Doubts About OJK Independence

 

Rimawan Pradiptya, an economics lecturer at Gadja Mada University questioned whether former officials from financial institutions will be able to be objective when they serve on the Commissioner Council of the OJK.It is certain that the OJK will be established. However, the OJK’s independence and neutrality is still being questioned. Rimawan Pradiptya, an economics lecturer at Gadja Mada University questioned whether former officials from financial institutions will be able to be objective when they serve on the Commissioner Council of the OJK.

At the Indonesia Corruption Watch (ICW) office, Wednesday (2/11), Rimawan asserted that whoever becomes a member of the Commissioner Council of the OJK will be emotionally involved, since they have been working for a financial institution for a long time. “It will be hard for them to be neutral because [they] will want to return favors to the institution that supported their career,” said Rimawan.

The same thing happened in the United States before the 2008 global financial crisis. At the time, former Goldman Sachs employees held key positions in financial oversight institutions. When Goldman Sachs collapsed during the 2008 global financial crisis, these former employees pushed the government to invest and rescue Goldman Sachs.

It should be noted, that the members of the OJK Commissioner Council are: the Head of the Commissioner Council; the Chief Executive for Banking Supervision; a Chief Executive for Capital Market Supervision; the Chief Executive for Insurance, Retirement Funds, Financing Institutions and other Financial Institutions;  the Head of the Audit Council; a member who is in charge of consumer protection and education; an ex officio member from Bank Indonesia who is also a member of the Board of Governors of Bank Indonesia; and an ex officio member form the Ministry of Finance who is also an echelon I official within the Ministry of Finance.

Seven members of the Commissioner Council of the OJK will be chosen by the House of Representatives (DPR) based on Presidential recommendations. A Selection Committee with nine members will select Commissioner Council Members.  The members of this Selection Committee will come from the government, Bank Indonesia, and the community. The Selection Committee will submit three candidates for each position on the Commissioner Council to the President.

The President will choose and submit the names of two candidates for each position on the OJK Commissioner Council to the DPR. At this stage, the President will submit the name of two candidates to the DPR for the Head of the Commissioner Council. The commissioner who fails to become the Head of the Commissioner Council will be included as a candidate for a member of the CommissionerCouncil.

The Commissioner Council of the OJK will make OJK regulations, Commissioner Council regulations, and Commissioner Council decrees. However, Rimawan is not sure the OJK will be able to carry out these functions independently. “Looking at the composition of the Commissioner Council, I am not convinced that the OJK will run effectively and independently,” he said.

As previously reported by Hukumonline, the DPR finally passed a Bill on the Financial Services Authority (OJK Bill) in a plenary session, Thursday (27/10). In a speech, the Ministry of Finance, Agus DW Martowardojo, stated that the OJK should become an independent institution in performing their duties and authority. The OJK is free from outside interferences.

Agus confirmed that the OJK will be independent. He sees the OJK as an institution that won’t be controlled by the government. However, he didn’t deny the possibility that ex officio representatives from the Ministry of Finance or Bank Indonesia might be biased.

(M Agus Yozami/Adi Condro Bawono)

 

Rimawan Pradiptya, an economics lecturer at Gadja Mada University questioned whether former officials from financial institutions will be able to be objective when they serve on the Commissioner Council of the OJK.It is certain that the OJK will be established. However, the OJK’s independence and neutrality is still being questioned. Rimawan Pradiptya, an economics lecturer at Gadja Mada University questioned whether former officials from financial institutions will be able to be objective when they serve on the Commissioner Council of the OJK.

At the Indonesia Corruption Watch (ICW) office, Wednesday (2/11), Rimawan asserted that whoever becomes a member of the Commissioner Council of the OJK will be emotionally involved, since they have been working for a financial institution for a long time. “It will be hard for them to be neutral because [they] will want to return favors to the institution that supported their career,” said Rimawan.

The same thing happened in the United States before the 2008 global financial crisis. At the time, former Goldman Sachs employees held key positions in financial oversight institutions. When Goldman Sachs collapsed during the 2008 global financial crisis, these former employees pushed the government to invest and rescue Goldman Sachs.

It should be noted, that the members of the OJK Commissioner Council are: the Head of the Commissioner Council; the Chief Executive for Banking Supervision; a Chief Executive for Capital Market Supervision; the Chief Executive for Insurance, Retirement Funds, Financing Institutions and other Financial Institutions;  the Head of the Audit Council; a member who is in charge of consumer protection and education; an ex officio member from Bank Indonesia who is also a member of the Board of Governors of Bank Indonesia; and an ex officio member form the Ministry of Finance who is also an echelon I official within the Ministry of Finance.

Seven members of the Commissioner Council of the OJK will be chosen by the House of Representatives (DPR) based on Presidential recommendations. A Selection Committee with nine members will select Commissioner Council Members.  The members of this Selection Committee will come from the government, Bank Indonesia, and the community. The Selection Committee will submit three candidates for each position on the Commissioner Council to the President.

The President will choose and submit the names of two candidates for each position on the OJK Commissioner Council to the DPR. At this stage, the President will submit the name of two candidates to the DPR for the Head of the Commissioner Council. The commissioner who fails to become the Head of the Commissioner Council will be included as a candidate for a member of the CommissionerCouncil.

The Commissioner Council of the OJK will make OJK regulations, Commissioner Council regulations, and Commissioner Council decrees. However, Rimawan is not sure the OJK will be able to carry out these functions independently. “Looking at the composition of the Commissioner Council, I am not convinced that the OJK will run effectively and independently,” he said.

As previously reported by Hukumonline, the DPR finally passed a Bill on the Financial Services Authority (OJK Bill) in a plenary session, Thursday (27/10). In a speech, the Ministry of Finance, Agus DW Martowardojo, stated that the OJK should become an independent institution in performing their duties and authority. The OJK is free from outside interferences.

Agus confirmed that the OJK will be independent. He sees the OJK as an institution that won’t be controlled by the government. However, he didn’t deny the possibility that ex officio representatives from the Ministry of Finance or Bank Indonesia might be biased.

(M Agus Yozami/Adi Condro Bawono)

2026 Hak Cipta Milik Hukumonline.com
Cookies Info