After the issuance of the Bill on Currency, Bank Indonesia sent a letter regarding problems with the Bill to the President. The Bill was signed by the President, and is now called Law No. 7 of 2011 on Currency ("Currency Law").
"We also sent the letter to the Minister of Law and Human Rights and several other related ministers," said Ahmad Fuad, Director of Law at Bank Indonesia, at a hukumonline seminar on the Currency Law held in Jakarta, Thursday (24/11).
Fuad told the audience that the letter pointed out some concerns that arose after the Bill passed the Parliament that have to be solved by the government.
According to Fuad, Bank Indonesia received many questions about the Currency Law, particularly with regard to Articles 21 and 23. "The people who sent complaints are [mainly] afraid of the threat of criminalization if they are using other currencies besides rupiah for their business transactions. We, however, declined to answer," Fuad explained.
Fuad emphasized that Bank Indonesia was not asked for its opinion, and was not asked to be a member of the drafting committee, in the initial drafting process of the Currency Law. Therefore, Fuad said, all questions were forwarded to the Ministry of Finance, who drafted the law.
Because of its many problems, Fuad said that amendment of Articles 21 and 23 is the best solution. Otherwise, someone may file for judicial review. "If this law is reviewed at the Constitutional Court, the problems are getting worse," Fuad asserted.
Meanwhile, Timur Sukirno, a lawyer from Hadiputranto Hadinoto and Partners, expressed his confusion regarding Articles 21 and 23, particularly over the terms "payment" (pembayaran) and "obligation settlement" (penyelesaian kewajiban).
Timur is of the view that Article 23 provisions on “payment” are more general than Article 21 provisions on “transactions for purpose of payment.” However, it is confusing, he said, when a legislation uses the same terms but with different meanings.
Timur also stated that there is a legal vacuum due to the wording of those two articles. In his opinion, "Article 23 (2) will be used, because it has more general meaning."
He recommended applying Article 23 (2) so that the transaction cannot be criminalized. "An exception can be created for the use of foreign currency that is stated in a written contract," Timur emphasized.
WHO IS THE TARGET?
Hikmahanto Juwana, a lecturer at Universitas Indonesia Faculty of Law, also expressed his confusion. "Who is the target of the Currency Law?" he asked.
The Currency Law implementation, Hikmahanto said, will criminalize Indonesian citizens located in border areas, who rarely use rupiah to cover their living costs. "It should be noted that they are low-class citizens," Hikmahanto asserted.
Meanwhile, Hikmahanto explained, wealthier citizens can easily avoid criminalization because of their access to banking services. "The upper-middle class is using Law No. 3 of 2011 on Fund Transfer to avoid criminalization."
Hikmahanto also highlighted the inconsistency between the draft and final versions of the Currency Law. He quoted the academic draft that explained “legal tender” in Article 2 of Law No. 3 of 2004 on the Amendment of Law No. 23 of 1999 on Bank Indonesia. That Article stipulates an obligation to use rupiah as a payment tool and a prohibition on rejecting payment in rupiah.
Hikmahanto is of the view that the Currency Law cannot be implemented yet because Article 47 mandates the issuance of implementing regulations one year after the law enters into force. The exact date is 28 June 2012.
Rudi Wibowo, an official at the Directorate General of the Treasury, agreed that the Currency Law regulates cash transactions only. "This is the government's official position that will be emphasized” when the Currency Law is explained to the public in December 2011, he said.
(Leo Wisnu Susapto / Pirhot Nababan)
After the issuance of the Bill on Currency, Bank Indonesia sent a letter regarding problems with the Bill to the President. The Bill was signed by the President, and is now called Law No. 7 of 2011 on Currency ("Currency Law").
"We also sent the letter to the Minister of Law and Human Rights and several other related ministers," said Ahmad Fuad, Director of Law at Bank Indonesia, at a hukumonline seminar on the Currency Law held in Jakarta, Thursday (24/11).
Fuad told the audience that the letter pointed out some concerns that arose after the Bill passed the Parliament that have to be solved by the government.
According to Fuad, Bank Indonesia received many questions about the Currency Law, particularly with regard to Articles 21 and 23. "The people who sent complaints are [mainly] afraid of the threat of criminalization if they are using other currencies besides rupiah for their business transactions. We, however, declined to answer," Fuad explained.
Fuad emphasized that Bank Indonesia was not asked for its opinion, and was not asked to be a member of the drafting committee, in the initial drafting process of the Currency Law. Therefore, Fuad said, all questions were forwarded to the Ministry of Finance, who drafted the law.
Because of its many problems, Fuad said that amendment of Articles 21 and 23 is the best solution. Otherwise, someone may file for judicial review. "If this law is reviewed at the Constitutional Court, the problems are getting worse," Fuad asserted.
Meanwhile, Timur Sukirno, a lawyer from Hadiputranto Hadinoto and Partners, expressed his confusion regarding Articles 21 and 23, particularly over the terms "payment" (pembayaran) and "obligation settlement" (penyelesaian kewajiban).
Timur is of the view that Article 23 provisions on “payment” are more general than Article 21 provisions on “transactions for purpose of payment.” However, it is confusing, he said, when a legislation uses the same terms but with different meanings.
Timur also stated that there is a legal vacuum due to the wording of those two articles. In his opinion, "Article 23 (2) will be used, because it has more general meaning."
He recommended applying Article 23 (2) so that the transaction cannot be criminalized. "An exception can be created for the use of foreign currency that is stated in a written contract," Timur emphasized.
WHO IS THE TARGET?
Hikmahanto Juwana, a lecturer at Universitas Indonesia Faculty of Law, also expressed his confusion. "Who is the target of the Currency Law?" he asked.
The Currency Law implementation, Hikmahanto said, will criminalize Indonesian citizens located in border areas, who rarely use rupiah to cover their living costs. "It should be noted that they are low-class citizens," Hikmahanto asserted.
Meanwhile, Hikmahanto explained, wealthier citizens can easily avoid criminalization because of their access to banking services. "The upper-middle class is using Law No. 3 of 2011 on Fund Transfer to avoid criminalization."
Hikmahanto also highlighted the inconsistency between the draft and final versions of the Currency Law. He quoted the academic draft that explained “legal tender” in Article 2 of Law No. 3 of 2004 on the Amendment of Law No. 23 of 1999 on Bank Indonesia. That Article stipulates an obligation to use rupiah as a payment tool and a prohibition on rejecting payment in rupiah.
Hikmahanto is of the view that the Currency Law cannot be implemented yet because Article 47 mandates the issuance of implementing regulations one year after the law enters into force. The exact date is 28 June 2012.
Rudi Wibowo, an official at the Directorate General of the Treasury, agreed that the Currency Law regulates cash transactions only. "This is the government's official position that will be emphasized” when the Currency Law is explained to the public in December 2011, he said.
(Leo Wisnu Susapto / Pirhot Nababan)