All government apparatuses (Executive, Legislative or Judicial), should obey the Constructional Court (MK) decision on Law No. 18 of 2004 on Plantations. On 6 September, the MK declared Article 21, the elucidation of Article 21, and article 47 (1) and (2) of Law No. 18 of 2004 as unconstitutional.
The two articles contain legal standards that have the potential to criminalize persons interfering with plantation businesses and occupying land without a permit. According to the MK, the standard in both articles are too vague, thus, creating uncertainty.
The MK decision needs to become a reference for settling dispute or conflicts that arose in the plantation business. The President, for example,said the decision needs to be made into a new policy framework for the plantation sector. The police and prosecutor are also asked to incriminate farmers, filled by plantation companies, to stop such practices. This also goes with judges who are handling similar cases.
“Don’t use the criminalization approach any more when handling farmers and indigenous people,” said Andi Muttaqien, the lawyer who represented several farmers in the MK review of the Plantation Law.
Edi Sutrisno, from Palm Oil Watch Campaigners, explained that the criminalization of farmers and indigenous people has reach to an alarming level, especially during the establishment of palm oil plantations. Activities of farmers and indigenous people were seen as criminal acts by government apparatuses. The MK decision, according to Edi, is a gift to farmers in commemoration of the National Land Day.
Edi also asked law enforcers to not to use Article 170 of the Penal Code (KUHPidana) overzealously. As explained by the MK in their decision, indigenous people’s existence is recognized and guaranteed by the Constitution. People’s reactions are often triggered by the absence of a clear boundary between the plantation area and the lands of the indigenous people. The National Land Agency (BPN) has a role here. Article 5 of the Minister of Land Affairs/Head of BPN Regulation No. 5 of 1999 explains the need to post a cartography sign and, if possible, draw the boundaries on the land register.
Minister Regulation
Telapak, an organization concerned about indigenous people’s land issues, criticized Minister of Forestry Regulation No. P-62/MenhutII/2011. This regulation was issued by the Forestry Minister and allows palm oil plantations to be established in permanent production forest areas. Central Kalimantan has the largest levels of deforestation.
This Policy will have a large impact on the environment. “Prior to this [regulation] palm oil could only developed in areas outside permanent production forest areas and non-forestry cultivation areas,” said Abu Meridian from Telapak Campaigners.
Telapak found 97 palm oil plantation companies that operates in forest areas, where a moratorium on exploitation licenses is being implemented. Telapak estimates that there are at least 900 thousand hectares of overlapping forest areas.
The Minister of Forestry Regulation provides opportunities for deforestation, rather than protecting these forest areas. The problem is most severe in Central Kalimantan. “The Minister of Forestry Regulation has ignored the implementation of the moratorium,” said Abu Meridian in a press release.
(M. Yasin / Adi Condro Bawono)
All government apparatuses (Executive, Legislative or Judicial), should obey the Constructional Court (MK) decision on Law No. 18 of 2004 on Plantations. On 6 September, the MK declared Article 21, the elucidation of Article 21, and article 47 (1) and (2) of Law No. 18 of 2004 as unconstitutional.
The two articles contain legal standards that have the potential to criminalize persons interfering with plantation businesses and occupying land without a permit. According to the MK, the standard in both articles are too vague, thus, creating uncertainty.
The MK decision needs to become a reference for settling dispute or conflicts that arose in the plantation business. The President, for example,said the decision needs to be made into a new policy framework for the plantation sector. The police and prosecutor are also asked to incriminate farmers, filled by plantation companies, to stop such practices. This also goes with judges who are handling similar cases.
“Don’t use the criminalization approach any more when handling farmers and indigenous people,” said Andi Muttaqien, the lawyer who represented several farmers in the MK review of the Plantation Law.
Edi Sutrisno, from Palm Oil Watch Campaigners, explained that the criminalization of farmers and indigenous people has reach to an alarming level, especially during the establishment of palm oil plantations. Activities of farmers and indigenous people were seen as criminal acts by government apparatuses. The MK decision, according to Edi, is a gift to farmers in commemoration of the National Land Day.
Edi also asked law enforcers to not to use Article 170 of the Penal Code (KUHPidana) overzealously. As explained by the MK in their decision, indigenous people’s existence is recognized and guaranteed by the Constitution. People’s reactions are often triggered by the absence of a clear boundary between the plantation area and the lands of the indigenous people. The National Land Agency (BPN) has a role here. Article 5 of the Minister of Land Affairs/Head of BPN Regulation No. 5 of 1999 explains the need to post a cartography sign and, if possible, draw the boundaries on the land register.
Minister Regulation
Telapak, an organization concerned about indigenous people’s land issues, criticized Minister of Forestry Regulation No. P-62/MenhutII/2011. This regulation was issued by the Forestry Minister and allows palm oil plantations to be established in permanent production forest areas. Central Kalimantan has the largest levels of deforestation.
This Policy will have a large impact on the environment. “Prior to this [regulation] palm oil could only developed in areas outside permanent production forest areas and non-forestry cultivation areas,” said Abu Meridian from Telapak Campaigners.
Telapak found 97 palm oil plantation companies that operates in forest areas, where a moratorium on exploitation licenses is being implemented. Telapak estimates that there are at least 900 thousand hectares of overlapping forest areas.
The Minister of Forestry Regulation provides opportunities for deforestation, rather than protecting these forest areas. The problem is most severe in Central Kalimantan. “The Minister of Forestry Regulation has ignored the implementation of the moratorium,” said Abu Meridian in a press release.
(M. Yasin / Adi Condro Bawono)