Thirty years ago, Australia had a troubled economy and weak competition policies. Now, it is an economic powerhouse, as a result of economic reforms including strengthening competition policies and creating a culture of fair business competition.
By examining the Australian experience, Indonesia can develop better competition policies as well as gain some assurance that improving competition policies will lead to a stronger economy.
Experts at an ASEAN Competition Conference in Bali, on Tuesday (15/11), unanimously agreed that strong competition policies and a culture of fair business competition are correlated to many economic benefits, such as increased efficiency, which leads to better prices for consumers, and economic growth.
"Australia was transformed from a highly protected and over-regulated economy supplying a small protected domestic market [in the 1980s] to an open competitive economy supplying global markets,” said Deborah Healey, a professor at the University of New South Wales. It was aimed through economic reforms including cutting tariffs and eliminating import quotas, as well as improving competition law and establishing a culture of fair business competition.
Robert Ian McEwin, a Visiting Professor of Law at the National University of Singapore, reinforced this idea, stating that Australia was a “basket case” in the 1960s, 70s, and 80s, before these reforms were enacted, and many businesses were opposed to competition policies. But, currently, businesses are in favor of competition law because it has had a positive impact.
As Deborah explained, these reforms changed the way businesses did business. Productivity in the late 90s and early 2000s have been attributed to the national competition policy and the prices of electricity, gas, milk, telecommunications, and other products went downafter these reforms. In 2002, the Productivity Commission estimated that the reforms resulted in $20 billion or 2.5% of the GDP per year in efficiency gains.
Based on the Australian experience, Robert and Deborah offered some advice for Indonesia and other ASEAN countries that are struggling to create fair business competition cultures.
Both noted the importance of studying the economic situation and country specific needs in Indonesia to determine the best approach. For example, Australia engaged in a comprehensive review (known as the Hilmer Review) of its competition law and policy in 1992, which allowed it to identify strategies for strengthening competition.
The Hilmer Review recommended a process of review for all laws at all levels to identify and amend laws that are unnecessarily anti-competitive, requiring all new laws to undergo a review to consider their anti-competitive impact before enacted, and an agreement between the commonwealth and the states and territories to create a national economy-wide competition law.
The Australian government adopted a new approach, that included an incentive system to pay states and territories AUD 890 million over five years for complying with their obligations to review and reform laws.
“Legal institutions are extremely important,” Robert argued. He asserted that many economists are uncomfortable with dealing with legal regimes and being questioned by legal regimes, but must understand the laws and look at efforts in their country to develop good policies.
In addition, Robert noted that there needs to be strong political will at the top. This thought was reiterated by R Shyam Khemani, a specialist in economic analysis and competition matters. Shyam asserted that economic and political leaders need to feel a high level of anxiety, otherwise change is not likely.
According to Shyam, a high level of anxiety leads to political will and change. He attributed competition reforms in Indonesian, such as the 1999 law and establishment of the Business Competition Supervisory Comission (Komisi Persaingan Usaha - KPPU), to the 1998 financial crisis, which created a high level of anxiety and the political will to make changes.
However, simply revising current competition laws or adopting new policies based on experiences in other countries is not recommended. Robert cautioned that it is important to have a coordinated economic policy based on country specific research, such as the Hilmer Review, not just research across the world.
"Law doesn’t matter much. It’s about how the law is interpreted,” Robert asserted. For example, he noted that competition law in the United States is “mixed up and conflicting, but over time it has worked out a system” resulting in a strong competition cultures.
Although he doesn’t believe revising the laws are the most important approach, Robert did provide some tips on how Indonesia could improve its competition law. During a discussion after a seminar, Robert said the Indonesian competition law is “too complicated, and has too many conflicting acts”.
Instead, the competition law should stick to competition issues, rather than regulating too many issues. He suggested looking at Singapore and the European Union, which only have a few prohibitions and are written in simple language, which makes these laws clear and easy to interpret.
Robert also offered some words of encouragement on improving competition. He is “heartened” by developments in Indonesia during the last five years, and encouraged Indonesia to continue strengthening competition.
“If Indonesia had started thirty years ago, its economy would be like Australia’s economy today,” Robert emphasized.
(Julie Ota)
Thirty years ago, Australia had a troubled economy and weak competition policies. Now, it is an economic powerhouse, as a result of economic reforms including strengthening competition policies and creating a culture of fair business competition.
By examining the Australian experience, Indonesia can develop better competition policies as well as gain some assurance that improving competition policies will lead to a stronger economy.
Experts at an ASEAN Competition Conference in Bali, on Tuesday (15/11), unanimously agreed that strong competition policies and a culture of fair business competition are correlated to many economic benefits, such as increased efficiency, which leads to better prices for consumers, and economic growth.
"Australia was transformed from a highly protected and over-regulated economy supplying a small protected domestic market [in the 1980s] to an open competitive economy supplying global markets,” said Deborah Healey, a professor at the University of New South Wales. It was aimed through economic reforms including cutting tariffs and eliminating import quotas, as well as improving competition law and establishing a culture of fair business competition.
Robert Ian McEwin, a Visiting Professor of Law at the National University of Singapore, reinforced this idea, stating that Australia was a “basket case” in the 1960s, 70s, and 80s, before these reforms were enacted, and many businesses were opposed to competition policies. But, currently, businesses are in favor of competition law because it has had a positive impact.
As Deborah explained, these reforms changed the way businesses did business. Productivity in the late 90s and early 2000s have been attributed to the national competition policy and the prices of electricity, gas, milk, telecommunications, and other products went downafter these reforms. In 2002, the Productivity Commission estimated that the reforms resulted in $20 billion or 2.5% of the GDP per year in efficiency gains.
Based on the Australian experience, Robert and Deborah offered some advice for Indonesia and other ASEAN countries that are struggling to create fair business competition cultures.
Both noted the importance of studying the economic situation and country specific needs in Indonesia to determine the best approach. For example, Australia engaged in a comprehensive review (known as the Hilmer Review) of its competition law and policy in 1992, which allowed it to identify strategies for strengthening competition.
The Hilmer Review recommended a process of review for all laws at all levels to identify and amend laws that are unnecessarily anti-competitive, requiring all new laws to undergo a review to consider their anti-competitive impact before enacted, and an agreement between the commonwealth and the states and territories to create a national economy-wide competition law.
The Australian government adopted a new approach, that included an incentive system to pay states and territories AUD 890 million over five years for complying with their obligations to review and reform laws.
“Legal institutions are extremely important,” Robert argued. He asserted that many economists are uncomfortable with dealing with legal regimes and being questioned by legal regimes, but must understand the laws and look at efforts in their country to develop good policies.
In addition, Robert noted that there needs to be strong political will at the top. This thought was reiterated by R Shyam Khemani, a specialist in economic analysis and competition matters. Shyam asserted that economic and political leaders need to feel a high level of anxiety, otherwise change is not likely.
According to Shyam, a high level of anxiety leads to political will and change. He attributed competition reforms in Indonesian, such as the 1999 law and establishment of the Business Competition Supervisory Comission (Komisi Persaingan Usaha - KPPU), to the 1998 financial crisis, which created a high level of anxiety and the political will to make changes.
However, simply revising current competition laws or adopting new policies based on experiences in other countries is not recommended. Robert cautioned that it is important to have a coordinated economic policy based on country specific research, such as the Hilmer Review, not just research across the world.
"Law doesn’t matter much. It’s about how the law is interpreted,” Robert asserted. For example, he noted that competition law in the United States is “mixed up and conflicting, but over time it has worked out a system” resulting in a strong competition cultures.
Although he doesn’t believe revising the laws are the most important approach, Robert did provide some tips on how Indonesia could improve its competition law. During a discussion after a seminar, Robert said the Indonesian competition law is “too complicated, and has too many conflicting acts”.
Instead, the competition law should stick to competition issues, rather than regulating too many issues. He suggested looking at Singapore and the European Union, which only have a few prohibitions and are written in simple language, which makes these laws clear and easy to interpret.
Robert also offered some words of encouragement on improving competition. He is “heartened” by developments in Indonesia during the last five years, and encouraged Indonesia to continue strengthening competition.
“If Indonesia had started thirty years ago, its economy would be like Australia’s economy today,” Robert emphasized.
(Julie Ota)