Without including an Assembly Decree in the statute’s preamble, the Bill on Land Procurement for Public Interest is considered to contain formal defects, now that the Assembly Decree belongs to the hierarchy of legislation.
The Draft Bill on Land Procurement for Public Interest hasbeen approved by the House and the President. Severalactivists plan to propose judicial review of this law, and the status of the case is that it is waiting for numbering.
Budiman Sudjatmiko, member of Commission II of the House of Representatives, thinks that opportunities to review this Law are wide open. Budiman admitted that he was “lost” for letting this bill pass into law. In his opinion, the Law is inclined to be advantageous for entrepreneurs or investors rather than people.
"I consider that I've lost," said the politician from Partai Demokrasi Indonesia Perjungan (PDIP) in a discussion in Jakarta, Tuesday (27/12).
However, this former activist is not going to give up. Budiman encouraged civil society to propose judicial review for this Law, especially on the basis of its formal flaw. "The law is not in accordance with Law No. 12 of 2011 on the Establishment of Laws and Regulations, because it did not include the Assembly Decree as a legal basis," he explained.
"The Assembly Decree is not listed in the preamble of the Land Acquisition Law. This could be the basis for filing a judicial review to the Constitutional Court (MK),"he said.
Budiman explained that after the stipulation of Law No. 12 of 2011, the Assembly Decree is re-admitted to be classified in the hierarchy of legislation. The Assembly Decree position is higher than law. The Law should refer to the Constitution and the Assembly Decree. Unfortunately, the Land Acquisition Law only refers to the Constitution and Law No. 5 of 1960 (Basic Agrarian Law).
According to Budiman, the Assembly Decree which should be referred to is Assembly Decree No. IX/MPR/2001 on Agrarian Reform and Natural Resources Management, which is of great concern to the public interest.
Noer Fauzi Rachman, member of the Board of Agrarian Reform Experts Consortium (Konsorsium Pembaruan Agraria-KPA), explained that the Assembly Decree was the result of agrarian reform activists’ struggle in the reform era. He also welcomed the reinvigorating of Assembly Decree in the legislation hierarchy so it can be enforced more.
"The Assembly Decree can be used as a tool to encourage the government to perform land reform," he said.
It is Obscure
Yuliandri, Legislation professor of Andalas University in Padang, explained that in theory the lower regulation should not be contrary to the higher regulation. Since the Assembly Decree is higher than law, a law must not conflict with the Assembly Decree. “That’s in theory,” she said.
Yuliandri also said that it is quite difficult to review a law against an Assembly Decree, because the Constitution states that law must be reviewed against the Constitution by the Constitutional Court. Moreover, Law No. 12 of2011 does not explain clearly about the definition of Assembly Decree and what would happened if a lower regulation conflicted with an Assembly Decree or if an Assembly Decree conflicted with the Constitution.
Nevertheless, Yuliandri agree that the law must refer to the relevant Assembly Decree as a legal basis. "The Land Acquisition Law should include the Assembly Decree No. IX. Formally it should be there," she concluded to hukumonline.
(Ali Salmande / Aurora Meliala)
Without including an Assembly Decree in the statute’s preamble, the Bill on Land Procurement for Public Interest is considered to contain formal defects, now that the Assembly Decree belongs to the hierarchy of legislation.
The Draft Bill on Land Procurement for Public Interest hasbeen approved by the House and the President. Severalactivists plan to propose judicial review of this law, and the status of the case is that it is waiting for numbering.
Budiman Sudjatmiko, member of Commission II of the House of Representatives, thinks that opportunities to review this Law are wide open. Budiman admitted that he was “lost” for letting this bill pass into law. In his opinion, the Law is inclined to be advantageous for entrepreneurs or investors rather than people.
"I consider that I've lost," said the politician from Partai Demokrasi Indonesia Perjungan (PDIP) in a discussion in Jakarta, Tuesday (27/12).
However, this former activist is not going to give up. Budiman encouraged civil society to propose judicial review for this Law, especially on the basis of its formal flaw. "The law is not in accordance with Law No. 12 of 2011 on the Establishment of Laws and Regulations, because it did not include the Assembly Decree as a legal basis," he explained.
"The Assembly Decree is not listed in the preamble of the Land Acquisition Law. This could be the basis for filing a judicial review to the Constitutional Court (MK),"he said.
Budiman explained that after the stipulation of Law No. 12 of 2011, the Assembly Decree is re-admitted to be classified in the hierarchy of legislation. The Assembly Decree position is higher than law. The Law should refer to the Constitution and the Assembly Decree. Unfortunately, the Land Acquisition Law only refers to the Constitution and Law No. 5 of 1960 (Basic Agrarian Law).
According to Budiman, the Assembly Decree which should be referred to is Assembly Decree No. IX/MPR/2001 on Agrarian Reform and Natural Resources Management, which is of great concern to the public interest.
Noer Fauzi Rachman, member of the Board of Agrarian Reform Experts Consortium (Konsorsium Pembaruan Agraria-KPA), explained that the Assembly Decree was the result of agrarian reform activists’ struggle in the reform era. He also welcomed the reinvigorating of Assembly Decree in the legislation hierarchy so it can be enforced more.
"The Assembly Decree can be used as a tool to encourage the government to perform land reform," he said.
It is Obscure
Yuliandri, Legislation professor of Andalas University in Padang, explained that in theory the lower regulation should not be contrary to the higher regulation. Since the Assembly Decree is higher than law, a law must not conflict with the Assembly Decree. “That’s in theory,” she said.
Yuliandri also said that it is quite difficult to review a law against an Assembly Decree, because the Constitution states that law must be reviewed against the Constitution by the Constitutional Court. Moreover, Law No. 12 of2011 does not explain clearly about the definition of Assembly Decree and what would happened if a lower regulation conflicted with an Assembly Decree or if an Assembly Decree conflicted with the Constitution.
Nevertheless, Yuliandri agree that the law must refer to the relevant Assembly Decree as a legal basis. "The Land Acquisition Law should include the Assembly Decree No. IX. Formally it should be there," she concluded to hukumonline.
(Ali Salmande / Aurora Meliala)