State Intelligence Law Could Be Detrimental for Advocates

 

The State Intelligence Law has the potential to threat the client-advocate confidentiality principle, because Law No. 18 of 2003 on Advocates classify advocate as a law enforcer. As a result, advocates must adhere to the law enforcer obligations stipulated in the State Intelligence Law.Based on this assumption, Article 34 (2) of the State Intelligence Law could ruin the client-advocate relationship.

Article 31 of State Intelligence Law gives the Indonesian Intelligence Agency (Badan Intelijen Nasional – BIN) the authority to obtain information. As a last resort, BIN is permitted to conduct stakeout or engage in surveillance, monitoring, infiltrating, fund inspection, and wiretapping to obtain accurate and complete information. Article 34 (1) encourages BIN to cooperate with other law enforcers, while Article 34 (2) states that every law enforcer must assist BIN in obtain information.

The Indonesian legal system recognizes four law enforcers: the National Police, public prosecutors, judges, and advocates. Law No. 18 of 2003 on Advocates clearly states that advocates are law enforcers.  However, an advocate must maintain client confidentiality,and they would be violating advocacy principles if they help intelligence officers by revealingtheir client’s secrets.

Article 34 (2) could be detrimental to the advocate-client relationship, because it doesn’t clearly state what kind of ‘help’ an advocate must provide. Article 34 (2) only mentions the help is to obtain information regarding intelligence targets.

This raises several questions. Is an advocate obligated to reveal detrimental information regarding a client who becomes an intelligence target? Should an advocate be obligated to help BIN in revealing their client’ssecrets?

According to Indriaswati D Saptaningrum, “client confidentiality cannot be negated for the purpose of obtaining intelligence information.”

Indriaswati, the Executive Director of The Institute for Community Studies and Advocacy (Lembaga Studi dan Advokasi Masyarakat – Elsam) says every advocate must follow the professional code of ethics for advocates, including maintaining client confidentiality. Not even a judge can force an advocate to reveal their client’s secrets.

An advocate, Bambang Widjojanto,also reminds advocates to maintain client confidentiality.  Client confidentiality is an obligation according to the advocate’s code of ethics. “The advocate’s code of ethics must be protected,” he said.

Bambang confirmed that there are stipulations in the State Intelligence Law that are inconsistent with other regulations. However, he believes itis bestto ask the Constitutional Court to review a regulation that is inconsistent and open to multiple interpretations. “I think advocates already know the solution, it is better to review it in the Constitutional Court,” said Bambang who is also a lecturer at Trisakti University.

Wahyudi Djafar, a member of the Public Interest Lawyers Network andanElsam researcher, confirms that judicial review of the State Intelligence Law is possible. “Article 34 will be included in the review petition,” he said.

The State Intelligence Law has been criticized because several articles are open to multiple interpretations. Law enforcers in the field could interpret the law differently, creating inconsistencies and the possibility of abuse. “The law gives BIN broad authorities and allows it to use its authorities without clear guidelines,” Indriaswati said.

The law must be clarified to make law enforcers obligations clear. From the beginning the phrase ‘obtaining information’ has been suspected of being another word for investigation. To resolve the Article 34 (2) problem, Wahyudi confirmed that a judicial review petition for the State Intelligence Law has been discussed and finalized to be presented in the Constitutional Court. 

(Muhammad Yasin/Adi Condro Bawono)

 

The State Intelligence Law has the potential to threat the client-advocate confidentiality principle, because Law No. 18 of 2003 on Advocates classify advocate as a law enforcer. As a result, advocates must adhere to the law enforcer obligations stipulated in the State Intelligence Law.Based on this assumption, Article 34 (2) of the State Intelligence Law could ruin the client-advocate relationship.

Article 31 of State Intelligence Law gives the Indonesian Intelligence Agency (Badan Intelijen Nasional – BIN) the authority to obtain information. As a last resort, BIN is permitted to conduct stakeout or engage in surveillance, monitoring, infiltrating, fund inspection, and wiretapping to obtain accurate and complete information. Article 34 (1) encourages BIN to cooperate with other law enforcers, while Article 34 (2) states that every law enforcer must assist BIN in obtain information.

The Indonesian legal system recognizes four law enforcers: the National Police, public prosecutors, judges, and advocates. Law No. 18 of 2003 on Advocates clearly states that advocates are law enforcers.  However, an advocate must maintain client confidentiality,and they would be violating advocacy principles if they help intelligence officers by revealingtheir client’s secrets.

Article 34 (2) could be detrimental to the advocate-client relationship, because it doesn’t clearly state what kind of ‘help’ an advocate must provide. Article 34 (2) only mentions the help is to obtain information regarding intelligence targets.

This raises several questions. Is an advocate obligated to reveal detrimental information regarding a client who becomes an intelligence target? Should an advocate be obligated to help BIN in revealing their client’ssecrets?

According to Indriaswati D Saptaningrum, “client confidentiality cannot be negated for the purpose of obtaining intelligence information.”

Indriaswati, the Executive Director of The Institute for Community Studies and Advocacy (Lembaga Studi dan Advokasi Masyarakat – Elsam) says every advocate must follow the professional code of ethics for advocates, including maintaining client confidentiality. Not even a judge can force an advocate to reveal their client’s secrets.

An advocate, Bambang Widjojanto,also reminds advocates to maintain client confidentiality.  Client confidentiality is an obligation according to the advocate’s code of ethics. “The advocate’s code of ethics must be protected,” he said.

Bambang confirmed that there are stipulations in the State Intelligence Law that are inconsistent with other regulations. However, he believes itis bestto ask the Constitutional Court to review a regulation that is inconsistent and open to multiple interpretations. “I think advocates already know the solution, it is better to review it in the Constitutional Court,” said Bambang who is also a lecturer at Trisakti University.

Wahyudi Djafar, a member of the Public Interest Lawyers Network andanElsam researcher, confirms that judicial review of the State Intelligence Law is possible. “Article 34 will be included in the review petition,” he said.

The State Intelligence Law has been criticized because several articles are open to multiple interpretations. Law enforcers in the field could interpret the law differently, creating inconsistencies and the possibility of abuse. “The law gives BIN broad authorities and allows it to use its authorities without clear guidelines,” Indriaswati said.

The law must be clarified to make law enforcers obligations clear. From the beginning the phrase ‘obtaining information’ has been suspected of being another word for investigation. To resolve the Article 34 (2) problem, Wahyudi confirmed that a judicial review petition for the State Intelligence Law has been discussed and finalized to be presented in the Constitutional Court. 

(Muhammad Yasin/Adi Condro Bawono)

2026 Hak Cipta Milik Hukumonline.com
Cookies Info