DPR and Minister of Finance Argue About Newmont

It seems there will be another debate regarding the seven percent acquisition of Newmont Nusa Tenggara (“Newmont”) divestment shares. Vice Chairman of Commission XI of the House of Representatives (DPR), Harry AzharAzis, claims he obtained the Supreme Audit Agency’s (Badan Pemeriksa Keuangan – BPK) audit results regarding the Indonesia Investment Agency’s (Perusahaan Investasi Pemerintah – PIP) plans to buy Newmont shares. According to the audit results, PIP used State Revenue and Expenditure Budget (APBN) funds to purchase the shares, without DPR approval.

“The BPK states that based on the Newmont share acquisition audit results there was a violation. That is why we [ed. the DPR] call the Minister of Finance (Menkeu) as soon as possible,” said Harry Azhar Asis, Monday (24/10).

According to Harry, BPK’s opinion raises two points of concern for the government. First, the BPK states that a separate government regulation is required to regulate investments that use the funds from the state budget. This is similar to state capital participation (Penyertaan Modal Negara – PMN) for state-owned companies (BUMN), which also require a special regulation.

Second, the government should ask for DPR approval before implementing a divestment policy, because funds come from the APBN. After the BPK’s audit, there is no excuse for the Minister of Finance to continue the Newmont divestment transaction.

“In accordance with BPK audit results, the PIP plan to buy seven percent of Newmont shares must be void by law. Unless the Minister of Finance submits a new proposal to ask the DPR’s approval later,” said Harry, aFunctional Group Party (Golkar) politician.

Unfortunately, BPK has not publicly provided details about the audit results.Vice Chairman of the BPK, Hasan Bisri, did not reply to a hukumonline inquiry regarding this issue.

Meanwhile, the Minister of Finance, Agus Martowardojo admits that has not been informed about the BPK audit results yet. However, he will continue the plan to buy Newmont shares, even if the DPR doesn’t approve the plan. According to him, the plan to buy Newmont share does not violate any regulation. He insisted there is nothing wrong with buying the shares.

“We have legal grounds to buy seven percent of Newmont’s shares without DPR approval,” he asserts. “Everything is in accordance with Article 41 of Law No. 1 of 2004 on the State Treasury,” said the minister in the Ministry of Finance building, Monday (24/10).

Agus explains, from a legal perspective, there are two categories of government investment activities. The first category covers permanent investments through PMN. The second category includes temporary investments, such as PIP’s plan to buy seven percent of Newmont shares.

Agus says the PIP plan is in accordance with Article 41 of Law No. 1 of 2004 on State Treasury (“State Treasury Law”), which states “the government can make long-term investments to gain economic and social benefits, and/or other benefits in the form of shares, bonds, and direct investments”.

Agus said, based on the State Treasury Law, the Ministry of Finance has the authority to make investments. These investments can be share acquisitions, or purchases of bonds or other securities. But the investments should not be permanent investments.

Temporary investments are different from investments conducted through PMN. “PMN have permanent investment characteristics. PMN is a permanent capital participation and it needs DPR approval,” said Agus, the former CEO of Bank Mandiri.

The Ministry of Finance also hopes that the settlement process for buying Newmont divestment shares will be accelerated after Jero Wacik is replaced by Darwin Zahedy Saleh as the Minister of Energy and Mineral Resources.

Agus’s statement contradicts a statement made by Hatta Rajasa, the Coordinating Minister of Economic Affairs. According to Hatta Rajasa, the government is still waiting for BPK audit results. The government doesn’t want to make any decisions before studying the BPK audit results.

“We don’t want to violate any regulation. I will study the BPK audit result first,” he said.

As a reminder, Newmont operates the second largest copper mine in Indonesia after PT Freeport. Beside copper, Newmont also extracts gold and silver. From a business point of view, the Newmont mine is very promising and attracts a lot of investors. On May 6, 2011, Newmont divested seven percent of its shares. The government, through PIP, bought these shares for USD 246,8 million.

The current shareholders of Newmont Nusa Tenggara are: Newmont & Sumitomo (NTP) which owns 49 percent; Multi Daerah Bersaing (MDB), which owns 24 percent; Pukuafu Indah (PI), which owns 17,8 percent;Indonesia Masbaga Investama (IMI), which owns 2,2 percent and the Indonesian Government, which owns 7 percent.

(M Agus Yozami / Fitri Novia Heriani / Adi Condro Bawono)

It seems there will be another debate regarding the seven percent acquisition of Newmont Nusa Tenggara (“Newmont”) divestment shares. Vice Chairman of Commission XI of the House of Representatives (DPR), Harry AzharAzis, claims he obtained the Supreme Audit Agency’s (Badan Pemeriksa Keuangan – BPK) audit results regarding the Indonesia Investment Agency’s (Perusahaan Investasi Pemerintah – PIP) plans to buy Newmont shares. According to the audit results, PIP used State Revenue and Expenditure Budget (APBN) funds to purchase the shares, without DPR approval.

“The BPK states that based on the Newmont share acquisition audit results there was a violation. That is why we [ed. the DPR] call the Minister of Finance (Menkeu) as soon as possible,” said Harry Azhar Asis, Monday (24/10).

According to Harry, BPK’s opinion raises two points of concern for the government. First, the BPK states that a separate government regulation is required to regulate investments that use the funds from the state budget. This is similar to state capital participation (Penyertaan Modal Negara – PMN) for state-owned companies (BUMN), which also require a special regulation.

Second, the government should ask for DPR approval before implementing a divestment policy, because funds come from the APBN. After the BPK’s audit, there is no excuse for the Minister of Finance to continue the Newmont divestment transaction.

“In accordance with BPK audit results, the PIP plan to buy seven percent of Newmont shares must be void by law. Unless the Minister of Finance submits a new proposal to ask the DPR’s approval later,” said Harry, aFunctional Group Party (Golkar) politician.

Unfortunately, BPK has not publicly provided details about the audit results.Vice Chairman of the BPK, Hasan Bisri, did not reply to a hukumonline inquiry regarding this issue.

Meanwhile, the Minister of Finance, Agus Martowardojo admits that has not been informed about the BPK audit results yet. However, he will continue the plan to buy Newmont shares, even if the DPR doesn’t approve the plan. According to him, the plan to buy Newmont share does not violate any regulation. He insisted there is nothing wrong with buying the shares.

“We have legal grounds to buy seven percent of Newmont’s shares without DPR approval,” he asserts. “Everything is in accordance with Article 41 of Law No. 1 of 2004 on the State Treasury,” said the minister in the Ministry of Finance building, Monday (24/10).

Agus explains, from a legal perspective, there are two categories of government investment activities. The first category covers permanent investments through PMN. The second category includes temporary investments, such as PIP’s plan to buy seven percent of Newmont shares.

Agus says the PIP plan is in accordance with Article 41 of Law No. 1 of 2004 on State Treasury (“State Treasury Law”), which states “the government can make long-term investments to gain economic and social benefits, and/or other benefits in the form of shares, bonds, and direct investments”.

Agus said, based on the State Treasury Law, the Ministry of Finance has the authority to make investments. These investments can be share acquisitions, or purchases of bonds or other securities. But the investments should not be permanent investments.

Temporary investments are different from investments conducted through PMN. “PMN have permanent investment characteristics. PMN is a permanent capital participation and it needs DPR approval,” said Agus, the former CEO of Bank Mandiri.

The Ministry of Finance also hopes that the settlement process for buying Newmont divestment shares will be accelerated after Jero Wacik is replaced by Darwin Zahedy Saleh as the Minister of Energy and Mineral Resources.

Agus’s statement contradicts a statement made by Hatta Rajasa, the Coordinating Minister of Economic Affairs. According to Hatta Rajasa, the government is still waiting for BPK audit results. The government doesn’t want to make any decisions before studying the BPK audit results.

“We don’t want to violate any regulation. I will study the BPK audit result first,” he said.

As a reminder, Newmont operates the second largest copper mine in Indonesia after PT Freeport. Beside copper, Newmont also extracts gold and silver. From a business point of view, the Newmont mine is very promising and attracts a lot of investors. On May 6, 2011, Newmont divested seven percent of its shares. The government, through PIP, bought these shares for USD 246,8 million.

The current shareholders of Newmont Nusa Tenggara are: Newmont & Sumitomo (NTP) which owns 49 percent; Multi Daerah Bersaing (MDB), which owns 24 percent; Pukuafu Indah (PI), which owns 17,8 percent;Indonesia Masbaga Investama (IMI), which owns 2,2 percent and the Indonesian Government, which owns 7 percent.

(M Agus Yozami / Fitri Novia Heriani / Adi Condro Bawono)

2026 Hak Cipta Milik Hukumonline.com
Cookies Info