Bank Indonesia is still reviewing restrictions on foreign ownership of
banks in Indonesia. BI Governor Nasution, confirmed that restrictions
on bank majority stakeholders will directed for a long term. The central bank
believes that the policy does not create uncertainty for foreign
investors who will acquire a local bank.
Nasution regretted the misunderstandings regarding the restrictions on
foreign ownership in local banks. According to him, BI has not
regulated this issue yet. "There should be no confusion about this
issue, because we have not implemented the regulation yet. It is still
being assessed," he said in Parliament on Thursday (8/9).
The Former Director General of Taxation explained that a long-term
policy on foreign ownership restrictions in local backs is necessary.
This, he said, is so regulations do not create uncertainty for foreign
investors who want to invest in a national bank. This means, that BI
will continue to grant foreign banks permission to acquire local banks
this year.
Darmin’s statement disregards the statement of the Director of Licensing
and Banking Information, Jono Swastanto, made on Thursday (11/8).
According to Jono, the central bank will not grant foreign investors
permission to acquire local banks until the end of 2011. The
moratorium on bank acquisitions will be applied until a
regulation on ownership restrictions is officially implemented.
Chairman of the Capital Investment Coordinating Board, Gita Wirjawan,
previously warned that measures limiting foreign ownership in banking
may interfere with the domestic investment climate. According to her,
regulations cannot be rushed.
The foreign ownership topic re-surfaced after local bankers complained
about the difficulty of opening a branch abroad due to a lack of
equality principles with foreign banks that open branches in
Indonesia. Chairman of State-Owned Banks (Himbara) Gatot M Suwondo
requested the Parliament and the central bank to issue reciprocal
regulations between foreign banks that wishes to operate in Indonesia, and
towards Indonesian banks that are planning to expand their services overseas.
“BI and Parliament may establish reciprocal regulations. The issue at
hand is, it is very difficult for Indonesian Banks to open branches
overseas, but it is easy for foreign banks to open branches in
Indonesia.” Gatot said during a hearing with the Parliament Commission
XI, last May.
Minister of Finance Agus Martowardojo must have heard of these
complaints. He asked Bank Indonesia and the Capital Market and
Financial Institution Supervisory Agency (Bapepam-LK) to encourage
banks to reduce foreign ownership. According to him, the position of
the national banking industry is the opposite of the banking situation
in neighboring countries.
Agus said the Indonesian banking industry is quite open if compared
to other Asian countries. In addition to opening branches, foreign
investors can freely buy shares of banks in the country. Ironically,
there are some regulations that national banks must follow if they
want to open branches abroad. National banks are subject to the
multiple license system and restrictions on opening branches outside
their state capital.
To protect the domestic banking industry, the Minister of Finance
determined that public ownership of shares should be encouraged so the
industry could be easily monitored. "In Indonesia, once they [ed.foreign
banks] enter, they can immediately open branches in Jakarta, Medan, Surabaya,
and elsewhere. But in their country, Indonesian Banks have
difficulties opening branches, "said the former CEO of Bank Mandiri.
As widely known, majority ownership by foreign investors in domestic banks
is regulated by Law No. 10 of 1998 on Banking, The 1998 Banking law
allows foreign ownership of local banks up to 99 percent. This is
also made clear in Article 3 of Government Regulation No 29 of 2009 on
the Purchase of Commercial Bank Shares. This policy was established during the
Indonesian economic crisis and is a condition of the Letter of Intent
(LoI) agreement with the International Monetary Fund (IMF).
In response to the anticipated foreign ownership changes, some
investors have begun reviewing their expansion plans in Indonesia.
Banks in Malaysia also reportedly began to distance themselves from
Indonesia. These banks include RHB Capital Bhd (RHB Cap) and Affin
Holdings Bhd. RHB Cap previously intended to buy PT Bank Mestika
Dharma, while Affin wanted to buy PT Bank Ina Perdana.
To put the situation in perspective, a number of Malaysian banks
currently control banks in Indonesia, such as Malayan Banking Bhd.,
which has a 95 percent stake in PT Bank Internasional Indonesia (BII)
and CIMB Group Holdings Bhd, which has a 96 percent stake in PT Bank
CIMB Niaga Tbk. Operations in Indonesia are considered to provide
considerable profits.
(M Agus Yozami / Adi Condro Bawono)
Bank Indonesia is still reviewing restrictions on foreign ownership of
banks in Indonesia. BI Governor Nasution, confirmed that restrictions
on bank majority stakeholders will directed for a long term. The central bank
believes that the policy does not create uncertainty for foreign
investors who will acquire a local bank.
Nasution regretted the misunderstandings regarding the restrictions on
foreign ownership in local banks. According to him, BI has not
regulated this issue yet. "There should be no confusion about this
issue, because we have not implemented the regulation yet. It is still
being assessed," he said in Parliament on Thursday (8/9).
The Former Director General of Taxation explained that a long-term
policy on foreign ownership restrictions in local backs is necessary.
This, he said, is so regulations do not create uncertainty for foreign
investors who want to invest in a national bank. This means, that BI
will continue to grant foreign banks permission to acquire local banks
this year.
Darmin’s statement disregards the statement of the Director of Licensing
and Banking Information, Jono Swastanto, made on Thursday (11/8).
According to Jono, the central bank will not grant foreign investors
permission to acquire local banks until the end of 2011. The
moratorium on bank acquisitions will be applied until a
regulation on ownership restrictions is officially implemented.
Chairman of the Capital Investment Coordinating Board, Gita Wirjawan,
previously warned that measures limiting foreign ownership in banking
may interfere with the domestic investment climate. According to her,
regulations cannot be rushed.
The foreign ownership topic re-surfaced after local bankers complained
about the difficulty of opening a branch abroad due to a lack of
equality principles with foreign banks that open branches in
Indonesia. Chairman of State-Owned Banks (Himbara) Gatot M Suwondo
requested the Parliament and the central bank to issue reciprocal
regulations between foreign banks that wishes to operate in Indonesia, and
towards Indonesian banks that are planning to expand their services overseas.
“BI and Parliament may establish reciprocal regulations. The issue at
hand is, it is very difficult for Indonesian Banks to open branches
overseas, but it is easy for foreign banks to open branches in
Indonesia.” Gatot said during a hearing with the Parliament Commission
XI, last May.
Minister of Finance Agus Martowardojo must have heard of these
complaints. He asked Bank Indonesia and the Capital Market and
Financial Institution Supervisory Agency (Bapepam-LK) to encourage
banks to reduce foreign ownership. According to him, the position of
the national banking industry is the opposite of the banking situation
in neighboring countries.
Agus said the Indonesian banking industry is quite open if compared
to other Asian countries. In addition to opening branches, foreign
investors can freely buy shares of banks in the country. Ironically,
there are some regulations that national banks must follow if they
want to open branches abroad. National banks are subject to the
multiple license system and restrictions on opening branches outside
their state capital.
To protect the domestic banking industry, the Minister of Finance
determined that public ownership of shares should be encouraged so the
industry could be easily monitored. "In Indonesia, once they [ed.foreign
banks] enter, they can immediately open branches in Jakarta, Medan, Surabaya,
and elsewhere. But in their country, Indonesian Banks have
difficulties opening branches, "said the former CEO of Bank Mandiri.
As widely known, majority ownership by foreign investors in domestic banks
is regulated by Law No. 10 of 1998 on Banking, The 1998 Banking law
allows foreign ownership of local banks up to 99 percent. This is
also made clear in Article 3 of Government Regulation No 29 of 2009 on
the Purchase of Commercial Bank Shares. This policy was established during the
Indonesian economic crisis and is a condition of the Letter of Intent
(LoI) agreement with the International Monetary Fund (IMF).
In response to the anticipated foreign ownership changes, some
investors have begun reviewing their expansion plans in Indonesia.
Banks in Malaysia also reportedly began to distance themselves from
Indonesia. These banks include RHB Capital Bhd (RHB Cap) and Affin
Holdings Bhd. RHB Cap previously intended to buy PT Bank Mestika
Dharma, while Affin wanted to buy PT Bank Ina Perdana.
To put the situation in perspective, a number of Malaysian banks
currently control banks in Indonesia, such as Malayan Banking Bhd.,
which has a 95 percent stake in PT Bank Internasional Indonesia (BII)
and CIMB Group Holdings Bhd, which has a 96 percent stake in PT Bank
CIMB Niaga Tbk. Operations in Indonesia are considered to provide
considerable profits.
(M Agus Yozami / Adi Condro Bawono)