The iPad case is still ongoing in the Central Jakarta District Court.However, the defendants in the iPad case have challenged the Consumer Protection Law in the Constitutional Court (MK). They asked MK to find Article 62 (1) in conjunction with Article 8 (1) (j) of Law No. 8 of 1999 on Consumer Protection unconstitutional.
Virza Roy Hizzal formally submitted a petition for review of the two articles. Vizra is the General Chairman of the Indonesian Advocates Organization (OAI) and the lawyer for the defendants in the iPad case. He submitted the petition on behalf of his clients, who are iPad defendants, Dian Yudha Negara and Randy Lester Samusamu.
“Article 62 (1) in conjunction with Article 8 (1) (j) of the Consumer Protection Law is a way to use the law as means to incriminate people with criminal charges,” Virsa commented when submitting the case petition at the MK building in Jakarta, Monday (3/10).
Article 62 (1) states, “businesses that violate the provisions in Article 8, Article 9, Article 10, Article 13 (2), Article 15, Article 17 (1) (a), Article 17 (1) (b), Article 17 (1) (c), Article 17 (1) (d), Article 17 (1) (e), Article 17 (2) and Article 18 shall be punished by a maximum of five years imprisonment or by a maximum of IDR 2 billion fines.”
Article 8 (1) (j) states, “Businesses are prohibited from producing and/or selling goods and services that do not have Indonesian language information and/or manuals as stipulated by existing law.”
Virza argues that both articles are unclear and open to multiple interpretations. He also explained that Article 62 (1) of Consumer Protection Law apply criminal sanctions instead of civil sanctions to businesses that produce or sell goods that do not have an Indonesian language manual.
“Article 62 (1) in conjunction with Article 8 (1) (j) of the Consumer Protection Law is in conflict with the certainty before a just law principle embodied in Article 28D (1) of the Constitution,” said Virza.
The petitioner admits that the effort to review the Consumer Protection Law is due to the iPad case. In the iPad case, law enforcers apprehended iPad sellers who failed to provide an Indonesian manual for their products by targeting iPad sellers who promoted their products on the www.kaskus.us website.
According to the Tempo website (www.tempo.com),the Police apprehended several iPad sellers after they failed to provide Indonesian manuals for their products. The sellers were prosecuted for violating Articles 62(1) and 8 (1)(j) of the Consumer Protection Law.
The sellers could face several months of imprisonment. Wiwi Siswanto was sentenced to 6 months of imprisonment. Meanwhile, prosecutors have sought 5 months jail time for Dian and Randy, who are still waiting for judges in the Central Jakarta District Court to sentence them. In addition, there are ongoing cases in the South Jakarta District Court against Charlie Sianipar, and a case in the West Jakarta District Court against Calvil Winoto.
According to Virza, law enforcers who arrest iPad sellers do not respect the phrase “ ...as stipulated by existing law”. Under Minister of Trade Regulation No. 19 of 2009, iPad is not one of the 45 products that are required to be sold with an Indonesian manual and guarantee.
Virza says Article 62 (1) in conjunction with Article 8 (1) (j) of the Consumer Protection Law conflict with Article 1 (3), Article 27 (1), Article 28D (1), Article 28C, and Article 28G (1) of the Constitution. “We demand that these articles be revoked, because they conflict with the Constitution,” he insisted.
In addition, Virza has also asked MK to order the Police and Public Prosecutor's Office to stop their investigations and prosecutions of all suspects and defendants who are currently being investigated/prosecuted based on Article 62 (1) in conjunction with Article 8 (1) (j) of the Consumer Protection Law.
(Agus Sahbani/Adi Condro Bawono)
The iPad case is still ongoing in the Central Jakarta District Court.However, the defendants in the iPad case have challenged the Consumer Protection Law in the Constitutional Court (MK). They asked MK to find Article 62 (1) in conjunction with Article 8 (1) (j) of Law No. 8 of 1999 on Consumer Protection unconstitutional.
Virza Roy Hizzal formally submitted a petition for review of the two articles. Vizra is the General Chairman of the Indonesian Advocates Organization (OAI) and the lawyer for the defendants in the iPad case. He submitted the petition on behalf of his clients, who are iPad defendants, Dian Yudha Negara and Randy Lester Samusamu.
“Article 62 (1) in conjunction with Article 8 (1) (j) of the Consumer Protection Law is a way to use the law as means to incriminate people with criminal charges,” Virsa commented when submitting the case petition at the MK building in Jakarta, Monday (3/10).
Article 62 (1) states, “businesses that violate the provisions in Article 8, Article 9, Article 10, Article 13 (2), Article 15, Article 17 (1) (a), Article 17 (1) (b), Article 17 (1) (c), Article 17 (1) (d), Article 17 (1) (e), Article 17 (2) and Article 18 shall be punished by a maximum of five years imprisonment or by a maximum of IDR 2 billion fines.”
Article 8 (1) (j) states, “Businesses are prohibited from producing and/or selling goods and services that do not have Indonesian language information and/or manuals as stipulated by existing law.”
Virza argues that both articles are unclear and open to multiple interpretations. He also explained that Article 62 (1) of Consumer Protection Law apply criminal sanctions instead of civil sanctions to businesses that produce or sell goods that do not have an Indonesian language manual.
“Article 62 (1) in conjunction with Article 8 (1) (j) of the Consumer Protection Law is in conflict with the certainty before a just law principle embodied in Article 28D (1) of the Constitution,” said Virza.
The petitioner admits that the effort to review the Consumer Protection Law is due to the iPad case. In the iPad case, law enforcers apprehended iPad sellers who failed to provide an Indonesian manual for their products by targeting iPad sellers who promoted their products on the www.kaskus.us website.
According to the Tempo website (www.tempo.com),the Police apprehended several iPad sellers after they failed to provide Indonesian manuals for their products. The sellers were prosecuted for violating Articles 62(1) and 8 (1)(j) of the Consumer Protection Law.
The sellers could face several months of imprisonment. Wiwi Siswanto was sentenced to 6 months of imprisonment. Meanwhile, prosecutors have sought 5 months jail time for Dian and Randy, who are still waiting for judges in the Central Jakarta District Court to sentence them. In addition, there are ongoing cases in the South Jakarta District Court against Charlie Sianipar, and a case in the West Jakarta District Court against Calvil Winoto.
According to Virza, law enforcers who arrest iPad sellers do not respect the phrase “ ...as stipulated by existing law”. Under Minister of Trade Regulation No. 19 of 2009, iPad is not one of the 45 products that are required to be sold with an Indonesian manual and guarantee.
Virza says Article 62 (1) in conjunction with Article 8 (1) (j) of the Consumer Protection Law conflict with Article 1 (3), Article 27 (1), Article 28D (1), Article 28C, and Article 28G (1) of the Constitution. “We demand that these articles be revoked, because they conflict with the Constitution,” he insisted.
In addition, Virza has also asked MK to order the Police and Public Prosecutor's Office to stop their investigations and prosecutions of all suspects and defendants who are currently being investigated/prosecuted based on Article 62 (1) in conjunction with Article 8 (1) (j) of the Consumer Protection Law.
(Agus Sahbani/Adi Condro Bawono)