The drafting process for a Government Regulation on Exclusive Breastfeeding (Draft) is almost complete, however, many business owners object to the Draft’s provisions. Business owners say the Draft is an unwarranted form of government intervention that will increase the cost of doing business.
To some extent, the Draft burdens business owners with several obligations. For instance, business owners or industries are obligated to provide employees with a special place to breastfeed their children or allow women to store breast milk in the work place.
Consequently, business owners will have to provide a nursing room and refrigerators to store breast milk. There is even a possibility that business owners will be required to provide daycare services.
“To fail, means that business owners will be subject to administrative sanctions, which may lead to the revocation of a business license,” said Franky Sibarani, the Coordinator of the Cross-Associations Forum and the Deputy Secretary General of the Indonesia Businessmen Association (APINDO).
Further, Franky said that the Draft will leave room for many interpretations, because the provisions on providing nursing rooms, daycare, and other obligations are unclear. This could result in inconsistent technical regulations caused by various interpretations at the regional level. Inconsistent regulations may impose additional costs on businesses.
In addition, there may also be new maternity leave requirements. “The draft may result in a high-cost economy and affect business conditions, as well as lower industry competitiveness,“ said Franky.
It should be noted that, the government is be ready to issue the Exclusive Breastfeeding Draft in in the near future. The Minister of Health, Endang Rahayu Sedyaningsih, believes that the Draft is not too controversial, so it can be implemented smoothly.
A few things that are included in the Draft are, the central and regional governments’ responsibility for promoting formula-milk and other products; a requirement for regions to accommodate exclusive breastfeeding for the first six months of a baby’s life; the establishment of nursing rooms in work places or public places; and also dispensation for employees to breastfeed.
This Draft, therefore, encourages breastfeeding during the first six months of a baby’s life. Moreover, it could protect and encourage mothers to breastfeed their children until they are two years old— allowing babies to exclusively consume breast-milk for their main nutrition.
Article 128 of Law No. 36 of 2009 on Health included provisions on exclusive breastfeeding. Article 128 (1) states that each infant has the right to exclusive breastfeeding until they are six months old, unless a medical condition forbids it.
Furthermore, Article 128 (2) states that any person, who hinders the exclusive breastfeeding program, is subject to up to one year of imprisonment and up to IDR 100 million of fines.
Franky said that if the Draft is implemented, it would have a negative impact on businesses and labor-intensive industries; particularly industries that employ women, such as plantation, cigarette manufacturing, modern retail, craft and furniture, food manufacturing, electronic, textile, and other industries.
“We agree on the Draft, as long as it encourages breastfeeding without interfering with the organization of manufacturing, distribution, and retail business,” said Franky.
On the other hand, the House of Representatives criticized Franky’s objection. Member of Commission IX, Hang Ali Saputra Syah Pahan said that it would be better if business owners were not just concerned about their own interests. In his opinion, the Draft should be passed as soon as possible, since many people are unaware of the importance of breastfeeding. In fact, breast-milk is better than formula-milk every aspect.
“We want the government to complete the Draft and familiarize the public on the issue,” said Hang Ali, a politician from the National Mandate Party (PAN), to hukumonline.
(M Agus Yozami / Josephine Hadiwijaya)
The drafting process for a Government Regulation on Exclusive Breastfeeding (Draft) is almost complete, however, many business owners object to the Draft’s provisions. Business owners say the Draft is an unwarranted form of government intervention that will increase the cost of doing business.
To some extent, the Draft burdens business owners with several obligations. For instance, business owners or industries are obligated to provide employees with a special place to breastfeed their children or allow women to store breast milk in the work place.
Consequently, business owners will have to provide a nursing room and refrigerators to store breast milk. There is even a possibility that business owners will be required to provide daycare services.
“To fail, means that business owners will be subject to administrative sanctions, which may lead to the revocation of a business license,” said Franky Sibarani, the Coordinator of the Cross-Associations Forum and the Deputy Secretary General of the Indonesia Businessmen Association (APINDO).
Further, Franky said that the Draft will leave room for many interpretations, because the provisions on providing nursing rooms, daycare, and other obligations are unclear. This could result in inconsistent technical regulations caused by various interpretations at the regional level. Inconsistent regulations may impose additional costs on businesses.
In addition, there may also be new maternity leave requirements. “The draft may result in a high-cost economy and affect business conditions, as well as lower industry competitiveness,“ said Franky.
It should be noted that, the government is be ready to issue the Exclusive Breastfeeding Draft in in the near future. The Minister of Health, Endang Rahayu Sedyaningsih, believes that the Draft is not too controversial, so it can be implemented smoothly.
A few things that are included in the Draft are, the central and regional governments’ responsibility for promoting formula-milk and other products; a requirement for regions to accommodate exclusive breastfeeding for the first six months of a baby’s life; the establishment of nursing rooms in work places or public places; and also dispensation for employees to breastfeed.
This Draft, therefore, encourages breastfeeding during the first six months of a baby’s life. Moreover, it could protect and encourage mothers to breastfeed their children until they are two years old— allowing babies to exclusively consume breast-milk for their main nutrition.
Article 128 of Law No. 36 of 2009 on Health included provisions on exclusive breastfeeding. Article 128 (1) states that each infant has the right to exclusive breastfeeding until they are six months old, unless a medical condition forbids it.
Furthermore, Article 128 (2) states that any person, who hinders the exclusive breastfeeding program, is subject to up to one year of imprisonment and up to IDR 100 million of fines.
Franky said that if the Draft is implemented, it would have a negative impact on businesses and labor-intensive industries; particularly industries that employ women, such as plantation, cigarette manufacturing, modern retail, craft and furniture, food manufacturing, electronic, textile, and other industries.
“We agree on the Draft, as long as it encourages breastfeeding without interfering with the organization of manufacturing, distribution, and retail business,” said Franky.
On the other hand, the House of Representatives criticized Franky’s objection. Member of Commission IX, Hang Ali Saputra Syah Pahan said that it would be better if business owners were not just concerned about their own interests. In his opinion, the Draft should be passed as soon as possible, since many people are unaware of the importance of breastfeeding. In fact, breast-milk is better than formula-milk every aspect.
“We want the government to complete the Draft and familiarize the public on the issue,” said Hang Ali, a politician from the National Mandate Party (PAN), to hukumonline.
(M Agus Yozami / Josephine Hadiwijaya)