Andi Hamzah, criminal law professor at Trisakti University, believes that the Draft Criminal Code is no longer appropriate to be considered as the new Criminal Code. “We filed the Draft with the government in 1992, yet they retain it for discussion. For now, the bill is no longer relevant to discuss,” said Andi at a seminar in Jakarta, Thursday (8/12).
Though the draft is often discussed by the government, Andi argued that it is no longer suitable in light of recent developments and that it would be more appropriate to change the Draft from the beginning.
Andi explained that in the Netherlands—where the Indonesian Criminal Code originated—the Criminal Code is revised every year to adjust according to recent developments.
For example, Indonesia’s current Criminal Code only regulates scams for goods. This is different from the corresponding regulation in the Netherlands, which states that scams not only include scams relating to goods but also more modern scams relating to data and service. “In Netherlands, giving an empty check also falls under the definition of scams,” Andi added.
In the Netherlands, rape is now defined as any action to insert any part of the perpetrator’s body into another person’s body. Andi explained that according to the Netherlands’ definition, forcibly kissing someone could be classified as rape.
“The definition of rape in our Criminal Code and the Bill for its revision is no longer in accordance with the times,” he asserted.
Andi is of the view that Indonesia needs to follow the way developed countries, like the Netherlands, have revised the law. “If we went to the Netherlands in December and bought a law book, that book would be discounted 50%, due to the many changed articles in the law,” he explained.
Romli Atmasasmita, international criminal law professor at Padjadjaran University, agrees with Andi. However, he thinks that the government will still discuss the obsolete bill. “In Indonesia, even an expired food is good to be eaten”, he joked.
Romli admitted that the law in developed countries changes rapidly. “For example, when we buy a book from abroad, the substance of the revised edition in the following year is completely different. Maybe due to the low salary, Indonesian professors are too lazy to write,” Romli emphasized.
As previously reported, Amir Syamsuddin, Minister of Law and Human Rights promised to restart the discussion on the Draft Criminal Code in early 2012. As for now, the Draft is still being discussed at internal levels of government.
"We will submit the Draft Criminal Code or Criminal Procedure Law to the House, but it seems that the Draft Criminal Code has the most potential," he explained.
Legislators anxious to begin discussion regarding the Draft with the government. Ahmad Yani, member of Commission III, suggested that discussion on the Draft could be conducted in a chapter-by-chapter method starting with the first chapter, which contains general provisions.
However, Andi did not agree with this proposal. He asserted that discussion of the Draft should be carried out thoroughly .
(Ali Salmande / Aurora Meliala)
Andi Hamzah, criminal law professor at Trisakti University, believes that the Draft Criminal Code is no longer appropriate to be considered as the new Criminal Code. “We filed the Draft with the government in 1992, yet they retain it for discussion. For now, the bill is no longer relevant to discuss,” said Andi at a seminar in Jakarta, Thursday (8/12).
Though the draft is often discussed by the government, Andi argued that it is no longer suitable in light of recent developments and that it would be more appropriate to change the Draft from the beginning.
Andi explained that in the Netherlands—where the Indonesian Criminal Code originated—the Criminal Code is revised every year to adjust according to recent developments.
For example, Indonesia’s current Criminal Code only regulates scams for goods. This is different from the corresponding regulation in the Netherlands, which states that scams not only include scams relating to goods but also more modern scams relating to data and service. “In Netherlands, giving an empty check also falls under the definition of scams,” Andi added.
In the Netherlands, rape is now defined as any action to insert any part of the perpetrator’s body into another person’s body. Andi explained that according to the Netherlands’ definition, forcibly kissing someone could be classified as rape.
“The definition of rape in our Criminal Code and the Bill for its revision is no longer in accordance with the times,” he asserted.
Andi is of the view that Indonesia needs to follow the way developed countries, like the Netherlands, have revised the law. “If we went to the Netherlands in December and bought a law book, that book would be discounted 50%, due to the many changed articles in the law,” he explained.
Romli Atmasasmita, international criminal law professor at Padjadjaran University, agrees with Andi. However, he thinks that the government will still discuss the obsolete bill. “In Indonesia, even an expired food is good to be eaten”, he joked.
Romli admitted that the law in developed countries changes rapidly. “For example, when we buy a book from abroad, the substance of the revised edition in the following year is completely different. Maybe due to the low salary, Indonesian professors are too lazy to write,” Romli emphasized.
As previously reported, Amir Syamsuddin, Minister of Law and Human Rights promised to restart the discussion on the Draft Criminal Code in early 2012. As for now, the Draft is still being discussed at internal levels of government.
"We will submit the Draft Criminal Code or Criminal Procedure Law to the House, but it seems that the Draft Criminal Code has the most potential," he explained.
Legislators anxious to begin discussion regarding the Draft with the government. Ahmad Yani, member of Commission III, suggested that discussion on the Draft could be conducted in a chapter-by-chapter method starting with the first chapter, which contains general provisions.
However, Andi did not agree with this proposal. He asserted that discussion of the Draft should be carried out thoroughly .
(Ali Salmande / Aurora Meliala)