Representatives Reject Immigration Policy For Migrant Workers

The Indonesian government is scheduled to begin re-sending Indonesian migrant workers (TKI) to Malaysia on December 1, 2011, when the moratorium on sending migrant workers to Malaysia is lifted. However, the government must meet certain requirements before sending migrant workers to Malaysia.

A member of Commission IX of the DPR, Rizki Sadiq, is not convinced that the government is capable of implementing the policy to re-send Indonesian migrant workers to Malaysia. He believes that the government is not serious about providing prospective migrant workers with adequate training. He also said that proper work placements remain a serious issue.

“DPR Commission IX still takes the stance that lifting the moratorium is a bad decision,” said Rizki when contacted by hukumonline, Saturday (22/10).

Rizki explains that comprehensive improvements should be implemented before the moratorium is lifted. Commission IX rejected the plan, because there are still many Indonesian migrant workers who are facing capital punishment and identity forgery, besides the fact that they lack in working skills, which is a big issue.

“Comprehensive improvements should be made first,” he said.

The same concerns were also expressed by several non-governmental organizations (NGO/LSM) and worker’s unions (Serikat pekerja/Union). Migrant Care, an NGO that has been focusing on the rights of migrant workers, said that the agreement between Indonesia and Malaysia can’t solve migrant worker’s problems.

“It will be hard to control the [ed.policy] implementation. And what about the obedience of [ed.TKI] employers in Malaysia?” said Anis Hidayah, the Executive Director of Migrant Care, when interviewed by hukumonline, Saturday (22/10).

Lifting the moratorium and establishing a Joint Task Force does not seem promising. Anis doubted the Indonesian government’s ability to protect Indonesian migrant workers. Even though there are several requirements that must met before the moratorium is lifted.

Anis said the MoU will be weak in the implementation stages, since the MoU didn’t appoint an agency to force employers to comply with the requirements. Anis also explained that Malaysia doesn’t have any laws that specifically regulate the protection of Indonesian migrant workers who are employed as housemaids.

“Malaysia cannot supervise Indonesian migrant workers that work as housemaids, because there are no laws regarding this issue,” said Anis.

The Indonesian and Malaysian governments should conduct a routine evaluation after the moratorium is lifted. If there are no significant improvements, then the policy should be re-examined. It is better if Indonesia stops sending Migrant Workers to Malaysia.

“In my opinion there is no other way except to re-negotiate [the MoU] or stop sending migrant workers to Malaysia,” he said.

Previously, the government had never invited NGOs and unions to formulate the Indonesian migrant worker policy. The government actions and regulations to protect Indonesian migrant workers are not effective, because they haven’t received enough input from related parties.

NGOs and unions could make important contributions to formulating the policy. “[The government] should involve public elements when formulating the policy,” he said.

(Adi Thea / Adi Condro Bawono)

The Indonesian government is scheduled to begin re-sending Indonesian migrant workers (TKI) to Malaysia on December 1, 2011, when the moratorium on sending migrant workers to Malaysia is lifted. However, the government must meet certain requirements before sending migrant workers to Malaysia.

A member of Commission IX of the DPR, Rizki Sadiq, is not convinced that the government is capable of implementing the policy to re-send Indonesian migrant workers to Malaysia. He believes that the government is not serious about providing prospective migrant workers with adequate training. He also said that proper work placements remain a serious issue.

“DPR Commission IX still takes the stance that lifting the moratorium is a bad decision,” said Rizki when contacted by hukumonline, Saturday (22/10).

Rizki explains that comprehensive improvements should be implemented before the moratorium is lifted. Commission IX rejected the plan, because there are still many Indonesian migrant workers who are facing capital punishment and identity forgery, besides the fact that they lack in working skills, which is a big issue.

“Comprehensive improvements should be made first,” he said.

The same concerns were also expressed by several non-governmental organizations (NGO/LSM) and worker’s unions (Serikat pekerja/Union). Migrant Care, an NGO that has been focusing on the rights of migrant workers, said that the agreement between Indonesia and Malaysia can’t solve migrant worker’s problems.

“It will be hard to control the [ed.policy] implementation. And what about the obedience of [ed.TKI] employers in Malaysia?” said Anis Hidayah, the Executive Director of Migrant Care, when interviewed by hukumonline, Saturday (22/10).

Lifting the moratorium and establishing a Joint Task Force does not seem promising. Anis doubted the Indonesian government’s ability to protect Indonesian migrant workers. Even though there are several requirements that must met before the moratorium is lifted.

Anis said the MoU will be weak in the implementation stages, since the MoU didn’t appoint an agency to force employers to comply with the requirements. Anis also explained that Malaysia doesn’t have any laws that specifically regulate the protection of Indonesian migrant workers who are employed as housemaids.

“Malaysia cannot supervise Indonesian migrant workers that work as housemaids, because there are no laws regarding this issue,” said Anis.

The Indonesian and Malaysian governments should conduct a routine evaluation after the moratorium is lifted. If there are no significant improvements, then the policy should be re-examined. It is better if Indonesia stops sending Migrant Workers to Malaysia.

“In my opinion there is no other way except to re-negotiate [the MoU] or stop sending migrant workers to Malaysia,” he said.

Previously, the government had never invited NGOs and unions to formulate the Indonesian migrant worker policy. The government actions and regulations to protect Indonesian migrant workers are not effective, because they haven’t received enough input from related parties.

NGOs and unions could make important contributions to formulating the policy. “[The government] should involve public elements when formulating the policy,” he said.

(Adi Thea / Adi Condro Bawono)

2026 Hak Cipta Milik Hukumonline.com
Cookies Info