With the passage of the Bill on Financial Services Authority (Otoritas Jasa Keuangan/OJK) last Thursday (27/10). The House of Representatives(DPR) expectsthe Bill to address problems in the financial sector. However, Rimawan Pradiptyo, an economist and lecturer of Economic CrimesatGadjah Mada University explained that although OJK has many advantages, itis not perfect.
At a discussion held at the Indonesia Corruption Watch (ICW) office on Wednesday (2/11), Rimawan said consumer protection will become one of OJK’s strengths, because BI and Bapepam-LK do not provide enoughprotectionto consumer.
However,Rimawan criticized the OJK Bill, because itdoesn’t have clear provisionson consumer or bank customer protection. This issue needs to be addressed during the transition period. “I think everyone should think about this carefully duringthe transition period,” said Rimawan.
Articles28 to31 of the OJK Bill regulate consumer protection. Under the OJK Bill, OJK is authorized to take preventative measures in order to protect societyand consumers, and to prevent consumer losses. The preventative measuresincludeproviding information and educational servicesaboutproducts, services, and characteristics of the financial service sector.
OJK is also authorized to ask financial service institutions to stop their activities if theinstitutionsare involved in an activity that might harm society. In addition, OJK can take other measures in accordance with financial service sectorlaws.
Furthermore, OJK willprovide consumer complaint services, to handle complaintsfrom consumerswho have sufferedlosses due tofinancial service institution activities. OJK is responsible forpreparing devices to handle consumer complaints;establishing amechanism for consumer complaint services;and facilitatingconsumer complaint resolution in accordance with financial service sectorlaws.
OJK has alsobeen given the authorityto advocate on behalf ofconsumers and society. Under this authority,OJK can take certain actionsor instruct financial service institutions to resolve consumer complaints. Moreover, OJK can submit a lawsuit to recover propertyforinjured parties.
FKSSK is necessary
According to Rismawan, another advantage of the OJK Bill is that it establishes a sytstem for addressing the economic reprecussions of the current global crisis, since “a coordination system for the crisis hasalready been establishedin the Bill”.
It should be noted, that the OJK Bill includes acoordination protocol.In order to safeguard the stability of the financial system,a Coordination Forum for Financial System Stability (Forum Koordinasi Stabilitas Sistem Keuangan – FKSSK) will be established. FKSSK will be supported by a secretariat lead by anechelon I official within the Ministry of Finance.
FKSSK will hold meetings based on deliberation and consensus (Musyawarah untuk Mufakat)in order to make a decisions.If a consensus cannotbe reached, then a decision will be madeby voting.
The Head of National Banking (Perbanas), Sigit Pramono,also supports the plan to establish FKSSK. According to him, establishing FKSSK is theright decisionto handle the financial crisis, because the crisis cannot be solvedby one institution. “I support FKSSK establishment. There are many authorities in Indonesia, that is why we need a coordination forum between these authorities,” he said.
Sigit explained thatthe purpose ofestablishingFKSSK is basically the same asthe reason for establishing the FinancialSystem Stability Committee (Komite Stabilitas Sistem Keuangan - KSSK) based on a Government Regulation in Lieu ofaLaw on a Financial Stability Safety Net (Jaring Pengaman Sistem Keuangan - JPSK). The similarities between the two institutionscan be seen in theirmonitoring, information exchange, and policy recommendationfunctions. FKSSK’s functionis to decide whether to take a rescue action or not ifthere is an economic crisis.
Economist Ichsanuddin Noorsy also made similar comments. He said, FKSSK is necessary,because financialpolicy will now result from coordinatedeffortsbetween several supervisory agenciesand policymakersin the financialsector.
Another potential flaw in the OJK Bill is the scope of OJK’s authority. Rimawan is disappointed by the fact that OJK only coversbanks, rural banks(Bank Perkereditan Rakyat – BPR), and non-bank financial institutions(Lembaga Keuangan Non-Bank – LKNB).
He arguesthatcooperatives(Koperasi) are a type ofLKNB and should also be supervised by OJK. Currently, The Ministry of Cooperatives and Small Enterprises supervisescooperatives, and the Islamic Small Finance Institution (Baitul Maal Wat-Tamwil - BMT) is unsupervised, even though cooperative profitsreach IDR 55 trillion annually.
“The implication of excluding cooperativesand the BMT from OJK supervision isthatthousands of micro-finance institutions will be unsupervised,” he said.
In addition, Rimawan criticizedthe OJK fee that will be imposed onthe financialindustry, becausethe fee will be charged to banking customersand addtotheir financial burdens.
(M Agus Yozami/Adi Thea/Adi Condro Bawono)
With the passage of the Bill on Financial Services Authority (Otoritas Jasa Keuangan/OJK) last Thursday (27/10). The House of Representatives(DPR) expectsthe Bill to address problems in the financial sector. However, Rimawan Pradiptyo, an economist and lecturer of Economic CrimesatGadjah Mada University explained that although OJK has many advantages, itis not perfect.
At a discussion held at the Indonesia Corruption Watch (ICW) office on Wednesday (2/11), Rimawan said consumer protection will become one of OJK’s strengths, because BI and Bapepam-LK do not provide enoughprotectionto consumer.
However,Rimawan criticized the OJK Bill, because itdoesn’t have clear provisionson consumer or bank customer protection. This issue needs to be addressed during the transition period. “I think everyone should think about this carefully duringthe transition period,” said Rimawan.
Articles28 to31 of the OJK Bill regulate consumer protection. Under the OJK Bill, OJK is authorized to take preventative measures in order to protect societyand consumers, and to prevent consumer losses. The preventative measuresincludeproviding information and educational servicesaboutproducts, services, and characteristics of the financial service sector.
OJK is also authorized to ask financial service institutions to stop their activities if theinstitutionsare involved in an activity that might harm society. In addition, OJK can take other measures in accordance with financial service sectorlaws.
Furthermore, OJK willprovide consumer complaint services, to handle complaintsfrom consumerswho have sufferedlosses due tofinancial service institution activities. OJK is responsible forpreparing devices to handle consumer complaints;establishing amechanism for consumer complaint services;and facilitatingconsumer complaint resolution in accordance with financial service sectorlaws.
OJK has alsobeen given the authorityto advocate on behalf ofconsumers and society. Under this authority,OJK can take certain actionsor instruct financial service institutions to resolve consumer complaints. Moreover, OJK can submit a lawsuit to recover propertyforinjured parties.
FKSSK is necessary
According to Rismawan, another advantage of the OJK Bill is that it establishes a sytstem for addressing the economic reprecussions of the current global crisis, since “a coordination system for the crisis hasalready been establishedin the Bill”.
It should be noted, that the OJK Bill includes acoordination protocol.In order to safeguard the stability of the financial system,a Coordination Forum for Financial System Stability (Forum Koordinasi Stabilitas Sistem Keuangan – FKSSK) will be established. FKSSK will be supported by a secretariat lead by anechelon I official within the Ministry of Finance.
FKSSK will hold meetings based on deliberation and consensus (Musyawarah untuk Mufakat)in order to make a decisions.If a consensus cannotbe reached, then a decision will be madeby voting.
The Head of National Banking (Perbanas), Sigit Pramono,also supports the plan to establish FKSSK. According to him, establishing FKSSK is theright decisionto handle the financial crisis, because the crisis cannot be solvedby one institution. “I support FKSSK establishment. There are many authorities in Indonesia, that is why we need a coordination forum between these authorities,” he said.
Sigit explained thatthe purpose ofestablishingFKSSK is basically the same asthe reason for establishing the FinancialSystem Stability Committee (Komite Stabilitas Sistem Keuangan - KSSK) based on a Government Regulation in Lieu ofaLaw on a Financial Stability Safety Net (Jaring Pengaman Sistem Keuangan - JPSK). The similarities between the two institutionscan be seen in theirmonitoring, information exchange, and policy recommendationfunctions. FKSSK’s functionis to decide whether to take a rescue action or not ifthere is an economic crisis.
Economist Ichsanuddin Noorsy also made similar comments. He said, FKSSK is necessary,because financialpolicy will now result from coordinatedeffortsbetween several supervisory agenciesand policymakersin the financialsector.
Another potential flaw in the OJK Bill is the scope of OJK’s authority. Rimawan is disappointed by the fact that OJK only coversbanks, rural banks(Bank Perkereditan Rakyat – BPR), and non-bank financial institutions(Lembaga Keuangan Non-Bank – LKNB).
He arguesthatcooperatives(Koperasi) are a type ofLKNB and should also be supervised by OJK. Currently, The Ministry of Cooperatives and Small Enterprises supervisescooperatives, and the Islamic Small Finance Institution (Baitul Maal Wat-Tamwil - BMT) is unsupervised, even though cooperative profitsreach IDR 55 trillion annually.
“The implication of excluding cooperativesand the BMT from OJK supervision isthatthousands of micro-finance institutions will be unsupervised,” he said.
In addition, Rimawan criticizedthe OJK fee that will be imposed onthe financialindustry, becausethe fee will be charged to banking customersand addtotheir financial burdens.
(M Agus Yozami/Adi Thea/Adi Condro Bawono)