A ‘culture’ of corruption has penetrated the Indonesian community, affecting both public officials and entrepreneurs. According to the 2011 Bribe Payers Index, published by Transparency International Indonesia (TII), Indonesian entrepreneurs are among the most likely to offer bribes.
The index is based on a survey of 28 countries organized by Transparency International (TI). “Out of 28 countries, Indonesia is fourth from the bottom, especially in the public works and construction sectors,” said TII researcher Frenky Simanjuntak in Jakarta, Thursday (3/11).
In the survey, Indonesia scored 7,1, placing it at the bottom of the index with Russia (6,1), China (6,5), and Mexico (7,0). In this survey, the number zero indicates that entrepreneurs often engage in bribery when conducting business abroad, while the number ten indicates the opposite. Entrepreneurs from the Netherlands and Switzerland, which both scored 8,8, were at the top of the index.
According to Frenky, “the conclusion is that bribery is still a common business practice abroad. The proof is that no country scored a ten.” He also explained that the survey involved 3.016 business executives from 28 countries.
In addition, Frenky explained that the survey shows that the behavior of entrepreneurs abroad is not much different from the behavior of public officials in the entrepreneurs’ home country. He showed that countries with low scores on the Bribe Payers Index also have low scores on the Corruption Perceptions Index (IPK), which is used to indicate how corrupt public officials are.
For example, Russia, China, Mexico and Indonesia have relatively low IPKs. “The Netherlands has a high IPK. So, public officials there do not commit acts of corruption or bribery often,” he said.
Vice Chairman of the Indonesian Chamber of Commerce, Natsir Mansyur, criticized the survey, saying it is only intended to discredit Indonesian entrepreneurs. “It can’t be generalized like that,” he said. He even claimed that the survey conducted by Transparency International in 28 countries was invalid.
“Until now, no Indonesian entrepreneur has been arrested for bribery abroad. Moreover, very few Indonesian entrepreneurs operate in the construction sector abroad. So, I still have some doubts about the data,” he said.
Adopting OECD
Frenky suggests that the government and the House of Representatives (DPR) should revise the Corruption Law by incorporating all of the articles concerning bribery in the United Nations Convention Against Corruption (UNCAC) and the Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) Convention on International Bribery. Once the convention is adopted, Indonesian law enforcers can take legal measures to apprehend Indonesian entrepreneurs who commit bribery abroad. “Adopting the OECD stipulations is one way to resolve this problem,” he said.
Previously, bribery among countries was discussed at the OECD Conference on Anti Foreign Bribery in Nusa Dua Bali. A dozen conclusions were drawn at the conference, which was attended by 400 participants from 38 countries. The Conference concluded that implementing bribery detection and prevention measures and sanctions requires a multidisciplinary approach that involves stakeholders within the framework of international and regional cooperation.
The Corruption Eradication Commission (KPK) admits that several articles in the Corruption Law provide a narrow definition of bribery. Bribery within the private sector isn’t covered in the Corruption Law. “The [Corruption Law] only relates to public officials,” said the Deputy Chairman of KPK, M Jasin in a discussion organized by hukumonline in 2009.
(Ali Salmande/Adi Condro Bawono)
A ‘culture’ of corruption has penetrated the Indonesian community, affecting both public officials and entrepreneurs. According to the 2011 Bribe Payers Index, published by Transparency International Indonesia (TII), Indonesian entrepreneurs are among the most likely to offer bribes.
The index is based on a survey of 28 countries organized by Transparency International (TI). “Out of 28 countries, Indonesia is fourth from the bottom, especially in the public works and construction sectors,” said TII researcher Frenky Simanjuntak in Jakarta, Thursday (3/11).
In the survey, Indonesia scored 7,1, placing it at the bottom of the index with Russia (6,1), China (6,5), and Mexico (7,0). In this survey, the number zero indicates that entrepreneurs often engage in bribery when conducting business abroad, while the number ten indicates the opposite. Entrepreneurs from the Netherlands and Switzerland, which both scored 8,8, were at the top of the index.
According to Frenky, “the conclusion is that bribery is still a common business practice abroad. The proof is that no country scored a ten.” He also explained that the survey involved 3.016 business executives from 28 countries.
In addition, Frenky explained that the survey shows that the behavior of entrepreneurs abroad is not much different from the behavior of public officials in the entrepreneurs’ home country. He showed that countries with low scores on the Bribe Payers Index also have low scores on the Corruption Perceptions Index (IPK), which is used to indicate how corrupt public officials are.
For example, Russia, China, Mexico and Indonesia have relatively low IPKs. “The Netherlands has a high IPK. So, public officials there do not commit acts of corruption or bribery often,” he said.
Vice Chairman of the Indonesian Chamber of Commerce, Natsir Mansyur, criticized the survey, saying it is only intended to discredit Indonesian entrepreneurs. “It can’t be generalized like that,” he said. He even claimed that the survey conducted by Transparency International in 28 countries was invalid.
“Until now, no Indonesian entrepreneur has been arrested for bribery abroad. Moreover, very few Indonesian entrepreneurs operate in the construction sector abroad. So, I still have some doubts about the data,” he said.
Adopting OECD
Frenky suggests that the government and the House of Representatives (DPR) should revise the Corruption Law by incorporating all of the articles concerning bribery in the United Nations Convention Against Corruption (UNCAC) and the Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) Convention on International Bribery. Once the convention is adopted, Indonesian law enforcers can take legal measures to apprehend Indonesian entrepreneurs who commit bribery abroad. “Adopting the OECD stipulations is one way to resolve this problem,” he said.
Previously, bribery among countries was discussed at the OECD Conference on Anti Foreign Bribery in Nusa Dua Bali. A dozen conclusions were drawn at the conference, which was attended by 400 participants from 38 countries. The Conference concluded that implementing bribery detection and prevention measures and sanctions requires a multidisciplinary approach that involves stakeholders within the framework of international and regional cooperation.
The Corruption Eradication Commission (KPK) admits that several articles in the Corruption Law provide a narrow definition of bribery. Bribery within the private sector isn’t covered in the Corruption Law. “The [Corruption Law] only relates to public officials,” said the Deputy Chairman of KPK, M Jasin in a discussion organized by hukumonline in 2009.
(Ali Salmande/Adi Condro Bawono)