The government, through the Directorate General of Taxation (Ditjen Pajak) at the Ministry of Finance, plans to conduct a tax census of corporate taxpayers at the end of September. However, Anggito Abimanyu, an economist, argues that the tax census for individual taxpayers is more important than the corporate census. Anggito expressed his view after beinga sked for input related to state revenues by Commission XI of the House of Representatives on Monday (12/9).
According to Anggito, a taxes census of individuals has more potential than the corporate census, which would beless effective at increasing tax revenues. "The inventory of individual taxpayers is more urgent. Currently [tax revenues from] individual taxpayers has huge potential, but it is untapped because many people have double income or more than one source, "he said.
Nevertheless, the former Head of Fiscal Policy (BKF), said identifying individual taxpayers will be more difficult than identifying corporate taxpayers that already use the auditing system and financial reports. Based on Directorate General of Taxation data, only 8.5 millionin dividual taxpayers submitted a tax report (SPT). Whereas the number of people actively working is 110 million people. This means that the tax reporting percentage for actively working individuals is only 7,73 percent. As for corporate taxpayers, only 466 thousand reported tax payments through tax reports, while the number of active business entities, excluding the micro-enterprises, is about 12.9 million taxpayers.
In response to Aggito’s view, the Director General of Taxation (Dirjen Pajak) Fuad Rahmany said his institution also plans to conduct a census ofindividual taxpayers. According to him, the Directorate General of Taxation has not decided which taxpayers the census will be concentrated on. However, he complained about the constraints faced by the Directorate General of Taxation, which has difficulties obtaining financial data on individual taxpayers’ owned by the banks.
“The regulation on bank secrecy issued by Bank of Indonesia is one of the obstacles to conduct an individual taxes census,” he said.
It should be noted, that the basic provisions on bank secrecy in Indonesia, are stipulated in Law No. 7 of 1992, which was amended by Law No. 10 of 1998. Article 1, paragraph 28 of Law No. 10 of 1998 states “Bank Secrecy is everything related to information about the customers and their savings”
Furthermore, Bank Indonesia Regulation No. 2/19/PBI/2000 asserted, that banks are required to keep things related to information about the depository customer and customer deposits secret. However, this beleid (regulation) states an obligation to obtain written permission or a written order from the Head of Bank Indonesia to access a bank secret.
Fuad asked for this banking regulation to be revised. According to him, there must be a clear Standard Operating Procedure (SOP) that does not complicate the tax census and prevents private individual data from beingleaked. “Obviously with the agreement that we will keep it secret, there is a protocol,” he said.
Vice Chairman of Commission IX of the House of Representatives Harry Azhar Azis agrees there should be a new regulation so the Directorate General of Taxes can access individual taxpayer data in banks. For that, he advised the Directorate General of Taxes to propose a revision to Law No. 10 of 1998 on Banking to the president.
“If the regulation is revised, then the Directorate General of Taxes can access private customer data, ” said the Functional Group politician.
(M. Agus Yozami / Adi Condro Bawono)
The government, through the Directorate General of Taxation (Ditjen Pajak) at the Ministry of Finance, plans to conduct a tax census of corporate taxpayers at the end of September. However, Anggito Abimanyu, an economist, argues that the tax census for individual taxpayers is more important than the corporate census. Anggito expressed his view after beinga sked for input related to state revenues by Commission XI of the House of Representatives on Monday (12/9).
According to Anggito, a taxes census of individuals has more potential than the corporate census, which would beless effective at increasing tax revenues. "The inventory of individual taxpayers is more urgent. Currently [tax revenues from] individual taxpayers has huge potential, but it is untapped because many people have double income or more than one source, "he said.
Nevertheless, the former Head of Fiscal Policy (BKF), said identifying individual taxpayers will be more difficult than identifying corporate taxpayers that already use the auditing system and financial reports. Based on Directorate General of Taxation data, only 8.5 millionin dividual taxpayers submitted a tax report (SPT). Whereas the number of people actively working is 110 million people. This means that the tax reporting percentage for actively working individuals is only 7,73 percent. As for corporate taxpayers, only 466 thousand reported tax payments through tax reports, while the number of active business entities, excluding the micro-enterprises, is about 12.9 million taxpayers.
In response to Aggito’s view, the Director General of Taxation (Dirjen Pajak) Fuad Rahmany said his institution also plans to conduct a census ofindividual taxpayers. According to him, the Directorate General of Taxation has not decided which taxpayers the census will be concentrated on. However, he complained about the constraints faced by the Directorate General of Taxation, which has difficulties obtaining financial data on individual taxpayers’ owned by the banks.
“The regulation on bank secrecy issued by Bank of Indonesia is one of the obstacles to conduct an individual taxes census,” he said.
It should be noted, that the basic provisions on bank secrecy in Indonesia, are stipulated in Law No. 7 of 1992, which was amended by Law No. 10 of 1998. Article 1, paragraph 28 of Law No. 10 of 1998 states “Bank Secrecy is everything related to information about the customers and their savings”
Furthermore, Bank Indonesia Regulation No. 2/19/PBI/2000 asserted, that banks are required to keep things related to information about the depository customer and customer deposits secret. However, this beleid (regulation) states an obligation to obtain written permission or a written order from the Head of Bank Indonesia to access a bank secret.
Fuad asked for this banking regulation to be revised. According to him, there must be a clear Standard Operating Procedure (SOP) that does not complicate the tax census and prevents private individual data from beingleaked. “Obviously with the agreement that we will keep it secret, there is a protocol,” he said.
Vice Chairman of Commission IX of the House of Representatives Harry Azhar Azis agrees there should be a new regulation so the Directorate General of Taxes can access individual taxpayer data in banks. For that, he advised the Directorate General of Taxes to propose a revision to Law No. 10 of 1998 on Banking to the president.
“If the regulation is revised, then the Directorate General of Taxes can access private customer data, ” said the Functional Group politician.
(M. Agus Yozami / Adi Condro Bawono)