Rome Statute Ratification is Urgent

Pirhot Nababan

Even though the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court ("Rome Statute") has entered into force nine years ago, many democratic nations have not signed or ratified the Rome Statute. This includes Indonesia, along with United States of America, Russia, and other countries.

In terms of human rights protection, since year 2000 Indonesia has enacted Law No. 26 of 2000 on Human Rights Court ("Law 26/2000"). However, it has not sufficiently uphold human rights enforcement.

"Law 26/2000 is a contradictive legislation, due to its reckless interpretation of the Rome Statute," said Bhatara Ibnu Reza, international law lecturer at Pelita Harapan University, at the Media Workshop and Lobby Works on ICC, in Jakarta, Thursday (17/11).

Bhatara explained crucial points regarding the weakness of law 26/2000, particularly on crimes against humanity, command responsibility, persecution, criminal procedure, and the establishment of an ad hoc human rights court.

Under the Rome Statute, Bhatara said, intended attacks against civilian is one of the elements of crimes against humanity, which is stipulated under Article 7 (2) (a) of the Rome Statute, "Attack directed against any civilian population".

"However, Article 9 of Law 26/2000 states attack that is aimed directly against civilian population. In other words, Law 26/2000 is addressed for field actors rather than high-level commander," he asserted.

Furthermore, command responsibility clause under Article 42 of Law 26/2000, can be interpreted being applied only to two level of command above the field officer. Bhatara explained that command responsibility is not merely two levels, but also from a high-ranking official in higher level of command.

Persecution, which is stated under Article 7 (2) (g) of Rome Statute, is translated as torture [penganiayaan] under Law 26/2000. Bhatara asserted that persecution is not similar to torture.

"Law 26/2000 uses Criminal Procedural Law for its procedure, whereas it is not in line with the human rights court at international level. For example, Slobodan Milosevic's oration can be used as evidence, while such evidence can not be used in Indonesia," Bhatara emphasized.

The estabilshment of an ad hoc human rights court under Law 26/2000 is also crucial, since it has to be approved by the parliament. "It is not correct if legal problems such as human rights violation is decided through a political process," Bhatara said.

The urgency of ratification
Problems regarding provisions under Law 26/2000 are evident that ratifying the Rome Statute is crucial to Indonesia. The effort to ratify it has been included in the 2004-2009 Human Rights National Action Plan (Rencana Aksi Nasional Hak Asasi Manusia - RANHAM), even though it failed. The ratification plan is still included in the 2011-2014 RANHAM.

"If Indonesia ratified it, serious crimes actors will be threaten," said Usman Hamid, member of the International Center for Transitional Justice, at the same occasion.

Usman further added that the existence of the International Criminal Court ("ICC") will help many nations to maintain peace and security in their regions. It will also strengthen the national criminal justice system to overcome serious crimes.

"It should be noted that ICC is not taking over prosecution and trial of a national legal system. It will only happen when a state is unable and unwilling to prosecute serious crimes actors," Usman asserted.

These conditions—unable and unwilling—should be declared by the state itself. "The ICC can't just intervene without the consent of the state," Usman explained.

Mugiyanto, Coordinator for Indonesia ICC Coalition, also explained that if the Rome Statute is ratified, it cannot be used to prosecute past crimes, since the non-retroactive principle is used by the Rome Statute. The ratification also protects Indonesian citizens in foreign countries, such as migrant workers and peacekeeping forces.

Moreover, Usman said that the ratification could make Indonesia an important actor in international justice issues, considering the absence of the United States, China, and Russia.

In regards to ratifying the Rome Statute, Bhatara added that many states tend to "copy-pasting" or transforming the Rome Statute into their national legal system, instead of ratifying it.

Meanwhile, Michael Tene, Spokesperson of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, said that the government has showed its willingness to ratify the Rome Statute. This willingness is clearly stated under the 2011-2014 RANHAM.

"The ratification process still needs a comprehensive discussion between related institutions, both governmental and non-governmental institutions," Michael explained.

However, Michael cannot estimate when the ratification will happen, since there are unfinished discussions to support the ratification.

As of October 2011, Rome Statute has been signed by 139 states; 119 states have ratified it. According to ICC official website, ICC has conducted investigation in seven states which are Democratic Republic of the Congo, Central African Republic, Uganda, Sudan, Republic of Kenya, Libya, and Republic of Côte d'Ivoire.

(ds/am)

Pirhot Nababan

Even though the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court ("Rome Statute") has entered into force nine years ago, many democratic nations have not signed or ratified the Rome Statute. This includes Indonesia, along with United States of America, Russia, and other countries.

In terms of human rights protection, since year 2000 Indonesia has enacted Law No. 26 of 2000 on Human Rights Court ("Law 26/2000"). However, it has not sufficiently uphold human rights enforcement.

"Law 26/2000 is a contradictive legislation, due to its reckless interpretation of the Rome Statute," said Bhatara Ibnu Reza, international law lecturer at Pelita Harapan University, at the Media Workshop and Lobby Works on ICC, in Jakarta, Thursday (17/11).

Bhatara explained crucial points regarding the weakness of law 26/2000, particularly on crimes against humanity, command responsibility, persecution, criminal procedure, and the establishment of an ad hoc human rights court.

Under the Rome Statute, Bhatara said, intended attacks against civilian is one of the elements of crimes against humanity, which is stipulated under Article 7 (2) (a) of the Rome Statute, "Attack directed against any civilian population".

"However, Article 9 of Law 26/2000 states attack that is aimed directly against civilian population. In other words, Law 26/2000 is addressed for field actors rather than high-level commander," he asserted.

Furthermore, command responsibility clause under Article 42 of Law 26/2000, can be interpreted being applied only to two level of command above the field officer. Bhatara explained that command responsibility is not merely two levels, but also from a high-ranking official in higher level of command.

Persecution, which is stated under Article 7 (2) (g) of Rome Statute, is translated as torture [penganiayaan] under Law 26/2000. Bhatara asserted that persecution is not similar to torture.

"Law 26/2000 uses Criminal Procedural Law for its procedure, whereas it is not in line with the human rights court at international level. For example, Slobodan Milosevic's oration can be used as evidence, while such evidence can not be used in Indonesia," Bhatara emphasized.

The estabilshment of an ad hoc human rights court under Law 26/2000 is also crucial, since it has to be approved by the parliament. "It is not correct if legal problems such as human rights violation is decided through a political process," Bhatara said.

The urgency of ratification
Problems regarding provisions under Law 26/2000 are evident that ratifying the Rome Statute is crucial to Indonesia. The effort to ratify it has been included in the 2004-2009 Human Rights National Action Plan (Rencana Aksi Nasional Hak Asasi Manusia - RANHAM), even though it failed. The ratification plan is still included in the 2011-2014 RANHAM.

"If Indonesia ratified it, serious crimes actors will be threaten," said Usman Hamid, member of the International Center for Transitional Justice, at the same occasion.

Usman further added that the existence of the International Criminal Court ("ICC") will help many nations to maintain peace and security in their regions. It will also strengthen the national criminal justice system to overcome serious crimes.

"It should be noted that ICC is not taking over prosecution and trial of a national legal system. It will only happen when a state is unable and unwilling to prosecute serious crimes actors," Usman asserted.

These conditions—unable and unwilling—should be declared by the state itself. "The ICC can't just intervene without the consent of the state," Usman explained.

Mugiyanto, Coordinator for Indonesia ICC Coalition, also explained that if the Rome Statute is ratified, it cannot be used to prosecute past crimes, since the non-retroactive principle is used by the Rome Statute. The ratification also protects Indonesian citizens in foreign countries, such as migrant workers and peacekeeping forces.

Moreover, Usman said that the ratification could make Indonesia an important actor in international justice issues, considering the absence of the United States, China, and Russia.

In regards to ratifying the Rome Statute, Bhatara added that many states tend to "copy-pasting" or transforming the Rome Statute into their national legal system, instead of ratifying it.

Meanwhile, Michael Tene, Spokesperson of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, said that the government has showed its willingness to ratify the Rome Statute. This willingness is clearly stated under the 2011-2014 RANHAM.

"The ratification process still needs a comprehensive discussion between related institutions, both governmental and non-governmental institutions," Michael explained.

However, Michael cannot estimate when the ratification will happen, since there are unfinished discussions to support the ratification.

As of October 2011, Rome Statute has been signed by 139 states; 119 states have ratified it. According to ICC official website, ICC has conducted investigation in seven states which are Democratic Republic of the Congo, Central African Republic, Uganda, Sudan, Republic of Kenya, Libya, and Republic of Côte d'Ivoire.

(ds/am)
2026 Hak Cipta Milik Hukumonline.com
Cookies Info