Former Merpati President Director is Named a Suspect in the Boeing Leasing Case

 

The Attorney General’s Office (AGO) has declared two suspects in the Boeing 737-400 and 737-500 corruption case at PT Merpati Nusantara Airlines ("Merpati"). The suspects are Hotasi Nababan, former President Director of Merpati; and Guntur Aradea, the Director of Finance at Merpati.

Hotasi and Guntur are considered to be the most responsible persons in the case. So far, only Hotasi that has been reported to the Directorate General of Immigration, in order to prevent him from leaving Indonesia.

Guntur, on the other hand, is now being processed by the Deputy Attorney General for Special Crimes (Jaksa Agung Muda Tindak Pidana Khusus - Jampidsus). "It's now an administrative process," said Andhi Nirwanto, Monday (12/9).

Decree No. Kep.233/D/DSP.3/09/2011, dated 12 September 2011 and signed by the Deputy Attorney General for Intelligence, is the formal letter, which prohibits Hotasi from exiting Indonesia. According to Noor Rachmad, Head of the Legal Information Center at the AGO, the prohibition is  to aid the investigation.

Pursuant to Article 97 of Law No. 6 of 2011 on Immigration, the prohibition will be valid for six months maximum and may be extended to another six months. J Kamaru, Hotasi's legal counsel, said that his client objects to the prohibition, and will file a request to the AGO to revoke the letter.

"We will file an objection, since Hotasi's current job requires him to travel a lot," said Kamaru. He further asserted that Hotasi will not run away from the investigation or destroy evidence.

"We are ready to bring Hotasi to the investigators," Kamaru added. Kamaru, who is also Guntur's counsel, said that his client is very cooperative. "Even though Guntur is now in Ujung Pandang, he will come by Tuesday," he said.

Noor, however, explained that even though every citizen has the right to an objection, the AGO still has the authority to approve the letter.

Noor does not know the exact dates of Hotasi and Guntur's examination. Hotasi is scheduled to be examined this week, but he cannot make it. The investigator is currently re-scheduling the examination.

In mid-July, the AGO changed the status of the Merpati corruption case from an inquiry (penyelidikan) into an investigation (penyidikan). A month later, the AGO determined Hotasi and Guntur were suspects. Both are subject to Articles 2 and 3 of the Corruption Law.

The case dates back to 2006. In 2006, Merpati planned to lease two airplanes,a Boeing 737-400 and a 737-500 from Thirdstone Aircraft Leasing Group (TALG). Merpati gave TALG a USD 500 thousand security deposit for each plane.

On 18 December 2006, Merpati paid USD 1 million to TALG. However, the planes did not arrive. The planes should have been delivered to Indonesia on 5 January 2007 and 20 March 2007.

Merpati won a lawsuit against TALG. However, the AGO insisted that the state experienced a loss, amounting to IDR 10 billion. Therefore, the AGO changed the status of the case into an investigation.

According to Kamaru, Hotasi and Guntur asserted that this was a private case, not a corruption case. An American court even decided that TALG has defaulted on its obligations to Merpati. TALG was ordered by the court to pay USD 1 million to Merpati, including interest. In addition, Kamaru said the case does not meet the two elements of a corruption case: state loss and a tort.

Kamaru also explained that Merpati won a lawsuit against TALG, which covered the state's losses. There has not been a state loss, yet, since Merpati has the right to collect payment from TALG.

Regarding the to the requirement, Kamaru said the Merpati Board of Directors did not commit any tortious acts. The Ministry of State-owned Companies approved Merpati's budget for the 2006 budget year. The leasing plan was not included in the 2006 budget plan, since it was within the board of directors’ authority.

(Novrieza Rahmi / Pirhot Nababan)

 

 

The Attorney General’s Office (AGO) has declared two suspects in the Boeing 737-400 and 737-500 corruption case at PT Merpati Nusantara Airlines ("Merpati"). The suspects are Hotasi Nababan, former President Director of Merpati; and Guntur Aradea, the Director of Finance at Merpati.

Hotasi and Guntur are considered to be the most responsible persons in the case. So far, only Hotasi that has been reported to the Directorate General of Immigration, in order to prevent him from leaving Indonesia.

Guntur, on the other hand, is now being processed by the Deputy Attorney General for Special Crimes (Jaksa Agung Muda Tindak Pidana Khusus - Jampidsus). "It's now an administrative process," said Andhi Nirwanto, Monday (12/9).

Decree No. Kep.233/D/DSP.3/09/2011, dated 12 September 2011 and signed by the Deputy Attorney General for Intelligence, is the formal letter, which prohibits Hotasi from exiting Indonesia. According to Noor Rachmad, Head of the Legal Information Center at the AGO, the prohibition is  to aid the investigation.

Pursuant to Article 97 of Law No. 6 of 2011 on Immigration, the prohibition will be valid for six months maximum and may be extended to another six months. J Kamaru, Hotasi's legal counsel, said that his client objects to the prohibition, and will file a request to the AGO to revoke the letter.

"We will file an objection, since Hotasi's current job requires him to travel a lot," said Kamaru. He further asserted that Hotasi will not run away from the investigation or destroy evidence.

"We are ready to bring Hotasi to the investigators," Kamaru added. Kamaru, who is also Guntur's counsel, said that his client is very cooperative. "Even though Guntur is now in Ujung Pandang, he will come by Tuesday," he said.

Noor, however, explained that even though every citizen has the right to an objection, the AGO still has the authority to approve the letter.

Noor does not know the exact dates of Hotasi and Guntur's examination. Hotasi is scheduled to be examined this week, but he cannot make it. The investigator is currently re-scheduling the examination.

In mid-July, the AGO changed the status of the Merpati corruption case from an inquiry (penyelidikan) into an investigation (penyidikan). A month later, the AGO determined Hotasi and Guntur were suspects. Both are subject to Articles 2 and 3 of the Corruption Law.

The case dates back to 2006. In 2006, Merpati planned to lease two airplanes,a Boeing 737-400 and a 737-500 from Thirdstone Aircraft Leasing Group (TALG). Merpati gave TALG a USD 500 thousand security deposit for each plane.

On 18 December 2006, Merpati paid USD 1 million to TALG. However, the planes did not arrive. The planes should have been delivered to Indonesia on 5 January 2007 and 20 March 2007.

Merpati won a lawsuit against TALG. However, the AGO insisted that the state experienced a loss, amounting to IDR 10 billion. Therefore, the AGO changed the status of the case into an investigation.

According to Kamaru, Hotasi and Guntur asserted that this was a private case, not a corruption case. An American court even decided that TALG has defaulted on its obligations to Merpati. TALG was ordered by the court to pay USD 1 million to Merpati, including interest. In addition, Kamaru said the case does not meet the two elements of a corruption case: state loss and a tort.

Kamaru also explained that Merpati won a lawsuit against TALG, which covered the state's losses. There has not been a state loss, yet, since Merpati has the right to collect payment from TALG.

Regarding the to the requirement, Kamaru said the Merpati Board of Directors did not commit any tortious acts. The Ministry of State-owned Companies approved Merpati's budget for the 2006 budget year. The leasing plan was not included in the 2006 budget plan, since it was within the board of directors’ authority.

(Novrieza Rahmi / Pirhot Nababan)

 

2026 Hak Cipta Milik Hukumonline.com
Cookies Info