Telkomsel Claims it Received Silent Approval to Deduct Phone Credits

 

A lawsuit filed by David Tobing against Telkomsel started in the District Court of South Jakarta this Thursday (17/11).  David claims Telkomsel deducted credits from his phone without his approval. However, Ignatius Andy, Telkomsel’s lawyer, argued that David had given his implied consent and asked the Panel of Judges to reject the plaintiff’s claim.

In his lawsuit, David claims that Telkomsel has been deducting phone credits from his phone without his consent. He finally got fed up when he received a short message from Telkomsel on Saturday, 16 July 2011, with the following message “Thank you for subscribing to Mini Opera for IDR 10,000/7-days. Terms/Conditions apply, contact *363#. To stop type OP OFF (and send) to 3636. To download, click http://mini.opera.com”

David was surprised to receive this SMS, because he has never subscribed to the Opera Mini service on his BlackBerry mobile. After this, David lost IDR 10,000 worth of cell phone credits every week, as evident in his HALO card monthly phone bill. When David submitted his claim, his cell phone credit had already been cut nine times.

During the trial, the Telkomsel rejected the plaintiff’s arguments, especially those regarding the activation of Opera Mini services. The defendant argues that David requested the service subscription. According to Ignatius, the Plaintiff consented to activating the Opera Mini service even extended the subscription period. The proof is that the plaintiff never asked Telkomsel to end the subscription.

Ignatius said that the plaintiff could have easily stopped subscribing to the Opera Mini Service, “by typing OP OFF and sending it to the access number 3636 free of charge. However, the plaintiff never stopped subscribing,” he said. 

In addition, Andi explained that the plaintiff was recorded to have called Telkomsel customer services four times. At the time, the plaintiff did ask about the Opera Mini application. Customer service had already given him information about canceling the Opera Mini service. However, the plaintiff never requested a subscription cancelation.

Ignatius said, the Opera Mini Service period is automatically extended so the subscriber doesn’t need to reactivate the service. Every time the service is extended, the defendant sends an extension notification text message (SMS) that states “Your Opera Mini Service has been extended. Enjoy FREE internet using opera mini for 7 days. To stop type OP OFF send to 3636. For help call *363*.

By not asking Telkomsel to cancel his subscription, Ignatius argues that David gave his silent approval to extend the Opera Mini Service subscription. “That means, the plaintiff gave his silent approval for the activation,” he said.

Ignatius argues that a silent approval is a valid agreement and in accordance with Article 1320 of the Indonesia Private Code (KUHPerd) on agreement validity requirements. So, the agreement had legal force that is binding and applicable  to both parties. The defendant also referred to the Supreme Court Jurisprudence No. 2178 K/Pdt/2008.

In the response, the defendant also questioned the plaintiff’s attitude, and his reluctance to settle. Ignatius said, the Plaintiff does not show any good will, because he refused to settle at the mediation stage. Moreover, the in the previous trial session, the plaintiff asked the Panel of Judges to precede the trial without mediation. “From the very beginning the plaintiff refused to settle with the defendant,” he said.

At the trial, the Panel of Judges also suggested that both parties to settle. The presiding judge, Andi Risajaya asked the plaintiff and the defendant to consider mediation, because a trial could be time consuming, said Ignatius said.

After the court session, David ML Tobing said that the defendant’s response indirectly confirmed that the defendant had activated the Opera Mini application without his approval. David said, he requested an unlimited BlackBerry roaming application, but the one activated was the Opera Mini application. “From that response it was clear that Telkomsel provided the Opera Mini service without approval,” he said.

David denied that he gave his silent approval by not requesting a cancellation. He argues that he was not obligated to stop the subscription, because he never subscribed to the service. David claimed that the defendant failed to send him the right application. “I was supposed to cancel [the subscription], but I didn’t want to. I never registered for that service subscription,” he said.

(Rofiq Hidayat/Adi Condro Bawono)

 

A lawsuit filed by David Tobing against Telkomsel started in the District Court of South Jakarta this Thursday (17/11).  David claims Telkomsel deducted credits from his phone without his approval. However, Ignatius Andy, Telkomsel’s lawyer, argued that David had given his implied consent and asked the Panel of Judges to reject the plaintiff’s claim.

In his lawsuit, David claims that Telkomsel has been deducting phone credits from his phone without his consent. He finally got fed up when he received a short message from Telkomsel on Saturday, 16 July 2011, with the following message “Thank you for subscribing to Mini Opera for IDR 10,000/7-days. Terms/Conditions apply, contact *363#. To stop type OP OFF (and send) to 3636. To download, click http://mini.opera.com”

David was surprised to receive this SMS, because he has never subscribed to the Opera Mini service on his BlackBerry mobile. After this, David lost IDR 10,000 worth of cell phone credits every week, as evident in his HALO card monthly phone bill. When David submitted his claim, his cell phone credit had already been cut nine times.

During the trial, the Telkomsel rejected the plaintiff’s arguments, especially those regarding the activation of Opera Mini services. The defendant argues that David requested the service subscription. According to Ignatius, the Plaintiff consented to activating the Opera Mini service even extended the subscription period. The proof is that the plaintiff never asked Telkomsel to end the subscription.

Ignatius said that the plaintiff could have easily stopped subscribing to the Opera Mini Service, “by typing OP OFF and sending it to the access number 3636 free of charge. However, the plaintiff never stopped subscribing,” he said. 

In addition, Andi explained that the plaintiff was recorded to have called Telkomsel customer services four times. At the time, the plaintiff did ask about the Opera Mini application. Customer service had already given him information about canceling the Opera Mini service. However, the plaintiff never requested a subscription cancelation.

Ignatius said, the Opera Mini Service period is automatically extended so the subscriber doesn’t need to reactivate the service. Every time the service is extended, the defendant sends an extension notification text message (SMS) that states “Your Opera Mini Service has been extended. Enjoy FREE internet using opera mini for 7 days. To stop type OP OFF send to 3636. For help call *363*.

By not asking Telkomsel to cancel his subscription, Ignatius argues that David gave his silent approval to extend the Opera Mini Service subscription. “That means, the plaintiff gave his silent approval for the activation,” he said.

Ignatius argues that a silent approval is a valid agreement and in accordance with Article 1320 of the Indonesia Private Code (KUHPerd) on agreement validity requirements. So, the agreement had legal force that is binding and applicable  to both parties. The defendant also referred to the Supreme Court Jurisprudence No. 2178 K/Pdt/2008.

In the response, the defendant also questioned the plaintiff’s attitude, and his reluctance to settle. Ignatius said, the Plaintiff does not show any good will, because he refused to settle at the mediation stage. Moreover, the in the previous trial session, the plaintiff asked the Panel of Judges to precede the trial without mediation. “From the very beginning the plaintiff refused to settle with the defendant,” he said.

At the trial, the Panel of Judges also suggested that both parties to settle. The presiding judge, Andi Risajaya asked the plaintiff and the defendant to consider mediation, because a trial could be time consuming, said Ignatius said.

After the court session, David ML Tobing said that the defendant’s response indirectly confirmed that the defendant had activated the Opera Mini application without his approval. David said, he requested an unlimited BlackBerry roaming application, but the one activated was the Opera Mini application. “From that response it was clear that Telkomsel provided the Opera Mini service without approval,” he said.

David denied that he gave his silent approval by not requesting a cancellation. He argues that he was not obligated to stop the subscription, because he never subscribed to the service. David claimed that the defendant failed to send him the right application. “I was supposed to cancel [the subscription], but I didn’t want to. I never registered for that service subscription,” he said.

(Rofiq Hidayat/Adi Condro Bawono)

2026 Hak Cipta Milik Hukumonline.com
Cookies Info