Public Concerned About Cell Phone Fraud

Recent short text message (SMS) scams have outraged the public and business community. The SMS scams have been used to steal cellular phone (cell phone) credit, harming consumers and the application and content industry.

The Indonesian Chamber of Commerce and Industry (KADIN) is concerned that these cases will affect the development of the creative application and content  industry. KADIN suspects the scams are the result of fraudulent practices by a few unscrupulous parties, but it affects the entire industry.

General Chairman of KADIN, Suryo Bambang Sulisto hopes the theft and fraud phone credit issue has not injured the industry. He said that KADIN, in cooperation with IMOCA (the Indonesian Mobile and Online Content Association) and ATSI (Asosiasi Telekomunikasi Seluler Indonesia) have  formulated a solution address the scams.

“This is to protect consumers and to maintain the existence of the content and application industry,” he said, Monday (10/10).

Currently, KADIN has 3 classifications related to the issue of phone credit theft and fraud through SMS. The first category includes an SMS such as ‘Mom Asks for Phone Credits’ (Mama Minta Pulsa) that does not relate to content providers and is obviously considered fraud.

The second category includes an SMS for an unsecured loan, which will eventually be sent by a party that is not related to telecommunication and content providers. However, Bambang said ATSI still does not consider these messages to be fraud.

The last category includes premium SMS that are the result of a collaboration between telecommunication and content providers. According to Bambang, the providers are bound by a cooperation agreement to provide services. “There is no policy to take the phone credits by fraud or theft,” he said.

Head of KADIN Permanent Committee Division of Application and Content Support, Yusuf K Hasnoputro, added that although ATSI and IMOCA admitted that there have been public complaints about unintentional premium SMS registration, which led consumers to follow the instructions to register for premium SMS services and lose their phone credits.

“To respond this issue, ATSI and IMOCA realized and agreed to continuously improve customer outreach and education efforts, so the customers are not trapped,” Yusuf said.

Recently, David Tobing, a consumer of the HALO mobile card, submitted a claim in the District Court of South Jakarta against Telkomsel, the issuer of the mobile card. David was disappointed because he received an SMS from Telkomsel on Saturday, 16 July 2011.

The message on the SMS was: “Thank you for subscribing to Mini Opera for IDR 10,000/7-days. Terms/Conditions apply, contact *363# to stop type OP OFF (and send) to 3636. To download, click http://mini.opera.com”.

was surprised to receive this SMS, because he has never subscribed to the Opera Mini service on his BlackBerry mobile. After this, David lost IDR 10,000 worth of cellphone credits every week, as  evident in his HALO card monthly phone bill. When David submitted his claim, his cell phone credit had already been cut nine times.

According to David, Telkomsel has committed a tortious act by binding the Opera Mini services unilaterally, automatically renewing the subscription period, and deducting credits or billing for services without prior consent from the customer.

“Subjective rights of the customers have been violated by Telkomsel,” David said.

Furthermore, David brought up the provisions in Article 1 (4) and (5) of Minister of Communication and Information Regulation No. 10/Per/M.Kominfo/3/2007 on the Use of Payable Features of Telecommunication Services. The Regulation stipulates that payable features are additional services that are provided by the telecommunication provider for a fee upon consent of the customer.

David also refers to Article 2(3) of the abovementioned regulation, pointing out Telkomsel’s legal obligation as a telecommunication provider to obtain prior written consent and/or consent by SMS from the customer to activate the payable feature.

David said, Telkomsel should have obtained prior consent from its customers to activate these payable features instead of unilaterally activating services and requiring the customer to deactivate services later.

Criminal Sanctions
The fraudulent theft of cell phone credits has also irritated members of the House of Representatives. Member of Commission I, Tjahjo Kumolo, criticized the approach of the Minister of Telecomunication and Information, Tifatul Sembiring, to these cases.

According to him, Tifatul, a Prosperous Justice Party (PKS) member, has been too ‘soft’. He called on the police to investigate these cases thoroughly.

“The Minister of Telecommunication and Information has not acted seriously. [I] Suspect they got kick-backs from these fraudulent acts,” said Tjahjo, a politician from the Indonesian Democratic Party of Struggle (PDIP).

According to Tjahjo, cell phone credit theft is subject to Article 362 of the Indonesian Criminal Code (KUHP). Under Article 362, whoever takes any goods, entirely or partially that belong to someone else, with the intention to own it, violates the law, and this may be considered theft punishable by up to 5 years of imprisonment.

“The word ‘take someone else’s goods’ in Article 362 of the KUHP has been widely interpreted. [The word ‘take’] does not only refer to ‘physical’ [action]. In  criminal law jurisprudence, if a person ‘steals electricity’ by connecting a wire from the utility pole to his house, he is considered to be stealing. This analogy could also be applied to cell phone credit theft,” Tjahojo clearly stated during a meeting with the Minister of Telecommunication and Information, Monday (10/10).

Tjahjo believes cell phone credit fraud and theft is criminal behavior. Providers could be investigated for committing crimes and the government is obliged to provide public assurance. According to him, these incidents can not be ignored, because the government is responsible for preventing this type of behavior.

Meanwhile, Tifatul stated government can not regulate cell phone content providers entirely.  He argued that there is no legal framework that authorizes the government to do this. The content provided is only registered with the Ministry.

“Government can not fully control content because there is no legal framework [that authorizes this],” he insisted.

Moreover, according to Tifatul, premium SMS, which have allegedly become a tool for phone credit theft, are regulated by Minister of Communication and Information Regulation No. 01 of 2009.

However, he said this regulation merely requires content providers to register. He explained that content providers are only controlled by operators through cooperation agreements. Therefore, his Ministry can only ask operators to blacklist troubled content providers.

He admitted that some parties have challenged the 2009 regulation. In addition, this regulation is already in the process of judicial review. Furthermore, Tifatul promised that he would meet the Criminal Investigation Agency (Bareskrim) of the National Police to investigate this matter.

“If there are in fact phone credit deductions, the police will investigate because it considered to be a criminal act,” he stated.

(M Agus Yozami / Josephine Hadiwijaya)

Recent short text message (SMS) scams have outraged the public and business community. The SMS scams have been used to steal cellular phone (cell phone) credit, harming consumers and the application and content industry.

The Indonesian Chamber of Commerce and Industry (KADIN) is concerned that these cases will affect the development of the creative application and content  industry. KADIN suspects the scams are the result of fraudulent practices by a few unscrupulous parties, but it affects the entire industry.

General Chairman of KADIN, Suryo Bambang Sulisto hopes the theft and fraud phone credit issue has not injured the industry. He said that KADIN, in cooperation with IMOCA (the Indonesian Mobile and Online Content Association) and ATSI (Asosiasi Telekomunikasi Seluler Indonesia) have  formulated a solution address the scams.

“This is to protect consumers and to maintain the existence of the content and application industry,” he said, Monday (10/10).

Currently, KADIN has 3 classifications related to the issue of phone credit theft and fraud through SMS. The first category includes an SMS such as ‘Mom Asks for Phone Credits’ (Mama Minta Pulsa) that does not relate to content providers and is obviously considered fraud.

The second category includes an SMS for an unsecured loan, which will eventually be sent by a party that is not related to telecommunication and content providers. However, Bambang said ATSI still does not consider these messages to be fraud.

The last category includes premium SMS that are the result of a collaboration between telecommunication and content providers. According to Bambang, the providers are bound by a cooperation agreement to provide services. “There is no policy to take the phone credits by fraud or theft,” he said.

Head of KADIN Permanent Committee Division of Application and Content Support, Yusuf K Hasnoputro, added that although ATSI and IMOCA admitted that there have been public complaints about unintentional premium SMS registration, which led consumers to follow the instructions to register for premium SMS services and lose their phone credits.

“To respond this issue, ATSI and IMOCA realized and agreed to continuously improve customer outreach and education efforts, so the customers are not trapped,” Yusuf said.

Recently, David Tobing, a consumer of the HALO mobile card, submitted a claim in the District Court of South Jakarta against Telkomsel, the issuer of the mobile card. David was disappointed because he received an SMS from Telkomsel on Saturday, 16 July 2011.

The message on the SMS was: “Thank you for subscribing to Mini Opera for IDR 10,000/7-days. Terms/Conditions apply, contact *363# to stop type OP OFF (and send) to 3636. To download, click http://mini.opera.com”.

was surprised to receive this SMS, because he has never subscribed to the Opera Mini service on his BlackBerry mobile. After this, David lost IDR 10,000 worth of cellphone credits every week, as  evident in his HALO card monthly phone bill. When David submitted his claim, his cell phone credit had already been cut nine times.

According to David, Telkomsel has committed a tortious act by binding the Opera Mini services unilaterally, automatically renewing the subscription period, and deducting credits or billing for services without prior consent from the customer.

“Subjective rights of the customers have been violated by Telkomsel,” David said.

Furthermore, David brought up the provisions in Article 1 (4) and (5) of Minister of Communication and Information Regulation No. 10/Per/M.Kominfo/3/2007 on the Use of Payable Features of Telecommunication Services. The Regulation stipulates that payable features are additional services that are provided by the telecommunication provider for a fee upon consent of the customer.

David also refers to Article 2(3) of the abovementioned regulation, pointing out Telkomsel’s legal obligation as a telecommunication provider to obtain prior written consent and/or consent by SMS from the customer to activate the payable feature.

David said, Telkomsel should have obtained prior consent from its customers to activate these payable features instead of unilaterally activating services and requiring the customer to deactivate services later.

Criminal Sanctions
The fraudulent theft of cell phone credits has also irritated members of the House of Representatives. Member of Commission I, Tjahjo Kumolo, criticized the approach of the Minister of Telecomunication and Information, Tifatul Sembiring, to these cases.

According to him, Tifatul, a Prosperous Justice Party (PKS) member, has been too ‘soft’. He called on the police to investigate these cases thoroughly.

“The Minister of Telecommunication and Information has not acted seriously. [I] Suspect they got kick-backs from these fraudulent acts,” said Tjahjo, a politician from the Indonesian Democratic Party of Struggle (PDIP).

According to Tjahjo, cell phone credit theft is subject to Article 362 of the Indonesian Criminal Code (KUHP). Under Article 362, whoever takes any goods, entirely or partially that belong to someone else, with the intention to own it, violates the law, and this may be considered theft punishable by up to 5 years of imprisonment.

“The word ‘take someone else’s goods’ in Article 362 of the KUHP has been widely interpreted. [The word ‘take’] does not only refer to ‘physical’ [action]. In  criminal law jurisprudence, if a person ‘steals electricity’ by connecting a wire from the utility pole to his house, he is considered to be stealing. This analogy could also be applied to cell phone credit theft,” Tjahojo clearly stated during a meeting with the Minister of Telecommunication and Information, Monday (10/10).

Tjahjo believes cell phone credit fraud and theft is criminal behavior. Providers could be investigated for committing crimes and the government is obliged to provide public assurance. According to him, these incidents can not be ignored, because the government is responsible for preventing this type of behavior.

Meanwhile, Tifatul stated government can not regulate cell phone content providers entirely.  He argued that there is no legal framework that authorizes the government to do this. The content provided is only registered with the Ministry.

“Government can not fully control content because there is no legal framework [that authorizes this],” he insisted.

Moreover, according to Tifatul, premium SMS, which have allegedly become a tool for phone credit theft, are regulated by Minister of Communication and Information Regulation No. 01 of 2009.

However, he said this regulation merely requires content providers to register. He explained that content providers are only controlled by operators through cooperation agreements. Therefore, his Ministry can only ask operators to blacklist troubled content providers.

He admitted that some parties have challenged the 2009 regulation. In addition, this regulation is already in the process of judicial review. Furthermore, Tifatul promised that he would meet the Criminal Investigation Agency (Bareskrim) of the National Police to investigate this matter.

“If there are in fact phone credit deductions, the police will investigate because it considered to be a criminal act,” he stated.

(M Agus Yozami / Josephine Hadiwijaya)

2026 Hak Cipta Milik Hukumonline.com
Cookies Info