Bad Decisions Reflect Poorly on BANI

 

The Arbiter of the Indonesian National Board of Arbitration (Badan Arbitrase Nasional Indonesia/BANI) needs enhance the quality of its decisions. Otherwise, BANI will be abandoned as a venue in resolving dispute. The Arbiters of BANI should firmly refer to prevailing laws, other arbitration regulations, and take international arbitration practices into account.

According to Todung Mulya Lubis, legal attorney of PT Wira Insani, BANI can play a strategic role in business dispute resolution in Indonesia.However, some of its decisions might be questioned. He questioned BANI’s recent decision in the PT Wira Insanicase against  PT Gear Capital. In the case, BANI penalized PT Wira Insani to pay PT Gear Capital and PT Carana Bunga Persada US$ 8 million. 

Todung explained that his client, PT Wira Insani,is thelicensed distributor for Weatherford International productsin Indonesia. “Licensing sales in Indonesia was granted by a representative of Weatherford Asia Pacific,” explained Todung. Weatherford International is a global supplier of oil and gas equipment and services, based in the United States.

Wira Insani initially planned Gear Capital as its sales agent. The companies had initial discussions, where Gear Capital expressed its intent to involve its affiliation company, PT Carana. However, the companies were unable to reach an agreement. According to Todung, a cooperation agreement was not signed. “There is no written agreement signed by the parties,” he said. The annulment of the plan was then disputed by Gear Capital, which submitted the dispute to BANI.

The problem appeared during the arbitration process, because PT Carana, PT Weatherford International, and PT Weatherford Indonesia are involved as parties in the dispute. He repeatedly said, “The agreement was between Wira Insani and Gear Capital. Nevertheless, a written agreement was not executed”. Thus, Todung is questioning BANI’s decision, which declared that his client violated the agreement. “How can our client be punished for something that has not occurred,” he wondered.

Moreover, Todung senses that this will become a bad precedent for BANI. “To become an alternative dispute resolution insitution, BANI must be capable of providing a fair, balanced, and international qualityarbitration process. If [disputes] turn out like this, BANI will be underestimated, particularly by international business entities,” he stated.

Todung explained that he and the two others respondents(PT Weatherford International and PT Weatherford Indonesia), have submitted an annulment request to the District Court of South Jakarta. “For my client, the first hearing will start on 11 October. Mean while, thetwo other respondents have a different attorney. If I’m not mistaken, [they] are already in the mediation stage,” he explained.

On the other hand, when the Secretary General of BANI, N. Krisnawenda, was contacted by telephone,he refused to makeany comment. According to him, it is unethical for an arbiter to comment on the decisions of other arbiters. “Even if I were [the arbiter] who decided [the case], I would be bound by arbitration material confidentiality. I cannot make any comment,” he said. However,Krisnawenda said it is not a problem for the parties to submit the annulment. “The right [to submit anannulment]is regulated by the prevailing laws,” he asserted.

(Josephine Hadiwijaya/ Davidson Samosir)

 

The Arbiter of the Indonesian National Board of Arbitration (Badan Arbitrase Nasional Indonesia/BANI) needs enhance the quality of its decisions. Otherwise, BANI will be abandoned as a venue in resolving dispute. The Arbiters of BANI should firmly refer to prevailing laws, other arbitration regulations, and take international arbitration practices into account.

According to Todung Mulya Lubis, legal attorney of PT Wira Insani, BANI can play a strategic role in business dispute resolution in Indonesia.However, some of its decisions might be questioned. He questioned BANI’s recent decision in the PT Wira Insanicase against  PT Gear Capital. In the case, BANI penalized PT Wira Insani to pay PT Gear Capital and PT Carana Bunga Persada US$ 8 million. 

Todung explained that his client, PT Wira Insani,is thelicensed distributor for Weatherford International productsin Indonesia. “Licensing sales in Indonesia was granted by a representative of Weatherford Asia Pacific,” explained Todung. Weatherford International is a global supplier of oil and gas equipment and services, based in the United States.

Wira Insani initially planned Gear Capital as its sales agent. The companies had initial discussions, where Gear Capital expressed its intent to involve its affiliation company, PT Carana. However, the companies were unable to reach an agreement. According to Todung, a cooperation agreement was not signed. “There is no written agreement signed by the parties,” he said. The annulment of the plan was then disputed by Gear Capital, which submitted the dispute to BANI.

The problem appeared during the arbitration process, because PT Carana, PT Weatherford International, and PT Weatherford Indonesia are involved as parties in the dispute. He repeatedly said, “The agreement was between Wira Insani and Gear Capital. Nevertheless, a written agreement was not executed”. Thus, Todung is questioning BANI’s decision, which declared that his client violated the agreement. “How can our client be punished for something that has not occurred,” he wondered.

Moreover, Todung senses that this will become a bad precedent for BANI. “To become an alternative dispute resolution insitution, BANI must be capable of providing a fair, balanced, and international qualityarbitration process. If [disputes] turn out like this, BANI will be underestimated, particularly by international business entities,” he stated.

Todung explained that he and the two others respondents(PT Weatherford International and PT Weatherford Indonesia), have submitted an annulment request to the District Court of South Jakarta. “For my client, the first hearing will start on 11 October. Mean while, thetwo other respondents have a different attorney. If I’m not mistaken, [they] are already in the mediation stage,” he explained.

On the other hand, when the Secretary General of BANI, N. Krisnawenda, was contacted by telephone,he refused to makeany comment. According to him, it is unethical for an arbiter to comment on the decisions of other arbiters. “Even if I were [the arbiter] who decided [the case], I would be bound by arbitration material confidentiality. I cannot make any comment,” he said. However,Krisnawenda said it is not a problem for the parties to submit the annulment. “The right [to submit anannulment]is regulated by the prevailing laws,” he asserted.

(Josephine Hadiwijaya/ Davidson Samosir)

2026 Hak Cipta Milik Hukumonline.com
Cookies Info