The Bench Does Not Comprehend International Arbitral Awards

Twelve years after the enactment of Law No. 30 of 1999 on Arbitration and Alternative Dispute Resolution (Arbitration Law), many of the law’s weaknesses have been revealed through its implementation. Most noticeable is the difficulty with enforcement of foreign arbitral awards.  

According to Mutiara Hikmah, an Universitas Indonesia law lecturer who wrote her doctoral dissertation on the enforcement of international arbitral awards, the difficulty can be attributed to general weaknesses in the law itself as well as to poorly-prepared human resources, namely the judges who handle petitions requesting to overrule or enforce an award.   

There are many reasons that parties choose to resolve their disputes through arbitration. Chief among them is the fact that prevailing legislation provides a mechanism to enforce arbitration awards through the courts. Nowadays, even state owned companies doing business with foreign firms choose arbitration to resolve their contract disputes, albeit with Indonesian law as the governing law.    

In her research, Mutiara conducted a thorough analysis of petitions requesting to overrule foreign arbitral awards and acquired primary anecdotal data through interviews with stakeholders. Her research revealed that there were at least 29 petitions filed with the Central Jakarta District Court (“CJDC”), the only court authorized to process such petitions. Not all of the petitions were granted, but seven petitions remain hung.

Based on her research, Mutiara concluded that the Arbitration Law has several weaknesses, and it has not been effective in protecting the enforcement rights of parties. Indonesia ratified the 1958 New York Convention on Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards through the issuance of Presidential Decree No. 34 of 1981.

In comparison to the New York Convention, the Arbitration Law’s provisions on the grounds for denying enforcement cannot be said to be comprehensive. For example, invalid arbitration agreements are not addressed in the Arbitration Law.

Mutiara identified three additional weaknesses. First, the terms as defined in Article 1 are unclear. For instance, what constitutes an international arbitral award, a public order, challenging an arbitral award by denial, or overruling an award are all poorly elucidated. Unclear definitions may be prove fatal in some cases, especially if judges have different interpretations regarding national or international arbitration.  

The second weakness regards Article 67 (1), which stipulates the registration and rendering process needed for legal recognition of an arbitral award. “Arbitrators from other countries, or their legal representatives, must register their [own] arbitral awards with the Central Jakarta District Court,” Mutiara says, but in reality, they have little incentive to do so. In practice, the petitioner requesting enforcement is left to register the award.

Third, there is no strict time limit to review an international arbitral award or to acquire an authorization of execution (penetapan eksekusi). This lack of clarity has resulted in several arbitral awards remaining hung or undecided.

Human Resources on the Bench

Supreme Court Regulation No. 1 of 1990 on the Procedure in Enforcing a Foreign Arbitral Award plays a significant role in the Chairman of the CJDC’s decisions whether to deny or enforce an arbitral award. However, in practice it is still problematic.

One of the problems, says Mutiara, is the human resources on the bench. Judges who understand international private law, specifically international arbitration, are very few, not only at the CJDC, but even at the Supreme Court.

Frequent transfer and promotion play a role, affording fewer judges the time needed to master the legal aspects of international arbitration, including the New York Convention and other similar laws.

Should there be a will to revise the Arbitration Law, Mutiara hopes that the weakness of the law will be addressed before foreign investors are reluctant to invest in Indonesia.  

(Muhammad Yasin / Davidson Samosir)

Twelve years after the enactment of Law No. 30 of 1999 on Arbitration and Alternative Dispute Resolution (Arbitration Law), many of the law’s weaknesses have been revealed through its implementation. Most noticeable is the difficulty with enforcement of foreign arbitral awards.  

According to Mutiara Hikmah, an Universitas Indonesia law lecturer who wrote her doctoral dissertation on the enforcement of international arbitral awards, the difficulty can be attributed to general weaknesses in the law itself as well as to poorly-prepared human resources, namely the judges who handle petitions requesting to overrule or enforce an award.   

There are many reasons that parties choose to resolve their disputes through arbitration. Chief among them is the fact that prevailing legislation provides a mechanism to enforce arbitration awards through the courts. Nowadays, even state owned companies doing business with foreign firms choose arbitration to resolve their contract disputes, albeit with Indonesian law as the governing law.    

In her research, Mutiara conducted a thorough analysis of petitions requesting to overrule foreign arbitral awards and acquired primary anecdotal data through interviews with stakeholders. Her research revealed that there were at least 29 petitions filed with the Central Jakarta District Court (“CJDC”), the only court authorized to process such petitions. Not all of the petitions were granted, but seven petitions remain hung.

Based on her research, Mutiara concluded that the Arbitration Law has several weaknesses, and it has not been effective in protecting the enforcement rights of parties. Indonesia ratified the 1958 New York Convention on Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards through the issuance of Presidential Decree No. 34 of 1981.

In comparison to the New York Convention, the Arbitration Law’s provisions on the grounds for denying enforcement cannot be said to be comprehensive. For example, invalid arbitration agreements are not addressed in the Arbitration Law.

Mutiara identified three additional weaknesses. First, the terms as defined in Article 1 are unclear. For instance, what constitutes an international arbitral award, a public order, challenging an arbitral award by denial, or overruling an award are all poorly elucidated. Unclear definitions may be prove fatal in some cases, especially if judges have different interpretations regarding national or international arbitration.  

The second weakness regards Article 67 (1), which stipulates the registration and rendering process needed for legal recognition of an arbitral award. “Arbitrators from other countries, or their legal representatives, must register their [own] arbitral awards with the Central Jakarta District Court,” Mutiara says, but in reality, they have little incentive to do so. In practice, the petitioner requesting enforcement is left to register the award.

Third, there is no strict time limit to review an international arbitral award or to acquire an authorization of execution (penetapan eksekusi). This lack of clarity has resulted in several arbitral awards remaining hung or undecided.

Human Resources on the Bench

Supreme Court Regulation No. 1 of 1990 on the Procedure in Enforcing a Foreign Arbitral Award plays a significant role in the Chairman of the CJDC’s decisions whether to deny or enforce an arbitral award. However, in practice it is still problematic.

One of the problems, says Mutiara, is the human resources on the bench. Judges who understand international private law, specifically international arbitration, are very few, not only at the CJDC, but even at the Supreme Court.

Frequent transfer and promotion play a role, affording fewer judges the time needed to master the legal aspects of international arbitration, including the New York Convention and other similar laws.

Should there be a will to revise the Arbitration Law, Mutiara hopes that the weakness of the law will be addressed before foreign investors are reluctant to invest in Indonesia.  

(Muhammad Yasin / Davidson Samosir)

2026 Hak Cipta Milik Hukumonline.com
Cookies Info