Freeport and Newmont Reluctant To Renegotiate

Two of the biggest mining companies in Indonesia, PT Freeport Indonesia and PT Newmont Nusa Tenggara, are reluctant to renegotiate contracts with the government. This information was provided by the Director General of Minerals and Coal inthe Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources, Thamrin Sihite, Tuesday (27/9).

 

The Government is still having difficulties trying to persuade Freeport and Newmont to renegotiate their mining contracts. But the government say they will continue their efforts to persuade both companies to renegotiate. “As mandated by the law, mining contracts should be renegotiated,” said Thamrin.

According to Thamrin, mining companies should understand the provision on minimum royalty payments in Government Regulation No. 45 of 2003 (PP) on Non-Tax State Income Tariffs, which applies to the Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources (ESDM).

 

In the PP, gold royalties are set at 3, 75 percent of the selling price multiplied by tonnage. However there is an exception for PT Freeport McMorran. The American mining company operating in Papua is only charged 1 percent of the sale price multiplied by tonnage.

Based on the ESDM Ministry data, there are currently 42 companies operating under work contracts (kontrak karya) and 72 companies operating under work agreements for coal mining companies (PKP2B). Of these companies, 65 percent have already expressed their intention to renegotiate.

 

Previously,the Coordinating Minister of Economic Affairs Hatta Rajasa said the Government will renegotiate mining contracts with all mining companies in Indonesia, without excluding Freeport.

The government plan to emphasize several obligations in the new contracts. These obligations include royalty sharing, the obligation to process minerals domestically, extension/expansion of the contracts, provision for stock divestment, and so on. Moreover, the government is aiming to include a domestic market obligation.

 

The government has often been reminded about renegotiations. For example, the Indonesian Human Rights Committe for Social Justice (IHCS), in the House of Representatives (DPR) urged the government and DPR to be brave enough to renegotiate the Freeport contract on Monday (26/9).

Secretary General of IHCS Gunawan explains, in the first Freeport work contract, the company is not obligated to pay gold royalties. But, after the government discovered that Freeport was mining gold, gold royalties were stipulated in the second work contract. Freeport is required to pay a 1 percent gold royalty. Later, the government enacted Regulation No.45 of 2003. “But it turns out this PP does not apply to Freeport,” he said.

 

Executive Director of the Indonesian Resources Studies Center (IRESS), Marwan Batubara, said that work contract renegotiation is basically to protect national and public interests. Unfortunately, mining companies who reject the renegotiation always hide behind the argument that we should respect the existing work contract until the contract period ends.

Marwan also talked about Article 169 of Law No. 4 of 2009 on Minerals and Coal Mining. Point (a) states that work contracts and work agreements for coal mining companies (PKP2B) that existed before before the law was enacted will continue to be valid until the contract or agreement ends.

 

However, Point (b) states that the provisions in the work contract and PKP2B should be adjusted within 1 year, except for adjustments related to state revenue. State revenue includes efforts to increase the state revenue. Both articles are confusing.

On the other hand, Law No. 4 of 2009 allows existing work contracts and PKP2B to remain in effect until the contract or agreement ends. While the contract is in effect, stipulations in the contract and agreement should be adjusted according to the new law.

 

Marwan explains, it is also important for the government to ask foreign mining companies to include an Indonesian government representative on their Board of Directors, during the renegotiations. “This position is important to avoid decisions that are detrimental to Indonesia,” he said.

(M Agus Yozami /Adi Condro Bawono)

Two of the biggest mining companies in Indonesia, PT Freeport Indonesia and PT Newmont Nusa Tenggara, are reluctant to renegotiate contracts with the government. This information was provided by the Director General of Minerals and Coal inthe Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources, Thamrin Sihite, Tuesday (27/9).

 

The Government is still having difficulties trying to persuade Freeport and Newmont to renegotiate their mining contracts. But the government say they will continue their efforts to persuade both companies to renegotiate. “As mandated by the law, mining contracts should be renegotiated,” said Thamrin.

According to Thamrin, mining companies should understand the provision on minimum royalty payments in Government Regulation No. 45 of 2003 (PP) on Non-Tax State Income Tariffs, which applies to the Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources (ESDM).

 

In the PP, gold royalties are set at 3, 75 percent of the selling price multiplied by tonnage. However there is an exception for PT Freeport McMorran. The American mining company operating in Papua is only charged 1 percent of the sale price multiplied by tonnage.

Based on the ESDM Ministry data, there are currently 42 companies operating under work contracts (kontrak karya) and 72 companies operating under work agreements for coal mining companies (PKP2B). Of these companies, 65 percent have already expressed their intention to renegotiate.

 

Previously,the Coordinating Minister of Economic Affairs Hatta Rajasa said the Government will renegotiate mining contracts with all mining companies in Indonesia, without excluding Freeport.

The government plan to emphasize several obligations in the new contracts. These obligations include royalty sharing, the obligation to process minerals domestically, extension/expansion of the contracts, provision for stock divestment, and so on. Moreover, the government is aiming to include a domestic market obligation.

 

The government has often been reminded about renegotiations. For example, the Indonesian Human Rights Committe for Social Justice (IHCS), in the House of Representatives (DPR) urged the government and DPR to be brave enough to renegotiate the Freeport contract on Monday (26/9).

Secretary General of IHCS Gunawan explains, in the first Freeport work contract, the company is not obligated to pay gold royalties. But, after the government discovered that Freeport was mining gold, gold royalties were stipulated in the second work contract. Freeport is required to pay a 1 percent gold royalty. Later, the government enacted Regulation No.45 of 2003. “But it turns out this PP does not apply to Freeport,” he said.

 

Executive Director of the Indonesian Resources Studies Center (IRESS), Marwan Batubara, said that work contract renegotiation is basically to protect national and public interests. Unfortunately, mining companies who reject the renegotiation always hide behind the argument that we should respect the existing work contract until the contract period ends.

Marwan also talked about Article 169 of Law No. 4 of 2009 on Minerals and Coal Mining. Point (a) states that work contracts and work agreements for coal mining companies (PKP2B) that existed before before the law was enacted will continue to be valid until the contract or agreement ends.

 

However, Point (b) states that the provisions in the work contract and PKP2B should be adjusted within 1 year, except for adjustments related to state revenue. State revenue includes efforts to increase the state revenue. Both articles are confusing.

On the other hand, Law No. 4 of 2009 allows existing work contracts and PKP2B to remain in effect until the contract or agreement ends. While the contract is in effect, stipulations in the contract and agreement should be adjusted according to the new law.

 

Marwan explains, it is also important for the government to ask foreign mining companies to include an Indonesian government representative on their Board of Directors, during the renegotiations. “This position is important to avoid decisions that are detrimental to Indonesia,” he said.

(M Agus Yozami /Adi Condro Bawono)

2026 Hak Cipta Milik Hukumonline.com
Cookies Info