Minister?s Authority to Grant Forest Area Permits is Constitutional

The Constitutional Court has denied a judicial review request regarding Article 38 (3) and 50 (3) (g) of the Law No 41 of 1999 on Forestry. "The petition is unreasonable, and the court denies it," said Mahfud MD, chief of the panel, at the Constitutional Court, Jakarta, Thursday (6/10).

Article 38 (3) and 50 (3) (g) of the Forestry Law state that forest area utilization permits for mining activities should be approved by the Ministry of Forestry. Andi Harahap, the  Regent of Penajam Paser Utara, East Borneo and applicant in this proceeding argued that these articles contradict Articles 18 and 18A of the 1945 Constitution and Article 21 of Law No. 32 of 2004 on Regional Government.

According to the applicant, forest area utilization permits should be within the authority of regional governments; as long as the permits meet certain requirements, such as, area limitations, time limitations, and environmental sustainability objectives. Moreover, Article 66 of the Forestry Law states that the government delegates some forestry affairs to regional governments.

The applicant asserted that Article 66 contradicts Articles 38 and 50. Furthermore, the investment climate in Penajam Paser Utara is stagnant, due to the complex procedures for obtaining forest utilization permits.

In its consideration, the court said that the procedure under Article 38 (3) cannot be interpreted as a violation of the regional autonomy principle or even a takeover of regional authority. Article 38 (3) is aimed at creating socially-oriented and environmentally-friendly mining activity.

"Therefore, the implementation requires strict sanctions, and it is relevant to the state's control over natural resources," said Hamdan Zoelva, one of the judges.

Forestry Law, according to Hamdan, clearly states the government's authority on forest area utilization licensing via the Minister of Forestry. In this sense, the Minister should thouroughly consider environmental sustainability and the social impact of a forest area utilization permit.

"Article 66 of the Forestry Law is intended to accommodate regional government, so that the government may grant a partial delegation. In that sense, the articles are correct," he asserted.

Hamdan also said that the government is authorized to supervise and control its natural resources, and to conduct constitutional economic activities. In addition, Hamdan added that the regional autonomy principle is included in Article 66 of the Forestry Law; therefore, Articles 38 (3) and 50 (3) (g) are in line with the 1945 Constitution.

(Agus Sahbani / Pirhot Nababan)

The Constitutional Court has denied a judicial review request regarding Article 38 (3) and 50 (3) (g) of the Law No 41 of 1999 on Forestry. "The petition is unreasonable, and the court denies it," said Mahfud MD, chief of the panel, at the Constitutional Court, Jakarta, Thursday (6/10).

Article 38 (3) and 50 (3) (g) of the Forestry Law state that forest area utilization permits for mining activities should be approved by the Ministry of Forestry. Andi Harahap, the  Regent of Penajam Paser Utara, East Borneo and applicant in this proceeding argued that these articles contradict Articles 18 and 18A of the 1945 Constitution and Article 21 of Law No. 32 of 2004 on Regional Government.

According to the applicant, forest area utilization permits should be within the authority of regional governments; as long as the permits meet certain requirements, such as, area limitations, time limitations, and environmental sustainability objectives. Moreover, Article 66 of the Forestry Law states that the government delegates some forestry affairs to regional governments.

The applicant asserted that Article 66 contradicts Articles 38 and 50. Furthermore, the investment climate in Penajam Paser Utara is stagnant, due to the complex procedures for obtaining forest utilization permits.

In its consideration, the court said that the procedure under Article 38 (3) cannot be interpreted as a violation of the regional autonomy principle or even a takeover of regional authority. Article 38 (3) is aimed at creating socially-oriented and environmentally-friendly mining activity.

"Therefore, the implementation requires strict sanctions, and it is relevant to the state's control over natural resources," said Hamdan Zoelva, one of the judges.

Forestry Law, according to Hamdan, clearly states the government's authority on forest area utilization licensing via the Minister of Forestry. In this sense, the Minister should thouroughly consider environmental sustainability and the social impact of a forest area utilization permit.

"Article 66 of the Forestry Law is intended to accommodate regional government, so that the government may grant a partial delegation. In that sense, the articles are correct," he asserted.

Hamdan also said that the government is authorized to supervise and control its natural resources, and to conduct constitutional economic activities. In addition, Hamdan added that the regional autonomy principle is included in Article 66 of the Forestry Law; therefore, Articles 38 (3) and 50 (3) (g) are in line with the 1945 Constitution.

(Agus Sahbani / Pirhot Nababan)

2026 Hak Cipta Milik Hukumonline.com
Cookies Info