asserted that the ministrial regulation is in accordance with the Broadcasting Law mandate. “If the regulation violates the Broadcasting Law, go ahead and review it [in the Supreme Court],” he concluded.

(Ali Samande / Mahinda Arkyasa)

2026 Hak Cipta Milik Hukumonline.com
Cookies Info