Former Minister of Justice Muladi launched his new book about the Rome Statute at the National Resilience Institute of the Republic of Indonesia, Jakarta, Monday (12/12).
Muladi’s book, 1998 Rome Statute on the Framework of International Criminal Law and Its Implications for Indonesian Criminal Law (Statuta Roma Tahun 1998 Dalam Kerangka Hukum Pidana Internasional dan Implikasinya Terhadap Hukum Pidana Nasional), discusses many issues regarding international criminal law, such as human rights courts, government responsibility, command responsibility, and the urgency of ratifying the Rome Statute. During the book launch event, the ratification issue became the center of discussion among the panelists.
Rome Statute ratification, according to Muladi, is important for Indonesia because it will improve the country’s regional and international reputation, especially with regard to Indonesia’s leadership in ASEAN.
However, Muladi’s opinion was challenged by Hikmahanto Juwana. “We already have a law regarding a human rights court, which also regulates international crimes as stated under the Rome Statute,” said the Professor of International Law from University of Indonesia.
When Hikmahanto was asked about the issues regarding Law No. 26 of 2000 on Human Rights Court, such as command responsibility in Article 42 and the translation of the word “persecution”, that is redefined as “torture”, Hikmahanto responded that the idea that command responsibility only applies two levels of command up from the direct perpetrator “is only an interpretation.”
He also asserted that command responsibility has three elements: effective command, commander’s knowledge, and commander’s failure to prohibit the perpetrator’s act. “It is not only about the level of superiority,” he explained, “those [other] elements must be fulfilled.”
Moreover, Hikmahanto stated that Law No. 1 of 1979 on Extradition does not regulate an extradition request from a non-governmental institution. Article 1 of Law 1/1979 stipulates that extradition is an official process whereby one nation or state surrenders a criminal to another nation or state. It does not state any clause regarding international organizations.
Hikmahanto also argued that it is not necessary to ratify the Rome Statute. Instead, he recommended an amendment of Law 26/2000. “The internal issues of the country must be solved without any intervention,” he stated.
Aziz Syamsuddin, Deputy Chairman of Commission III of the House, agreed with Hikmahanto’s opinion. He explained that Indonesia has a law on a human rights court, despite its imperfections, and it is better to improve it than to ratify the Rome Statute.
It has been our habit, Aziz stated, “to settle an internal issue at the international level. State sovereignty is much more important than international relations.”
In contrast, Ifdhal Kasim, Head of the Indonesian National Commission on Human Rights, stated that Rome Statute ratification is not something to worry about. He explained that the nature of International Criminal Court (ICC) jurisdiction under the Rome Statute is complementary. International crimes that are conducted domestically can only be referred to the ICC if a country is unable or unwilling to prosecute them.
“Moreover, the ratification will protect Indonesian citizens in foreign countries such as laborers and peacekeeping forces, if they become the victims of international crimes,” Ifdhal added.
Meanwhile, Agus Widjaja, former Territorial Chief of Staff of Indonesian Armed Forces (TNI), argued that the legal process in the ICC is vulnerable to political intervention. “That’s why Indonesia needs more time to ratify the Rome Statute,” Agus stated.
The Rome Statute was adopted on 17 July 1998 and entered into force on 1 July 2002. As of October 2011, the Rome Statute has been signed by 139 states; 119 states have ratified it.
According to the ICC’s official website, the Court has conducted investigations in seven states: Democratic Republic of the Congo, Central African Republic, Uganda, Sudan, Republic of Kenya, Libya, and Republic of Côte d'Ivoire. In the latest developments, ICC has taken custody of Laurent Gbagbo, former president of the Republic of Côte d'Ivoire.
Indonesia planned to ratify the Rome Statute under the 2004-2009 National Action Plan for Human Rights (Rencana Aksi Nasional Hak Asasi Manusia - RANHAM). However, the ratification effort failed. The plan is restated in the 2011-2014 RANHAM, and ratification might be achieved by 2013.
(Pirhot Nababan / Aurora Meliala)
Former Minister of Justice Muladi launched his new book about the Rome Statute at the National Resilience Institute of the Republic of Indonesia, Jakarta, Monday (12/12).
Muladi’s book, 1998 Rome Statute on the Framework of International Criminal Law and Its Implications for Indonesian Criminal Law (Statuta Roma Tahun 1998 Dalam Kerangka Hukum Pidana Internasional dan Implikasinya Terhadap Hukum Pidana Nasional), discusses many issues regarding international criminal law, such as human rights courts, government responsibility, command responsibility, and the urgency of ratifying the Rome Statute. During the book launch event, the ratification issue became the center of discussion among the panelists.
Rome Statute ratification, according to Muladi, is important for Indonesia because it will improve the country’s regional and international reputation, especially with regard to Indonesia’s leadership in ASEAN.
However, Muladi’s opinion was challenged by Hikmahanto Juwana. “We already have a law regarding a human rights court, which also regulates international crimes as stated under the Rome Statute,” said the Professor of International Law from University of Indonesia.
When Hikmahanto was asked about the issues regarding Law No. 26 of 2000 on Human Rights Court, such as command responsibility in Article 42 and the translation of the word “persecution”, that is redefined as “torture”, Hikmahanto responded that the idea that command responsibility only applies two levels of command up from the direct perpetrator “is only an interpretation.”
He also asserted that command responsibility has three elements: effective command, commander’s knowledge, and commander’s failure to prohibit the perpetrator’s act. “It is not only about the level of superiority,” he explained, “those [other] elements must be fulfilled.”
Moreover, Hikmahanto stated that Law No. 1 of 1979 on Extradition does not regulate an extradition request from a non-governmental institution. Article 1 of Law 1/1979 stipulates that extradition is an official process whereby one nation or state surrenders a criminal to another nation or state. It does not state any clause regarding international organizations.
Hikmahanto also argued that it is not necessary to ratify the Rome Statute. Instead, he recommended an amendment of Law 26/2000. “The internal issues of the country must be solved without any intervention,” he stated.
Aziz Syamsuddin, Deputy Chairman of Commission III of the House, agreed with Hikmahanto’s opinion. He explained that Indonesia has a law on a human rights court, despite its imperfections, and it is better to improve it than to ratify the Rome Statute.
It has been our habit, Aziz stated, “to settle an internal issue at the international level. State sovereignty is much more important than international relations.”
In contrast, Ifdhal Kasim, Head of the Indonesian National Commission on Human Rights, stated that Rome Statute ratification is not something to worry about. He explained that the nature of International Criminal Court (ICC) jurisdiction under the Rome Statute is complementary. International crimes that are conducted domestically can only be referred to the ICC if a country is unable or unwilling to prosecute them.
“Moreover, the ratification will protect Indonesian citizens in foreign countries such as laborers and peacekeeping forces, if they become the victims of international crimes,” Ifdhal added.
Meanwhile, Agus Widjaja, former Territorial Chief of Staff of Indonesian Armed Forces (TNI), argued that the legal process in the ICC is vulnerable to political intervention. “That’s why Indonesia needs more time to ratify the Rome Statute,” Agus stated.
The Rome Statute was adopted on 17 July 1998 and entered into force on 1 July 2002. As of October 2011, the Rome Statute has been signed by 139 states; 119 states have ratified it.
According to the ICC’s official website, the Court has conducted investigations in seven states: Democratic Republic of the Congo, Central African Republic, Uganda, Sudan, Republic of Kenya, Libya, and Republic of Côte d'Ivoire. In the latest developments, ICC has taken custody of Laurent Gbagbo, former president of the Republic of Côte d'Ivoire.
Indonesia planned to ratify the Rome Statute under the 2004-2009 National Action Plan for Human Rights (Rencana Aksi Nasional Hak Asasi Manusia - RANHAM). However, the ratification effort failed. The plan is restated in the 2011-2014 RANHAM, and ratification might be achieved by 2013.
(Pirhot Nababan / Aurora Meliala)