Law No. 7 of 2011 on Currency (Currency Law), which was passed on May 31, 2011, has created uncertainties for various parties, including Bank Indonesia (BI). BI contends that the Currency Law contains ambiguities and that Articles 21 and 23 are confusing.
Rosalia Suci, BI Senior Investigator at the Directorate of Banking Investigations and Mediation, asserted that neither article contains specific definitions regarding the type of transaction that is regulation. She made this statement during a public explanation on the Currency Law held at the Ministry of Finance, Jakarta, Tuesday (6/12).
"It is unclear, whether it applies to cash or non-cash transactions," said Rosalia. In addition, Article 23 (2) is ambiguous.
Article 21
(1) Rupiah shall be used in:
a. Any payment transaction;
b. Settlement of other obligations that must be met with money; and/or
c. Any other transaction by a financial institution.
(2) The obligation in paragraph (1) does not apply to:
a. Certain transactions involving the use of state budget revenues and expenditures;
b. The acceptance or disbursal of a foreign grant or grant to a foreign recipient;
c. International trade transactions;
d. Foreign currency deposits in banks;
e. International financial transactions.
Article 23
(1) Any person is prohibited from refusing to accept Rupiah for payment transactions or transactions to fulfill an obligation in Rupiah and/or for any other financial transaction in the Republic of Indonesia, unless there are doubts over the authenticity of the Rupiah.
(2) The provisions in paragraph (1) exclude payments or the settlement of liabilities in foreign currency that have been agreed to in writing.
Rosalia explained that Articles 21 and 23 are problematic, because the penalty for violating the articles is unclear and they create legal risks that might harm businessmen and society.
However, according to BI’s interpretation, Articles 21 and 23 only apply to cash payments. Meanwhile, in a contrario, non-cash payment parties are free to use currencies other than rupiah. If this is true, said Rosalia, it is not in accordance with ideals of rupiah sovereignty.
In response, BI offered several alternative solutions such as issuing an amendment to the Currency Law or a government regulation in lieu of law (peraturan pemerintah pengganti undang-undang). The government could also interpret the Currency Law in a government regulation. This regulation will be used as a guide for all parties.
On the other hand, Tata Suntara, the Secretary of the Directorate General of Treasury at the Ministry of Finance, denied the confusion over the Currency Law. He stated that it is clear enough. The transaction in the Currency Law refers to cash transactions using currency—bank notes and coins.
"In my opinion, this Law is clear and not confusing. The transactions that are contemplated in the Law are cash transactions. Foreign currency savings may use the US dollar as stipulated in Article 21 (2), which describes the exceptions for the cash transactions,” said Tata.
Meanwhile, Tata stated that the use of scriptural money (uang giral) is not regulated in the Law on Currency. It is clear then, he explained, the transactions covered by the Law on Currency are the cash transactions.
Based on an assessment of the Currency Law’s academic draft and the agreement between the Government and the House, it would be more appropriate to regulate scriptural money in a law regarding payment systems.
“It will be better under a different law. However, I don’t really understand the rules of demand deposits,“ Tata said.
Meanwhile, the term ‘agreement in writing’ in Article 23 means parties will have the freedom to contract and agree to any legitimate agreement. The freedom to contract is governed by Article 1338 (1) of the Indonesian Civil Code, which states, "any legitimate agreement must be applied as the law for each party who made it".
However, the freedom of contract and use foreign currencies is limited; because it may lead to rupiah devaluation.
Soeprayitno, Chairman of the Indonesian Employers Association (APINDO) Jakarta, Soeprayitno gave a positive response to Currency Law. According to him, this is one way for the government to increase the use of rupiah for cash transactions in Indonesia.
"I admit that this is a positive government effort. However, the government should pay attention to SMEs because use cash transactions frequently. Explanations will be required to avoid during implementation”, he said.
From employers’ viewpoint, Soeprayitno admitted that the Currency Law would not be so influential in the world of business, especially for big businesses. Since big businesses use more non-cash transactions.
Soeprayitno was reluctant to comment on the legal risks associated with the Currency Law. "I have not read the whole Law on Currency, so I can not comment on the legal risks to businesses," replied Soeprayitno via cell phone.
(Fitri Novia Heriani / Aurora Meliala)
Law No. 7 of 2011 on Currency (Currency Law), which was passed on May 31, 2011, has created uncertainties for various parties, including Bank Indonesia (BI). BI contends that the Currency Law contains ambiguities and that Articles 21 and 23 are confusing.
Rosalia Suci, BI Senior Investigator at the Directorate of Banking Investigations and Mediation, asserted that neither article contains specific definitions regarding the type of transaction that is regulation. She made this statement during a public explanation on the Currency Law held at the Ministry of Finance, Jakarta, Tuesday (6/12).
"It is unclear, whether it applies to cash or non-cash transactions," said Rosalia. In addition, Article 23 (2) is ambiguous.
Article 21
(1) Rupiah shall be used in:
a. Any payment transaction;
b. Settlement of other obligations that must be met with money; and/or
c. Any other transaction by a financial institution.
(2) The obligation in paragraph (1) does not apply to:
a. Certain transactions involving the use of state budget revenues and expenditures;
b. The acceptance or disbursal of a foreign grant or grant to a foreign recipient;
c. International trade transactions;
d. Foreign currency deposits in banks;
e. International financial transactions.
Article 23
(1) Any person is prohibited from refusing to accept Rupiah for payment transactions or transactions to fulfill an obligation in Rupiah and/or for any other financial transaction in the Republic of Indonesia, unless there are doubts over the authenticity of the Rupiah.
(2) The provisions in paragraph (1) exclude payments or the settlement of liabilities in foreign currency that have been agreed to in writing.
Rosalia explained that Articles 21 and 23 are problematic, because the penalty for violating the articles is unclear and they create legal risks that might harm businessmen and society.
However, according to BI’s interpretation, Articles 21 and 23 only apply to cash payments. Meanwhile, in a contrario, non-cash payment parties are free to use currencies other than rupiah. If this is true, said Rosalia, it is not in accordance with ideals of rupiah sovereignty.
In response, BI offered several alternative solutions such as issuing an amendment to the Currency Law or a government regulation in lieu of law (peraturan pemerintah pengganti undang-undang). The government could also interpret the Currency Law in a government regulation. This regulation will be used as a guide for all parties.
On the other hand, Tata Suntara, the Secretary of the Directorate General of Treasury at the Ministry of Finance, denied the confusion over the Currency Law. He stated that it is clear enough. The transaction in the Currency Law refers to cash transactions using currency—bank notes and coins.
"In my opinion, this Law is clear and not confusing. The transactions that are contemplated in the Law are cash transactions. Foreign currency savings may use the US dollar as stipulated in Article 21 (2), which describes the exceptions for the cash transactions,” said Tata.
Meanwhile, Tata stated that the use of scriptural money (uang giral) is not regulated in the Law on Currency. It is clear then, he explained, the transactions covered by the Law on Currency are the cash transactions.
Based on an assessment of the Currency Law’s academic draft and the agreement between the Government and the House, it would be more appropriate to regulate scriptural money in a law regarding payment systems.
“It will be better under a different law. However, I don’t really understand the rules of demand deposits,“ Tata said.
Meanwhile, the term ‘agreement in writing’ in Article 23 means parties will have the freedom to contract and agree to any legitimate agreement. The freedom to contract is governed by Article 1338 (1) of the Indonesian Civil Code, which states, "any legitimate agreement must be applied as the law for each party who made it".
However, the freedom of contract and use foreign currencies is limited; because it may lead to rupiah devaluation.
Soeprayitno, Chairman of the Indonesian Employers Association (APINDO) Jakarta, Soeprayitno gave a positive response to Currency Law. According to him, this is one way for the government to increase the use of rupiah for cash transactions in Indonesia.
"I admit that this is a positive government effort. However, the government should pay attention to SMEs because use cash transactions frequently. Explanations will be required to avoid during implementation”, he said.
From employers’ viewpoint, Soeprayitno admitted that the Currency Law would not be so influential in the world of business, especially for big businesses. Since big businesses use more non-cash transactions.
Soeprayitno was reluctant to comment on the legal risks associated with the Currency Law. "I have not read the whole Law on Currency, so I can not comment on the legal risks to businesses," replied Soeprayitno via cell phone.
(Fitri Novia Heriani / Aurora Meliala)