Most Consumers Agree on Sanctions for Smokers

The Indonesian Consumers Organization (Yayasan Lembaga Konsumen Indonesia – YLKI) just conducted a survey on the implementation of “no smoking” areas. The survey shows that 76 percent of hotel visitors and 80 percent of restaurant patrons agree with imposing fines on people who smoke inside hotels and restaurants.

YLKI based this survey on one main question, which is whether the implementation of “no smoking” areas will reduce hotel and restaurant visits.  Hotel and restaurant managers assumed that the “no smoking” area regulation affects business.

However, the survey, which was conducted in 100 hotels and 100 restaurants, shows that implementing the “no smoking” areas has nothing to do with visit rates. “The assumption is just a myth,” Tulus Abadi said in Jakarta, Tuesday (10/1).

What is interesting is that the majority of consumers agree with imposing fines. Only 24 percent of hotel visitors and 20 percent of restaurant visitors disagreed with imposing fines. The survey also shows that most consumers think that the fine should be between IDR 250 to 500 thousand; 18 percent think that the fine should be between IDR 500 thousand to one million; and 27 percent think that the fine should be more than IDR 1 million.

However, imposing fines on smokers is not as easy as it sounds, especially when it comes to hotel and restaurant service. DKI Jakarta, for example, has issued Special Jakarta Area Governor Regulation No 88 of 2010, which imposes fines on smokers and building managers. However, Tulus Abadi said that the regulation is not well-implemented.

Tatang Sumantri, Acting Head of the Jakarta Tourism and Culture Office, admitted that sanctions have not been entirely implemented. The provincial government is more focused on persuasion rather than imposing sanctions.

“We haven’t implemented the sanctions based on a variety of considerations,” he said. Furthermore, Tatang hoped that the assumption that “no smoking” areas will reduce hotel and restaurant visits will go away.

Husnah Zahir, Head of the YLKI organizing committee, expressed similar expectations. “Hotel and restaurant managers have to be firm about implementing  ‘no smoking’ areas,” Husnah said.

(Muhammad Yasin / Aurora Meliala / Pirhot Nababan)

The Indonesian Consumers Organization (Yayasan Lembaga Konsumen Indonesia – YLKI) just conducted a survey on the implementation of “no smoking” areas. The survey shows that 76 percent of hotel visitors and 80 percent of restaurant patrons agree with imposing fines on people who smoke inside hotels and restaurants.

YLKI based this survey on one main question, which is whether the implementation of “no smoking” areas will reduce hotel and restaurant visits.  Hotel and restaurant managers assumed that the “no smoking” area regulation affects business.

However, the survey, which was conducted in 100 hotels and 100 restaurants, shows that implementing the “no smoking” areas has nothing to do with visit rates. “The assumption is just a myth,” Tulus Abadi said in Jakarta, Tuesday (10/1).

What is interesting is that the majority of consumers agree with imposing fines. Only 24 percent of hotel visitors and 20 percent of restaurant visitors disagreed with imposing fines. The survey also shows that most consumers think that the fine should be between IDR 250 to 500 thousand; 18 percent think that the fine should be between IDR 500 thousand to one million; and 27 percent think that the fine should be more than IDR 1 million.

However, imposing fines on smokers is not as easy as it sounds, especially when it comes to hotel and restaurant service. DKI Jakarta, for example, has issued Special Jakarta Area Governor Regulation No 88 of 2010, which imposes fines on smokers and building managers. However, Tulus Abadi said that the regulation is not well-implemented.

Tatang Sumantri, Acting Head of the Jakarta Tourism and Culture Office, admitted that sanctions have not been entirely implemented. The provincial government is more focused on persuasion rather than imposing sanctions.

“We haven’t implemented the sanctions based on a variety of considerations,” he said. Furthermore, Tatang hoped that the assumption that “no smoking” areas will reduce hotel and restaurant visits will go away.

Husnah Zahir, Head of the YLKI organizing committee, expressed similar expectations. “Hotel and restaurant managers have to be firm about implementing  ‘no smoking’ areas,” Husnah said.

(Muhammad Yasin / Aurora Meliala / Pirhot Nababan)

2026 Hak Cipta Milik Hukumonline.com
Cookies Info