The Work Committee for Phone Credit Fraud at the House of Representatives summoned 10 content providers (CP) that are considered “troubled” by the Indonesian Telecommunication Regulatory Authority (BRTI) for a discussion. Members of the House asked whether the CPs are aware that they harmed customers.
“I want you to be honest. Do you ever think your business is harmful?” asked Max Sopacua, a member of the Committee in the Commission I plennary hall, Thursday (12/1).
All the content providers believe that they are not guilty, since they conduct legal activities. PT Kreatif Bersama’s representative said that the company has not done anything wrong, since it provided consumers with adequate information in accordance with the relevant regulations.
Rafli Ridwan, President Director of Nextion Prima, said that his business complies with laws and regulations. He admitted that there are complaints about his company’s short message service promotion. “We use words like ‘prizes’. It’s a common practice,” he said.
According to him, the company's actions are legal. “The problem arises when people who register don’t get the prize, and they say it’s a scam. It’s just like a bank promotion. We sell information,” he explained.
Unsatisfied with the CPs response, Max complained that the CPs do not feel guilty or responsible for their actions even though they harmed customers. “It’s like taking advantage of people's ignorance. As if they were stupid,” he said.
Ahmed Zaki Iskandar Zulkarnain, a parliament member from the Golkar Party, argued that providers violated Law No. 8 of 1999 on Consumer Protection by providing incomplete information. For example, Ahmed says the providers violated the law by making the process for terminating services much more difficult than the registration process.
“You never explained the product clearly. The penalty for providing incomplete information is regulated under the Consumer Protection Law. The sentence is 5 years of imprisonment,” he stated.
Business Competition
Yusuf Hasnoputro, President Director of PT Extend Media, refused to be called a cheater and said phone credit fraud cases are part of business competition. “I’ve been in the business for 10 years. It’s a cruel business,” he said.
He was suspicious about BRTI's detailed and complete complaints from customers. According to Yusuf, this information belongs to the CP itself. “I’m not sure customers have access to this data,” he said.
Yusuf also rejected BRTI’s accusation that his company is not registered. “We have registered using BRTI’s official site. We have proof. I’ll think about taking legal action,” he concluded
Yusuf's company is on a list of troubled content providers published by BRTI. The list includes the following companies:
1. 9393 : Owned by PT Extend Media Indonesia, working with Telkomsel. 81 complaints from customers. Has not been registered by BRTI;
2. 9877 : Owned by PT Kreatif Bersama, quiz and game services. 50 complaints from customers;
3. 1212 : Owned by PT Telkomsel, Ring Back Tone (RBT) service, Private Call Tone (NSP) service, and Langit Musik Telkomsel service. Allegedly does not have a permit from BRTI. 49 complaints from customers;
4. 9399 : Owned by PT Era Cahaya Brillian, has the same board of directors as PT Extent Media Indonesia which has not been registered by BRTI. 32 complaints from customers;
5. 9899 : Owned by Nextnation Prisma, offers prizes, and ANTV Pildacil SMS vote. 29 complaints;
6. 1818 : Owned by PT XL Axiata for RBT service. 24 complaints and does not have a business license from BRTI;
7. 9599 : Owned by PT Lingua Asiatic, for Indosat I-RING 808 and auction services. 19 complaints;
8. 9388 : Owned by PT Infokom Elektrindo, for music content services. 18 complaints;
9. 9133 : Owned by PT Collibri network. 17 complaints from customers;
10. 2680 : Religious and horoscope service owned by PT Cequal Indonesia, working with PT Telkomsel. 16 complaints from customers.
(Ali Salmande / Mahinda Arkyasa / Aurora Meliala)
The Work Committee for Phone Credit Fraud at the House of Representatives summoned 10 content providers (CP) that are considered “troubled” by the Indonesian Telecommunication Regulatory Authority (BRTI) for a discussion. Members of the House asked whether the CPs are aware that they harmed customers.
“I want you to be honest. Do you ever think your business is harmful?” asked Max Sopacua, a member of the Committee in the Commission I plennary hall, Thursday (12/1).
All the content providers believe that they are not guilty, since they conduct legal activities. PT Kreatif Bersama’s representative said that the company has not done anything wrong, since it provided consumers with adequate information in accordance with the relevant regulations.
Rafli Ridwan, President Director of Nextion Prima, said that his business complies with laws and regulations. He admitted that there are complaints about his company’s short message service promotion. “We use words like ‘prizes’. It’s a common practice,” he said.
According to him, the company's actions are legal. “The problem arises when people who register don’t get the prize, and they say it’s a scam. It’s just like a bank promotion. We sell information,” he explained.
Unsatisfied with the CPs response, Max complained that the CPs do not feel guilty or responsible for their actions even though they harmed customers. “It’s like taking advantage of people's ignorance. As if they were stupid,” he said.
Ahmed Zaki Iskandar Zulkarnain, a parliament member from the Golkar Party, argued that providers violated Law No. 8 of 1999 on Consumer Protection by providing incomplete information. For example, Ahmed says the providers violated the law by making the process for terminating services much more difficult than the registration process.
“You never explained the product clearly. The penalty for providing incomplete information is regulated under the Consumer Protection Law. The sentence is 5 years of imprisonment,” he stated.
Business Competition
Yusuf Hasnoputro, President Director of PT Extend Media, refused to be called a cheater and said phone credit fraud cases are part of business competition. “I’ve been in the business for 10 years. It’s a cruel business,” he said.
He was suspicious about BRTI's detailed and complete complaints from customers. According to Yusuf, this information belongs to the CP itself. “I’m not sure customers have access to this data,” he said.
Yusuf also rejected BRTI’s accusation that his company is not registered. “We have registered using BRTI’s official site. We have proof. I’ll think about taking legal action,” he concluded
Yusuf's company is on a list of troubled content providers published by BRTI. The list includes the following companies:
1. 9393 : Owned by PT Extend Media Indonesia, working with Telkomsel. 81 complaints from customers. Has not been registered by BRTI;
2. 9877 : Owned by PT Kreatif Bersama, quiz and game services. 50 complaints from customers;
3. 1212 : Owned by PT Telkomsel, Ring Back Tone (RBT) service, Private Call Tone (NSP) service, and Langit Musik Telkomsel service. Allegedly does not have a permit from BRTI. 49 complaints from customers;
4. 9399 : Owned by PT Era Cahaya Brillian, has the same board of directors as PT Extent Media Indonesia which has not been registered by BRTI. 32 complaints from customers;
5. 9899 : Owned by Nextnation Prisma, offers prizes, and ANTV Pildacil SMS vote. 29 complaints;
6. 1818 : Owned by PT XL Axiata for RBT service. 24 complaints and does not have a business license from BRTI;
7. 9599 : Owned by PT Lingua Asiatic, for Indosat I-RING 808 and auction services. 19 complaints;
8. 9388 : Owned by PT Infokom Elektrindo, for music content services. 18 complaints;
9. 9133 : Owned by PT Collibri network. 17 complaints from customers;
10. 2680 : Religious and horoscope service owned by PT Cequal Indonesia, working with PT Telkomsel. 16 complaints from customers.
(Ali Salmande / Mahinda Arkyasa / Aurora Meliala)