Recently, ASEAN countries have made progress toward both regional economic integration and fostering a culture of fair competition. In the ASEAN Economic Community Blueprint, ASEAN Member States agreed the “endeavor to introduce competition policy in all ASEAN Member countries by 2015” in order to ensure a level playing field and enhance regional economic performance in the long run.
While many ASEAN countries are still working on implementing national competition policy and law, experts at an ASEAN Competition Conference in Bali recommended developing a regional competition law and authority to promote competition on Wednesday (16/11).
Currently, only Indonesia, Singapore, Thailand and Vietnam have economy-wide competition policy and law (CPL) and competition authorities. Malaysia is expected to implement economy-wide CPL in 2012, while other countries have relied on sector-level policies and regulations to achieve competition policy objectives and are working to introduce competition policy by 2015.
However, there is no official ASEAN body for cooperative work on CPL to serve as a network for competition agencies or relative bodies to exchange policy experiences and information. The ASEAN Blueprint suggests establishing a network of authorities or agencies to responsible for competition policy and developing a regional guideline on competition policy to foster fair competition.
Regional Competition Agency
Mark Williams, a professor at the Hong Kong Polytechnic University, suggests going further and establishing a regional competition law “to prevent the partitioning of the [ASEAN] FTA along national boundaries and encourage the creation of a single internal regional market.”
He encouraged establishing a regional law that reflects a regional perspective, not a national one and creating an enforcement agency that would be guided by regional considerations, rather than national interests that might conflict with market integration objectives.
According to Mark, a regional competition agency could “reduce resource constraints by encouraging pooled or shared resources”, improve cross-border investigations, and enhance regional consistency and improve the predictability of decisions. Furthermore, consumers and businesses would have access to a greater range of products and services at competitive prices, and national and regional competitiveness would improve.
Andreas Stephen, a professor at the University of East Anglia, also pointed out the need for regional enforcement in order to address international cartels. Andreas argued that trade openness means counties are more exposed to international cartels, some of which control raw materials and commodities that are important to emerging economies. However, only a few countries are addressing these cartels, which means “other countries are essentially subsidizing shareholders” in countries where the cartels are located.
Despite the benefits of a regional competition law and authority, Mark cautioned that regional trade and competition policies must “ensure that everyone benefits” within the region. To ensure success, Mark suggests making sure the regional authority has clear and limited objectives that all members understand. In addition, he noted that integrating regional markets demands political will, a well-thought out regional structure, a transparent decision-making process, and effective implementation of decisions.
Andreas offered similar suggestions, and also recommended dealing with corruption and competition issues separately. Although some studies suggest addressing competition will result in reduced corruption, Andreas argued this is a “misuse of resources”, since the power to impose fines for violations of competition law could be used corruptly, these issues must be addressed independently.
(Julie Ota)
Recently, ASEAN countries have made progress toward both regional economic integration and fostering a culture of fair competition. In the ASEAN Economic Community Blueprint, ASEAN Member States agreed the “endeavor to introduce competition policy in all ASEAN Member countries by 2015” in order to ensure a level playing field and enhance regional economic performance in the long run.
While many ASEAN countries are still working on implementing national competition policy and law, experts at an ASEAN Competition Conference in Bali recommended developing a regional competition law and authority to promote competition on Wednesday (16/11).
Currently, only Indonesia, Singapore, Thailand and Vietnam have economy-wide competition policy and law (CPL) and competition authorities. Malaysia is expected to implement economy-wide CPL in 2012, while other countries have relied on sector-level policies and regulations to achieve competition policy objectives and are working to introduce competition policy by 2015.
However, there is no official ASEAN body for cooperative work on CPL to serve as a network for competition agencies or relative bodies to exchange policy experiences and information. The ASEAN Blueprint suggests establishing a network of authorities or agencies to responsible for competition policy and developing a regional guideline on competition policy to foster fair competition.
Regional Competition Agency
Mark Williams, a professor at the Hong Kong Polytechnic University, suggests going further and establishing a regional competition law “to prevent the partitioning of the [ASEAN] FTA along national boundaries and encourage the creation of a single internal regional market.”
He encouraged establishing a regional law that reflects a regional perspective, not a national one and creating an enforcement agency that would be guided by regional considerations, rather than national interests that might conflict with market integration objectives.
According to Mark, a regional competition agency could “reduce resource constraints by encouraging pooled or shared resources”, improve cross-border investigations, and enhance regional consistency and improve the predictability of decisions. Furthermore, consumers and businesses would have access to a greater range of products and services at competitive prices, and national and regional competitiveness would improve.
Andreas Stephen, a professor at the University of East Anglia, also pointed out the need for regional enforcement in order to address international cartels. Andreas argued that trade openness means counties are more exposed to international cartels, some of which control raw materials and commodities that are important to emerging economies. However, only a few countries are addressing these cartels, which means “other countries are essentially subsidizing shareholders” in countries where the cartels are located.
Despite the benefits of a regional competition law and authority, Mark cautioned that regional trade and competition policies must “ensure that everyone benefits” within the region. To ensure success, Mark suggests making sure the regional authority has clear and limited objectives that all members understand. In addition, he noted that integrating regional markets demands political will, a well-thought out regional structure, a transparent decision-making process, and effective implementation of decisions.
Andreas offered similar suggestions, and also recommended dealing with corruption and competition issues separately. Although some studies suggest addressing competition will result in reduced corruption, Andreas argued this is a “misuse of resources”, since the power to impose fines for violations of competition law could be used corruptly, these issues must be addressed independently.
(Julie Ota)