Mining Contracts Fail to Protect Public from Environmental Harm

 

In many cases, it is hard to prove who is responsible for pollution. As a result, companies often get away with polluting the environment. However, the Government has not made any tangible effort to address pollution issues. Suripto, a former Commission III member of The House of Representatives (DPR) made these comments at a seminar in Jakarta last Thursday (29/9).

Suripto said, past work contracts (KK) between the Government and multinational corporations (MNC) shows that the Government does not fully comprehend the legal implications of work contract terms. Consequently, when the Government drafted the work contract, they did not include clear environmental responsibility clauses to address pollution caused by the mining industry.

“The Government has only recently become aware of environmental pollution cases, the work contracts between the Government and MNC’s contain unclear legal mechanisms, so pollution cases often fall into a grey area” he said.

A few examples of environmental pollution cases that slipped through the law’s grasp are:the 2004 mercury contamination case in Mimika caused by PT Freeport Indonesia; the 2005 mercury contamination case in Nangroe Aceh Darussalam caused by PT Exxon Mobil Oil Indonesia; the Buyat Bay environmental pollution case involving PT Newmont Minahasa Raya in 2004; and the Timor Sea Montara oil pollution case involving PT TEP Australia (Ashomre Cartier) in 2009.


The Government’s failure to fully comprehend the law when drafting work contract has had negative consequences during dispute resolutions. The results of several actions filed by the Government and Non-Governmental Organizations, show that civil and criminal actions fail to hold businesses responsible for pollution. 

As a result, Suripto says these cases have set a bad precedent for law enforcement in Indonesia for similar disputes. Consequently, “the people in mining areas become the real victims of environmental pollution, and do not receive any economic value from environmental pollution incidents,” he added.

The pressure to renegotiate mining contracts has increased recently. In addition to the environmental pollution issue, there are demands for mining companies (especially Freeport) to provide more royalties to the state. Chandra Tirta Wijaya a member of Commission VII of the House of Representatives (DPR) said Freeport revenues from their mining operation in Tembagapura-Papua are still three times higher than Government revenue from taxes, royalties, and dividends given by the company.

According to Chandra, the Indonesian Government has only received USD 479 million since 1996, while Freeport has received USD 1,5 billion. In 2005, the Government only received USD 1,1 billion, while Freeport received USD 4,1 billion(before taxes).   

To date, Freeport only pays a 1 percent gold royalty, and copper royalties between 1,5 to 3,5 percent to the Government. “Clearly this royalty is much lower than other countries, which usually apply 6 percent royalty for copper and 5 percent royalty for gold and silver,” he said.

Meanwhile, Darwin Zahedy the Minister of Energy and Mineral Resources (ESDM) is optimistic about Freeport’s desire to renegotiate their work contract. In the same Commission VII hearing at the House of Representatives (DPR), he asked mining entrepreneurs to understand Government’s effort to renegotiate.

“The Government effort to renegotiate should be seen as an opportunity for mining entrepreneurs, especially huge mining companies such as Freeport,” said Darwin.

For example, he explained that mining companies can take advantage of opportunities such as developing a domestic smelter, so that the element of added value and domestic use of services increases. 

Furthermore, Darwin said that mining contract renegotiation is a mandated by the people as stated in the law. Therefore, he hopes foreign contractors who cooperate with Indonesia will pay attention to the Government’s wishes in the search for added value in the mining sector.

(M Agus Yozami/Adi Condro Bawono)

 

In many cases, it is hard to prove who is responsible for pollution. As a result, companies often get away with polluting the environment. However, the Government has not made any tangible effort to address pollution issues. Suripto, a former Commission III member of The House of Representatives (DPR) made these comments at a seminar in Jakarta last Thursday (29/9).

Suripto said, past work contracts (KK) between the Government and multinational corporations (MNC) shows that the Government does not fully comprehend the legal implications of work contract terms. Consequently, when the Government drafted the work contract, they did not include clear environmental responsibility clauses to address pollution caused by the mining industry.

“The Government has only recently become aware of environmental pollution cases, the work contracts between the Government and MNC’s contain unclear legal mechanisms, so pollution cases often fall into a grey area” he said.

A few examples of environmental pollution cases that slipped through the law’s grasp are:the 2004 mercury contamination case in Mimika caused by PT Freeport Indonesia; the 2005 mercury contamination case in Nangroe Aceh Darussalam caused by PT Exxon Mobil Oil Indonesia; the Buyat Bay environmental pollution case involving PT Newmont Minahasa Raya in 2004; and the Timor Sea Montara oil pollution case involving PT TEP Australia (Ashomre Cartier) in 2009.


The Government’s failure to fully comprehend the law when drafting work contract has had negative consequences during dispute resolutions. The results of several actions filed by the Government and Non-Governmental Organizations, show that civil and criminal actions fail to hold businesses responsible for pollution. 

As a result, Suripto says these cases have set a bad precedent for law enforcement in Indonesia for similar disputes. Consequently, “the people in mining areas become the real victims of environmental pollution, and do not receive any economic value from environmental pollution incidents,” he added.

The pressure to renegotiate mining contracts has increased recently. In addition to the environmental pollution issue, there are demands for mining companies (especially Freeport) to provide more royalties to the state. Chandra Tirta Wijaya a member of Commission VII of the House of Representatives (DPR) said Freeport revenues from their mining operation in Tembagapura-Papua are still three times higher than Government revenue from taxes, royalties, and dividends given by the company.

According to Chandra, the Indonesian Government has only received USD 479 million since 1996, while Freeport has received USD 1,5 billion. In 2005, the Government only received USD 1,1 billion, while Freeport received USD 4,1 billion(before taxes).   

To date, Freeport only pays a 1 percent gold royalty, and copper royalties between 1,5 to 3,5 percent to the Government. “Clearly this royalty is much lower than other countries, which usually apply 6 percent royalty for copper and 5 percent royalty for gold and silver,” he said.

Meanwhile, Darwin Zahedy the Minister of Energy and Mineral Resources (ESDM) is optimistic about Freeport’s desire to renegotiate their work contract. In the same Commission VII hearing at the House of Representatives (DPR), he asked mining entrepreneurs to understand Government’s effort to renegotiate.

“The Government effort to renegotiate should be seen as an opportunity for mining entrepreneurs, especially huge mining companies such as Freeport,” said Darwin.

For example, he explained that mining companies can take advantage of opportunities such as developing a domestic smelter, so that the element of added value and domestic use of services increases. 

Furthermore, Darwin said that mining contract renegotiation is a mandated by the people as stated in the law. Therefore, he hopes foreign contractors who cooperate with Indonesia will pay attention to the Government’s wishes in the search for added value in the mining sector.

(M Agus Yozami/Adi Condro Bawono)

2026 Hak Cipta Milik Hukumonline.com
Cookies Info