Preliminary discussions on revising Law No. 24 of 2000 on International Treaties have commenced. The Legislative Body of the House of Representatives has invited a number of international law and international relations experts to discuss solutions to issues related to international agreements.
Member of the Legislative Body from the Democratic Party, Dhiana Anwar criticized past government actions. She said the government has often ratified international conventions that do not benefit Indonesia.
“We have ratified too many conventions,” she said in the meeting room of the Legislative Body, Wednesday (12/10).
According to Dhiana, in some cases, the ratified convention is not implemented effectively, because countries that cooperate with Indonesia have not ratified the convention.
To provide an example, Dhiana explained that Indonesia has ratified the International Labor Organization (ILO) Convention to protect workers. However, Saudi Arabia, which employs many Indonesian migrant workers, has not ratified the convention. As a result, this convention, which would ideally protect migrant workers, does not apply in Saudi Arabia.
“Indonesia has ratified a lot of conventions, even more than the United States. We ratify too often,” said this politician from the Democratic Party.
International Law Lecturer from Faculty of Law at University of Indonesia, Harry P. Haryono admitted that Indonesia has ratified too many international conventions. He recognized that this practice started during President BJ Habibie’s regime.
This former diplomat stated that BJ Habibie instructed Ministry of Foreign Affairs to ratify all of the ILO conventions immediately. “We actually did not want to, but it was an instruction from the president. Besides, the ratification was [implemented] by a presidential decree, not law,” Harry explained.
Furthermore, Harry said that the government of Indonesia has to be confidence that it is capable of implementing signed conventions that will be ratified. “If it is deemed [that the convention] can not [be implemented], it would be better not to be a party to that convention,” he stated.
We may adopt the diplomacy style of the United States. Harry said that the United States is always talkative during international conferences, such as at UNCLOS (United Nations Convention on Law of the Sea) 1982. “They talked too much, but [in the end] they did not ratify [the UNCLOS 1982]. That’s the [diplomacy style of] the United States!” he explained.
However, in the context of UNCLOS, Harry agrees that Indonesia was a party and later ratified that convention, since Indonesia has interests that need to be accommodated by the convention.
“We ratified UNCLOS because we had an interest in ratifying the convention, so that the concept of archipelagic states (like Indonesia) were recognized and accommodated in the convention,” he elaborated.
Based on Hukumonline research, the Law on International Treaties does not strictly limit Indonesia from becoming a signatory to a convention and later ratifying the convention. We are waiting for the upcoming revision to see whether our advice that the government should not ratify too many conventions is treated as a reminder, or would the International undergo a revision.
(Ali Salmande / Josephine Hadiwijaya)
Preliminary discussions on revising Law No. 24 of 2000 on International Treaties have commenced. The Legislative Body of the House of Representatives has invited a number of international law and international relations experts to discuss solutions to issues related to international agreements.
Member of the Legislative Body from the Democratic Party, Dhiana Anwar criticized past government actions. She said the government has often ratified international conventions that do not benefit Indonesia.
“We have ratified too many conventions,” she said in the meeting room of the Legislative Body, Wednesday (12/10).
According to Dhiana, in some cases, the ratified convention is not implemented effectively, because countries that cooperate with Indonesia have not ratified the convention.
To provide an example, Dhiana explained that Indonesia has ratified the International Labor Organization (ILO) Convention to protect workers. However, Saudi Arabia, which employs many Indonesian migrant workers, has not ratified the convention. As a result, this convention, which would ideally protect migrant workers, does not apply in Saudi Arabia.
“Indonesia has ratified a lot of conventions, even more than the United States. We ratify too often,” said this politician from the Democratic Party.
International Law Lecturer from Faculty of Law at University of Indonesia, Harry P. Haryono admitted that Indonesia has ratified too many international conventions. He recognized that this practice started during President BJ Habibie’s regime.
This former diplomat stated that BJ Habibie instructed Ministry of Foreign Affairs to ratify all of the ILO conventions immediately. “We actually did not want to, but it was an instruction from the president. Besides, the ratification was [implemented] by a presidential decree, not law,” Harry explained.
Furthermore, Harry said that the government of Indonesia has to be confidence that it is capable of implementing signed conventions that will be ratified. “If it is deemed [that the convention] can not [be implemented], it would be better not to be a party to that convention,” he stated.
We may adopt the diplomacy style of the United States. Harry said that the United States is always talkative during international conferences, such as at UNCLOS (United Nations Convention on Law of the Sea) 1982. “They talked too much, but [in the end] they did not ratify [the UNCLOS 1982]. That’s the [diplomacy style of] the United States!” he explained.
However, in the context of UNCLOS, Harry agrees that Indonesia was a party and later ratified that convention, since Indonesia has interests that need to be accommodated by the convention.
“We ratified UNCLOS because we had an interest in ratifying the convention, so that the concept of archipelagic states (like Indonesia) were recognized and accommodated in the convention,” he elaborated.
Based on Hukumonline research, the Law on International Treaties does not strictly limit Indonesia from becoming a signatory to a convention and later ratifying the convention. We are waiting for the upcoming revision to see whether our advice that the government should not ratify too many conventions is treated as a reminder, or would the International undergo a revision.
(Ali Salmande / Josephine Hadiwijaya)