Members of the public expect that the Draft on Telematics Convergence will be overhauled because the substance of the bill is considered to prioritize business interests rather than ensure the rights of citizens.
Media Link Project Officer Mujtaba Hamdi and Knowledge Manager of Satu Dunia Firdaus Cahyadi stated a similar opinion at a press conference in Jakarta, Tuesday (27/12).
Firdaus argued that the draft bill, which is now in the Ministry of Justice and Human Rights to be harmonized, encourages the public consumption attitude. This can be seen from the draft bill that defines the citizen as consumer. “But Consumer Rights and the rights of citizens are far different,” he said.
According to him, the rights of consumers come up when a person buys a telematic product. Meanwhile, the preceding citizens’ telematics right is not recognized.
According to Firdaus, public opinion of telematics is only limited to the prestige of having specific hardware and software products. The bill draft would strengthen consumerism in telematics products, rather than reducing or diverting the public's perception.
The negative impact of consumerism was seen in late November 2011, when ninety people were victims in the queue of a cheap BlackBerry sale, three of them suffering broken bones.
Then, at the beginning of December 2011, Christopher Melkey??Tanujaya was killed into amurder motivated by plundering BlackBerry smart phones.
In fact, according to City Residents Forum (Facts) Jakarta, in 2010, poor people had tospend IDR 160.000 per month per family to buy credits. This amount exceeds the minimum expenditure requirement for housing, clothing, education, and health amounting to IDR 117.682.
The citizens telematics rights, for example the right to telematics infrastructure,are not clearly explained in the Bill. It is clearly mentioned in the article that government is obliged to provide universal service in remote areas. But it does not mention the rights of citizens if the government fails to perform the universal service.
According to Firdaus, telematics infrastructure in Indonesia has not been evenly distributed; it is still concentrated in Java, Sumatra, part of Borneo, and Sulawesi. As a result, efficient and transparent public Internetservice will not be affordable for people living in some areas. "For example, online National Selection of Higher Education (Seleks iNasional Masu kPerguruan Tinggi Negeri- SNMPTN)," he said.
The Capital Unification
Mujtaba highlighted that media convergence is not just a technologies convergence (information technology, telecommunications, broadcasting). "It is also about the ownership of media in certain business," he said.
Capital owners will manage the entire media supply chain, whether it relates to the content, packaging, or distribution. Employers will have an authorization through various media platforms that are distributed in a variety of means, such as radio, portals, television, or through home production.
Centralized media ownership will put the public in the position ofa spectator in the debate between one media and another. The publicwill only be counted as a consumer, and not as citizens who have the rights to information and communication.
The Telematics Convergence Bill, according to Mujtaba, will give a way for corporations to increasingly make information into a commodity, rather than protecting the interests and rights of citizens to information.
For that reason, Mujtaba said, the Draft Bill must be overhauled. "Telematics convergence regulation must protect the public interest, rather than corporate," he said.
Firdaus urged that the Draft Bill must change the paradigm on telematics—it is not just a commodity to dominate the people’s life. He added that it is necessary to revise policies that will diminish the citizens’ rights in telematics such as the Law on Information and Electronic Transactions.
Firdaus also suggested that campaigns must be held to emphasized that telematics products are not only tools of consumption, but also of production.
(Leo WisnuSusapto / Aurora Meliala)
Members of the public expect that the Draft on Telematics Convergence will be overhauled because the substance of the bill is considered to prioritize business interests rather than ensure the rights of citizens.
Media Link Project Officer Mujtaba Hamdi and Knowledge Manager of Satu Dunia Firdaus Cahyadi stated a similar opinion at a press conference in Jakarta, Tuesday (27/12).
Firdaus argued that the draft bill, which is now in the Ministry of Justice and Human Rights to be harmonized, encourages the public consumption attitude. This can be seen from the draft bill that defines the citizen as consumer. “But Consumer Rights and the rights of citizens are far different,” he said.
According to him, the rights of consumers come up when a person buys a telematic product. Meanwhile, the preceding citizens’ telematics right is not recognized.
According to Firdaus, public opinion of telematics is only limited to the prestige of having specific hardware and software products. The bill draft would strengthen consumerism in telematics products, rather than reducing or diverting the public's perception.
The negative impact of consumerism was seen in late November 2011, when ninety people were victims in the queue of a cheap BlackBerry sale, three of them suffering broken bones.
Then, at the beginning of December 2011, Christopher Melkey??Tanujaya was killed into amurder motivated by plundering BlackBerry smart phones.
In fact, according to City Residents Forum (Facts) Jakarta, in 2010, poor people had tospend IDR 160.000 per month per family to buy credits. This amount exceeds the minimum expenditure requirement for housing, clothing, education, and health amounting to IDR 117.682.
The citizens telematics rights, for example the right to telematics infrastructure,are not clearly explained in the Bill. It is clearly mentioned in the article that government is obliged to provide universal service in remote areas. But it does not mention the rights of citizens if the government fails to perform the universal service.
According to Firdaus, telematics infrastructure in Indonesia has not been evenly distributed; it is still concentrated in Java, Sumatra, part of Borneo, and Sulawesi. As a result, efficient and transparent public Internetservice will not be affordable for people living in some areas. "For example, online National Selection of Higher Education (Seleks iNasional Masu kPerguruan Tinggi Negeri- SNMPTN)," he said.
The Capital Unification
Mujtaba highlighted that media convergence is not just a technologies convergence (information technology, telecommunications, broadcasting). "It is also about the ownership of media in certain business," he said.
Capital owners will manage the entire media supply chain, whether it relates to the content, packaging, or distribution. Employers will have an authorization through various media platforms that are distributed in a variety of means, such as radio, portals, television, or through home production.
Centralized media ownership will put the public in the position ofa spectator in the debate between one media and another. The publicwill only be counted as a consumer, and not as citizens who have the rights to information and communication.
The Telematics Convergence Bill, according to Mujtaba, will give a way for corporations to increasingly make information into a commodity, rather than protecting the interests and rights of citizens to information.
For that reason, Mujtaba said, the Draft Bill must be overhauled. "Telematics convergence regulation must protect the public interest, rather than corporate," he said.
Firdaus urged that the Draft Bill must change the paradigm on telematics—it is not just a commodity to dominate the people’s life. He added that it is necessary to revise policies that will diminish the citizens’ rights in telematics such as the Law on Information and Electronic Transactions.
Firdaus also suggested that campaigns must be held to emphasized that telematics products are not only tools of consumption, but also of production.
(Leo WisnuSusapto / Aurora Meliala)