The PT Freeport Indonesia (Freeport) Work Contract dispute is still in the mediation phase in the South Jakarta District Court. The Indonesian Human Rights Committee For Social Justice (IHCS) submitted the claim in July 2011, arguing that Freeport failed to pay the proper amount of gold royalties.
Under Freeport’s Work Contract that was extended in 1991 (Contract), Freeport is obliged to pay gold royalties to Government of Indonesia at 1 percent. However, this rate is no longer in line with the prevailing regulation, i.e. Government Regulation No. 45 of 2003 on Non-Tax State Income Tariffs (PP), which stipulates that gold royalties are equal to 3,75 percent of the selling price multiplied by tonnage. According to IHCS, a 3,75 percent gold royalty is very low compared to African countries.
Although it was only charged a 1 percent gold royalty, Freeport has allegedly never paid any gold royalties. For 25 years, Freeport only paid copper royalties to the Government of Indonesia. Referring to the Work Contract (generation) I in 1967, Freeport reported that Freeport ony excavated for copper. However, Freeport has been exporting gold since 1978. Given this fact, IHCS, representing Indonesian citizens, claims it has been harmed. The royalty payment, which is a source of Non-Tax State Income, should have been used for the prosperity of the Indonesian people. IHCS estimates that the State has suffered losses of up to US$ 256,17 million.
“For us, the revision of the Contract and the royalty payment could not be compromised,” said Gunawan the Secretary General of IHCS and plaintiff Tuesday (4/10). IHCS considers the revision of the Work Contract and the royalty is a must. According to Gunawan, the Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources (ESDM) should revise the Contract that sets gold royalties at 1 percent, because based on PP, the gold royalty is set at 3,75 percent of the selling tonnage price. Hence, Gunawan says the Minister of ESDM (the defendant I) and Freeport (the defendant II) have carried out a legally defective agreement since 31 July 2003, because the Work Contract is not in accordance with PP.
However, the Minister of ESDM, Freeport, President (the defendant III), and House of Representatives (the co-defendant) have not responded to IHCS’s claim. The attorney for the Minister of ESDM and Freeport has asked IHCS to submit a concrete proposal. When IHCS insists on determining the merit of the claim, the Minister of ESDM and Freeport will not respond in court.
Meanwhile, the attorney for the House of Representatives was absent during the mediation. The attorney for the President, Maria, admitted that they are not yet prepared to submit any offering proposal. “We ask for a week [to prepare]. We are not ready yet,” said Maria. Given this condition, Gunawan expects Minister of ESDM, President and House of Representatives to provide a proposal that reflects the government’s efforts during the next mediation, scheduled on 11 October 2011.
Gunawan also cited the media, which has reported that the President and the Coordinating Minister of Economic Affairs, Hatta Rajasa have discussed mining renegotiation contracts, including Freeport’s Work Contract. “Co-chairman of the House of Representatives, Pramono Anung, has also pushed for renegotiating the Freeport [contract] and Freeport itself initially rejected this, but now has accepted the renegotiation,” said Gunawan.
Moreover, IHCS assumed that the Contract no longer fulfills the legal requirements for an agreement pursuant to Article 1320 of Indonesian Civil Code. It is obvious that the Contract has violated the provision stipulated in PP, thus it could be considered void by law. Thus, in its claim, IHCS requests the Minister of ESDM, Freeport, and the President to revise the Contract to be in accordance with provisions in PP. Furthermore, IHCS also asks the defendants to pay [the gold royalty] jointly in the amount of US$ 256,17 million to the State’s account.
In response to IHCS’s claim, spokesperson for Freeport, Ramdani Sirait, has stated that Freeport is still committed to fulfilling all prevailing agreements and laws. Ramdani believes the Contract between Freeport and the Government of Indonesia is fair enough and is better than contracts in other mineral producing countries.
Moreover, Ramdani said that Freeport has contributed more than US$ 12 billion pursuant to the Contract executed in 1991. “The contribution consists of taxes, dividends, and royalties for copper, gold, and silver. We expect continuing success in the decades ahead,” said Ramdani.
(Novirieza Rahmi / Josephine Hadiwijaya)
The PT Freeport Indonesia (Freeport) Work Contract dispute is still in the mediation phase in the South Jakarta District Court. The Indonesian Human Rights Committee For Social Justice (IHCS) submitted the claim in July 2011, arguing that Freeport failed to pay the proper amount of gold royalties.
Under Freeport’s Work Contract that was extended in 1991 (Contract), Freeport is obliged to pay gold royalties to Government of Indonesia at 1 percent. However, this rate is no longer in line with the prevailing regulation, i.e. Government Regulation No. 45 of 2003 on Non-Tax State Income Tariffs (PP), which stipulates that gold royalties are equal to 3,75 percent of the selling price multiplied by tonnage. According to IHCS, a 3,75 percent gold royalty is very low compared to African countries.
Although it was only charged a 1 percent gold royalty, Freeport has allegedly never paid any gold royalties. For 25 years, Freeport only paid copper royalties to the Government of Indonesia. Referring to the Work Contract (generation) I in 1967, Freeport reported that Freeport ony excavated for copper. However, Freeport has been exporting gold since 1978. Given this fact, IHCS, representing Indonesian citizens, claims it has been harmed. The royalty payment, which is a source of Non-Tax State Income, should have been used for the prosperity of the Indonesian people. IHCS estimates that the State has suffered losses of up to US$ 256,17 million.
“For us, the revision of the Contract and the royalty payment could not be compromised,” said Gunawan the Secretary General of IHCS and plaintiff Tuesday (4/10). IHCS considers the revision of the Work Contract and the royalty is a must. According to Gunawan, the Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources (ESDM) should revise the Contract that sets gold royalties at 1 percent, because based on PP, the gold royalty is set at 3,75 percent of the selling tonnage price. Hence, Gunawan says the Minister of ESDM (the defendant I) and Freeport (the defendant II) have carried out a legally defective agreement since 31 July 2003, because the Work Contract is not in accordance with PP.
However, the Minister of ESDM, Freeport, President (the defendant III), and House of Representatives (the co-defendant) have not responded to IHCS’s claim. The attorney for the Minister of ESDM and Freeport has asked IHCS to submit a concrete proposal. When IHCS insists on determining the merit of the claim, the Minister of ESDM and Freeport will not respond in court.
Meanwhile, the attorney for the House of Representatives was absent during the mediation. The attorney for the President, Maria, admitted that they are not yet prepared to submit any offering proposal. “We ask for a week [to prepare]. We are not ready yet,” said Maria. Given this condition, Gunawan expects Minister of ESDM, President and House of Representatives to provide a proposal that reflects the government’s efforts during the next mediation, scheduled on 11 October 2011.
Gunawan also cited the media, which has reported that the President and the Coordinating Minister of Economic Affairs, Hatta Rajasa have discussed mining renegotiation contracts, including Freeport’s Work Contract. “Co-chairman of the House of Representatives, Pramono Anung, has also pushed for renegotiating the Freeport [contract] and Freeport itself initially rejected this, but now has accepted the renegotiation,” said Gunawan.
Moreover, IHCS assumed that the Contract no longer fulfills the legal requirements for an agreement pursuant to Article 1320 of Indonesian Civil Code. It is obvious that the Contract has violated the provision stipulated in PP, thus it could be considered void by law. Thus, in its claim, IHCS requests the Minister of ESDM, Freeport, and the President to revise the Contract to be in accordance with provisions in PP. Furthermore, IHCS also asks the defendants to pay [the gold royalty] jointly in the amount of US$ 256,17 million to the State’s account.
In response to IHCS’s claim, spokesperson for Freeport, Ramdani Sirait, has stated that Freeport is still committed to fulfilling all prevailing agreements and laws. Ramdani believes the Contract between Freeport and the Government of Indonesia is fair enough and is better than contracts in other mineral producing countries.
Moreover, Ramdani said that Freeport has contributed more than US$ 12 billion pursuant to the Contract executed in 1991. “The contribution consists of taxes, dividends, and royalties for copper, gold, and silver. We expect continuing success in the decades ahead,” said Ramdani.
(Novirieza Rahmi / Josephine Hadiwijaya)