The Business Competition Supervisory Commission (KPPU) is reviewing the regulations on land use licenses issued by the Batam Island Industrial Development Authority (Batam Authority), in light of the fact that current licensing may discriminate against certain business actors.
KPPU Head of Public Relations and Legal Bureau, Ahmad Junaidi, explained that KPPU has received complaints about potential violations of Law No. 5 of 1999 on the Prohibition on Monopolistic Practices and Unfair Business Competition related to licensing land rights in Batam.
“KPPU has reviewed [the complaints] and will formulate a suggestion and recommendation that will be conveyed to the Batam Authority within the next 90 workdays,” said Junaidi at the KPPU office, in Jakarta, Wednesday (12/10).
Article 2 of Presidential Decree No. 41 of 1973 on the Batam Industrial Area (Decree), authorizes three institutions to develop, manage, and commercialize the industrial area of Batam Island. These institutions are the Batam Island Industrial Supervisory Agency, Batam Island Industrial Development Authority, and Batam Island Industrial Area Business Company (Persero).
Pursuant to Article 4 of the Decree, the Batam Authority is responsible for industrial development on Batam Island. Article 4(d) states that the Batam Authority is tasked with receiving and reviewing business license applications and submits it to the relevant institutions afterwards, as well as ensuring smooth licensing procedures and services for operating a business on Batam Island.
Article 6 elaborates on the purpose and utilization of land in the Batam industrial area. It also states that matters related to land utilization within the Batam industrial area will be managed by the Minister of Interior Affairs. However, the Head of the Batam Authority is also authorized to handle some land use issues, such as the use by a third party based on Articles 41 and 42 of the Agrarian Law. Moreover, it is also authorized to receive entrance fees or compensation fees and compulsory annual fees.
Minister of Interior Affairs Regulation No. 43 of 1997 (Regulation No. 43/1997) on the Management and Administration of Land in Batam Industrial Area was passed to address this issue. At that time, the incumbent Minister of Domestic Affairs, Amirmachmud decided that the Batam Authority would manage all the land on Batam Island, including the surrounding islands, as well as collect administration and compensation fees from third parties.
A few years later, the Minister of Domestic Affairs issued Regulation No. 1 of 1975 on Guidelines for Determining State Revenue, Mandatory Annual Fee, and Administration Fee related to rights granted for state land.
KPPU is questioning whether the Batam Authority has such a broad authority, since Article 3 of Regulation No. 43/1997 states that, the organizer of Batam industrial area will be established by a state-owned company in the form of a public company , i.e. the Batam Island Industrial Area Business Company (Persero).
KPPU assumed that there is a legal loophole concerning the Batam Authority’s role as a public agency and business actor that manages the Batam industrial area. KPPU is concerned such broad authority will hinder fair competition between businesses. “Because Batam Authority could determine land use rights for certain business without clear requirements,” Junaide explained.
Therefore, the KPPU team will evaluate whether the regulations result in unfair business competition within the next 90 workdays. Subsequently, KPPU will offer suggestions in order to ensure equal opportunities for operatng a business on Batam Island. “This is part of KPPU’s authority, in addition to law enforcement,“ said Junaidi.
(Leo Wisnu Susapto / Josephine Hadiwijaya)
The Business Competition Supervisory Commission (KPPU) is reviewing the regulations on land use licenses issued by the Batam Island Industrial Development Authority (Batam Authority), in light of the fact that current licensing may discriminate against certain business actors.
KPPU Head of Public Relations and Legal Bureau, Ahmad Junaidi, explained that KPPU has received complaints about potential violations of Law No. 5 of 1999 on the Prohibition on Monopolistic Practices and Unfair Business Competition related to licensing land rights in Batam.
“KPPU has reviewed [the complaints] and will formulate a suggestion and recommendation that will be conveyed to the Batam Authority within the next 90 workdays,” said Junaidi at the KPPU office, in Jakarta, Wednesday (12/10).
Article 2 of Presidential Decree No. 41 of 1973 on the Batam Industrial Area (Decree), authorizes three institutions to develop, manage, and commercialize the industrial area of Batam Island. These institutions are the Batam Island Industrial Supervisory Agency, Batam Island Industrial Development Authority, and Batam Island Industrial Area Business Company (Persero).
Pursuant to Article 4 of the Decree, the Batam Authority is responsible for industrial development on Batam Island. Article 4(d) states that the Batam Authority is tasked with receiving and reviewing business license applications and submits it to the relevant institutions afterwards, as well as ensuring smooth licensing procedures and services for operating a business on Batam Island.
Article 6 elaborates on the purpose and utilization of land in the Batam industrial area. It also states that matters related to land utilization within the Batam industrial area will be managed by the Minister of Interior Affairs. However, the Head of the Batam Authority is also authorized to handle some land use issues, such as the use by a third party based on Articles 41 and 42 of the Agrarian Law. Moreover, it is also authorized to receive entrance fees or compensation fees and compulsory annual fees.
Minister of Interior Affairs Regulation No. 43 of 1997 (Regulation No. 43/1997) on the Management and Administration of Land in Batam Industrial Area was passed to address this issue. At that time, the incumbent Minister of Domestic Affairs, Amirmachmud decided that the Batam Authority would manage all the land on Batam Island, including the surrounding islands, as well as collect administration and compensation fees from third parties.
A few years later, the Minister of Domestic Affairs issued Regulation No. 1 of 1975 on Guidelines for Determining State Revenue, Mandatory Annual Fee, and Administration Fee related to rights granted for state land.
KPPU is questioning whether the Batam Authority has such a broad authority, since Article 3 of Regulation No. 43/1997 states that, the organizer of Batam industrial area will be established by a state-owned company in the form of a public company , i.e. the Batam Island Industrial Area Business Company (Persero).
KPPU assumed that there is a legal loophole concerning the Batam Authority’s role as a public agency and business actor that manages the Batam industrial area. KPPU is concerned such broad authority will hinder fair competition between businesses. “Because Batam Authority could determine land use rights for certain business without clear requirements,” Junaide explained.
Therefore, the KPPU team will evaluate whether the regulations result in unfair business competition within the next 90 workdays. Subsequently, KPPU will offer suggestions in order to ensure equal opportunities for operatng a business on Batam Island. “This is part of KPPU’s authority, in addition to law enforcement,“ said Junaidi.
(Leo Wisnu Susapto / Josephine Hadiwijaya)